It's not just his eyes. That narrow chin with the wide jawline and feminine lips... Yeah, all added together, that's a whole lot of uncanny valley for me. I mean, look at the gigachad memes. He's also got a wide jawline. But that fits with the rest of his features. So, although exaggerated, he still looks fine.
Anyway, it's just how I see it. And I wasn't really making a serious statement, just having a little fun. So you don't really have to care about it. After all, someone else might find those proportions attractive.
As they say, it's not the appearance, but what's inside that matters, even though it's all blood, guts, and bones.