You're kidding, right? At four stars, this game, is vastly over-rated, and no, it's got nothing to do with the rape. What it does have to do with is the swap to defined 'solo Haley' and 'Haley and Sandra' paths, leaving the single pathing players with half the game they're used to, and much worse than that, it's been a buggy, save breaking, and non-proofread mess since then. Least we forget as well that last update we went back to the awful nighttime renders where we can barely see the characters again after finally getting away from that after so long.
We can argue until we're blue in the face about this being an "underappreciated" game, seeing as that's completely subjective, but calling this "underrated" when this game has been objectively a hot mess (at best) for four or five months now is hilarious.