I will quibble about the affair bit... We don't conclusively know that Andres had an affair, unless Nyx changed that scene in her 5.5 update. Otherwise I agree with everything being said about Emily, Erynn, etc.You would think so but look at all the hate Erynn gets...what has she done? Hardly any hate for Andres? Yet he instigated the secret...has had an affair...moved the MC around (and sprung suprises on him), assaulted him (depending on path)..yet he a sound fella.
People...heh...never understand em.
I don't know why people are so against any character at this point. No one has done anything that makes them unredeemable, it all comes down to how Nyx writes them. Emily made a promise to Andres not to tell their son who the bio-dad was... And Andres is still the MC's father, he raised him, he put in all the work that has made MC the man he is... More than anyone else at this point.
Emily has probably regretted sending her son away since she made the decision and the MC left. The MC was being a douche canoe and not explaining to anyone why he was acting out. She did what she thought was best but has missed her son terribly ever since. Now she thinks she's completely destroyed their relationship.
IMO everyone deserves a second chance, the MC receives second chances, why shouldn't he extend the same to his own mom? Yes, she kept a secret from him, but she did it at the request of her ex-husband/former love of her life... I think that's a reasonable person to keep secrets for when all is said and done. The way she told him was terrible and I would definitely poke fun at my mom for her delivery and timing... But if the MC is going to cut people out of his life for keeping secrets then he is going to be very lonely since everyone seems to have kept secrets from him - Erynn, Lexi, Layla, Mel, Emily, Andres... Give Nyx time perhaps at the end the MC will be a homeless bum who lives on the beach.