So I've played my first blind playthrough of the game. It broke my heart. Although I liked all the girls I ended up picking CeCe in the LA mansion. This just ended up making the game more heartbreaking, but I remain convinced that it was the right decision despite everything that happened. I can't argue that CeCe is the best girl, but she is the heart and soul of the game. It broke my heart, sure, but for a first playthrough, it made for a hell of a ride. The only problem is that now I don't want to do any of the other playthroughs just to get the scenes. I feel like I got the right one for me. This might be the mark of a great game or just my own stubbornness.