- Dec 27, 2017
- 5,714
- 19,722
What if:
1) Klaus was not the only one to have haley when she was at school.
2) When father and haley get to "her place" father makes a play for haley, (be it successful or not), I think he is aware of MC and haleys relationship (or at least suspicious) and maybe a little bit jealous.
Haley does call MC daddy during sex.
Then you would be playing some other game, not this one. What you suggest will never happen in this game: not in any route; not in any epilogue.Forgot that about the story.......but could she be lying, perhaps.
I'm not trying to be dismissive of your idea in general. In some other game it would work just fine - just not in this one. These developers have no history of doing anything remotely similar, and the way this game has unfolded just doesn't support that kind of plot line.
Haley calls the MC 'Daddy' because of her insecurity.
Dad is VERY concerned about the relationship between Haley and the MC. During one of the trips back home he has a conversation with the MC, "Can't help but notice, that you came from your old room... Where Haley was sleeping. It was cute you know. When you were little. You were never apart. But now. Now, it's not so cute anymore." Given that Dad also knows that Haley is undergoing therapy and no one will tell him why, you can be damned sure he is concerned and suspicious, especially in the Haley Solo route, where there is no girlfriend for the MC.