Actually, you were right and should have followed your instincts. When this game was first posted, AG got a lot of complaints from the non-NTR people. I do not like NTR games and when I saw the comments, I checked out AG's Patreon page. Since his goal was modest, I remained silent because I knew that he could eventually reach his goal even with an NTR game. About a week later he updated with the non-NTR option. He had few supporters so I signed up for a buck a month without having played the game. I encouraged (or maybe tried to shame) all those who asked for the non-NTR path to chip in a least a buck. I don't know that anyone really listened. AG might have been right about most of his current supporters being NTR fans since this was basically an NTR game with content that could be avoided. There was not a non-NTR path just an avoidable scene.
I used to think that financially it made sense to have an NTR path and a non-NTR path; you would get both sides supporting you. I no longer believe that is true. Non-NTR games make more money than NTR games, that is why there are so many more non-NTR games than NTR games. Games that have both paths seem to fall somewhere between the two. Some evidence: games that start out as NTR and add the non-NTR path get an immediate jump in sponsorship. If I remember correctly, it happened with this story. However, a game that has both paths never seems to achieve the success of solely non-NTR games. There is a certain amount of logic to it. If you are trying to do both paths, you either end up the an NTR game with some scenes that you can skip or have two separate paths which mean you update less often or with less content. Any of those options hurt you financially.
At one point I was willing to consider increasing my level of support, but ended up cancelling it altogether when you failed to meet your stated release date. I understood that there were some issues going on, but there was no posted explanation when the stated dated came and went. I asked about the update and got no response. I might have resigned when the update finally arrived but it turned out to be an NTR update with avoidable scenes. I kind of lost interest once the non-NTR update finally arrived.