The MC is already helping her get to grips with her past. So for Haley there is not much incentive to keep Sandra around if Haley was not into her. For a simple beard, Sandra is too involved and any of the other girls would be a better choice from Haley's perspective.
That is precisely why I broke it of with her.
"a
ny of the other girls would be a better choice from Haley's perspective."
None of them have the same emotional attachment to the MC as Sandra. So without Sandra, they can have a "normal" relationship. (As normal as an incestual relationship can be..
![Laugh :LOL: :LOL:]()
) I'm not a Sandra hater. In fact I look forward to playing the three-way path with her when I'm done with the single Haley path.
But I just differ on concluding that the three way is the best path. Look at what each character really wants.
1) Sandra wants a relationship with the MC.
2) Haley wants a relationship with MC
3) My MC wants a relationship with Haley, although he has soft spot for Sandra.
So for all three of them, a three-way is a compromise. So I did the right thing IMO and set Sandra free, so MC and Haley can go down in flames together, without taking anybody down with them.
I fully understand that point 3 can be different for different people
3) For Avaron: Her MC likes Sandra more and keeps Haley on due to obligation and hoping for the best.
or
3) You and other: Wants a relationship with both. The question becomes do you love both equally?
In all these cases, there is compromise in the three way. Maybe in your case, it's less, but it's still there.
For a three-way to work. Jealousy needs to be kept down to a minimum and the status of each person in the relationship needs to be roughly equal. For that to happen, as Avaron said, the girls need to develop a proper relationship. I'm not sure if a) I want that or b) the girls want that. (Sandra does not know about any of this and for Haley, the ends justify the means. It's a gamble for everything to pay of on the long run) There is definitely no love between them when the relationship starts of. Haley is the puppet master trying to get everything to work out. The MC is just going along with Haley.
So long story short. I prefer the MC and Haley to work this thing out on their own naturaly, without Haley trying to control everything.
Food for though:
Contrast this with the three way in Alexandra. Both the two females are fully committed in their relationship. The MC in that game fell for one of the girls. But to move forward, he had to accept her GF and she had to except him. Both knew they had to accept each other to move forward. That one worked for me, because everyone after that is on a complete equal footing.