If i had my way we would have both.Why not simply write an upcoming scene where a fuckboy MC who has been dating both, gets found out and confronted?
This is what I thought we were building to all along, not that Nyx had simply "forgotten" that you can date them both without consequence.
One clear option to chose Layla or Erynn(but not right after meeting them).
And the option to string both girls along until things go nuclear.
To be honest Erynn not sharing much with Alexis doesn't sound that unbelievable when Erynn never told her about Ethan, and Alexis also hid some things from Erynn...
She repeatedly denies having a relationship to her mom (despite the fact that Melissa knows and encourages it).
Erynn 100% falls into the a "i don't wanna jinx it" type person rather than a oversharer.