Except there is no actual choice right now besides the club scene. Which locks people out of seeing content for one of them. It is too innocuous and many people, if not using a walkthrough, won't understand that by making that choice they've locked themselves onto one path or the other. If, for example, there was a scene where the MC was hanging out with one of them, received a call from the other, and then made a choice to stay or leave that would be more obvious and understandable as a "lock out" moment. When I first played that scene I went with Layla, not because I didn't want to talk to Erynn, because I wanted to "roleplay" the MC and I'd want to see that my friends got home safe. Of course, I also replayed to see the scenes with Erynn too. I now know that choice essentially locks one of the love interests paths but a lot of people won't when they first play that scene.
The "squee" scene with Layla would still make sense for the player to see, even if the player/MC isn't actively pursuing her so that we can see that she is excited by the MC, seeing the Erynn kiss moment would also be logical to see, because she doesn't know that the MC has already decided to pursue Layla. Neither of them should be "just friends" in their minds or actions, only the MC and player know which one of them is going to be "friendzoned". If the scenes can both be seen regardless of who the MC is going to actively pursue then it makes the eventual decision more difficult. If the point threshold is too high to see either than players will miss out on character and relationship building (and conflict building) moments.
I don't want a game just like any other game on this site, I love THIS game. However, I also feel that at this point the player can't change their mind, or even know that they made up their mind, about who they will pursue because the scenes that would sway them are not available.
