She's knows for sure, but most likely only the version of "They had sex and Haley initiated it", not the real version. That's why she talked about her bad choices before and bad taste, and asked if there's someone else in the city, maybe an older guy. There was clearly a resentment towards it, and that comes from the false version of the events. Most likely her dad knows the same wrong version as well.So some here believe that's the reason why she treats her like that. If that's the case why wouldn't she do something knowing something horrible happened to her daughter?
Last edited: