dirtythiccboi

Member
Aug 7, 2019
125
419
So what, it's been like 4-6 months now after waiting a full year for a single half-assed update? Of course he still has patreon support. Yawn.
 

fried

Almost
Donor
Respected User
Former Staff
Nov 11, 2017
2,313
6,103
you can't separate "the game" from "the developer" - - that would be like making a thread about "The Chicago Bulls" and getting mad about someone constantly talking about "Michael Jordan" - no, just no

there is nothing wrong with making a "thread about a game" but then also talking about "the person who made the game" as well, no, i just can't

there is no way to justify what you said
Perhaps this will help make it more clear: there is typically a point after which complaints about the Dev and their purported lifestyle, their patrons and assumed levels of intelligence, etc. have nothing to do with the game, anymore - i.e., when it resembles an echo chamber of roundtable ranting about perceived injustices against the gaming universe. Even if you believe your ire supported by logic and facts, when such a point is reached then the thread may no longer be able to reasonably sustain fair participation under the General Rules.

As redknight00 aluded to: these topics are about a game's qualities/meanings/genre/fandom and its production (which includes the Dev team to a certain extent), rather than creative pilloring of the Developer's private life, pontificating about the motivations of their patrons, etc. An example of off-topic in this thread would be concentrating on the latter aspects almost uniquely and dialing that up to 11.

And this applies equally to every thread outside of Off-topic at the site, of course.
 

1tomadeira

Engaged Member
May 25, 2017
3,455
10,557
Any place that is not a game thread.
With all due respect, that reasoning is "meh".

I'm all against hate comments and completly agree those people must be punished. But forbidding discussion about the game releases? That doesn't make any sense at all.

I didn't want to comment to avoid the derail on the thread, but that reasoning completly doesn't make any sense at all. This I reinforce, without counting hatred towards the dev. I understand that kind of behaviour is hard to control.

About the game itself I'm sad it ended like this. It sucks when promising games are left incomplete, specially if we know the dev won't produce more afterwards. Also I hope everything is fine with the dev, from what I remember he had a pretty bad burnout (correct me if I'm wrong please), and his earlier games were always fun to play.
 

EclipseTheStars

Active Member
Aug 18, 2019
554
2,426
Perhaps this will help make it more clear: there is typically a point after which complaints about the Dev and their purported lifestyle, their patrons and assumed levels of intelligence, etc. have nothing to do with the game, anymore - i.e., when it resembles an echo chamber of roundtable ranting about perceived injustices against the gaming universe. Even if you believe your ire supported by logic and facts, when such a point is reached then the thread may no longer be able to reasonably sustain fair participation under the General Rules.

As redknight00 aluded to: these topics are about a game's qualities/meanings/genre/fandom and its production (which includes the Dev team to a certain extent), rather than creative pilloring of the Developer's private life, pontificating about the motivations of their patrons, etc. An example of off-topic in this thread would be concentrating on the latter aspects almost uniquely and dialing that up to 11.

And this applies equally to every thread outside of Off-topic at the site, of course.
this is a response i can respect, and almost entirely agree with

as someone who is NOT A MOD (i do have my bad days) i would suggest that those who ARE MODS dictate "when" the over-all environment of a thread completely de-rails into "just curb stomping" - - however, there are going to be times, like recently when ICSTOR released that last (come on, that's pretty controversial) patreon post, that people are going to cry out, especially when he is censoring them on his official pages

a few months ago Waifu Academy got very toxic, and so it was muted/closed for a few days, and that helped mildly, that might be a better course of action rather than having a mod start issuing a bunch of bans and/or going "to war" against the populace in here, as, even if they did make a good point, the mob gonna mob, but i liked what you said, so i decided to reply as such in return, not that we're talking about world justice or anything

but porn is a hobby too, nothing wrong with that, people get excited over less, - - that being said, i vote to keep "dev/release time" bashing to a max of one full page a day, because as pointed out prior, there are new players that are having the time of their lives NOT waiting for the next release...at least...not yet
 

Bruce_Wayne18

Member
Mar 14, 2018
294
681
The thread is already a dumpster fire by ICSTOR's own doing. The mods running around deleting every comment 'cause it doesn't belong in the game thread' must be EXHAUSTING. So, why not just let it burn as a warning to people who just discovered the game and they might make the mistake of supporting him on Patreon?
 

Bruce_Wayne18

Member
Mar 14, 2018
294
681
In no way am i excusing the hateful comments, but to tell me i can't address the developer in the thread of the game they made is ridiculous. It defeats the whole purpose of having a place for discussion.
It's contradicting with what the mods ACTUALLY do.

Comments praising the developer aren't deleted and by the mods behavior, one could say they are even encouraged at some level.

But God forbid someone says something negative! Call the shill brigade to delete all comments.

You can't have it both ways.

IMO devs and games are interconnected. You can't have discussion about the one without the other, negative or positive.

Granted though, I understand that not everyone can keep the discussion civil on the internet so that's the only thing that makes me understand the mods position. For scummy developers though like Gumdrop Games and sadly now ICSTOR, the mods can't be policing the forums and deleting comments all the time. People are pissed off at the devs behavior and the mods deleting comments is just pissing people off further.
 
Last edited:

Real Deggy

Member
May 27, 2020
111
175
It's contradicting with what the mods ACTUALLY do.

Comments praising the developer aren't deleted and by the mods behavior, one could say they are even encouraged at some level.

But God forbid someone says something negative! Call the shill brigade to delete all comments.

You can't have it both ways.

IMO devs and games are interconnected. You can't have discussion about the one without the other, negative or positive.

Granted though, I understand that not everyone can keep the discussion civil on the internet so that's the only thing that makes me understand the mods position. For scummy developers though like Gumdrop Games and sadly now ICSTOR, they can't be policing the forums cause what they are doing is so bad, it's gonna go to hell anw.
Exactly what I was thinking, it seems to only be "off-topic" when what is shared is negative. Personal attacks are too far, i can't dispute that. But bringing up ICSTORS name in a negative light should not be off-topic unless praising him is deemed so as well. I'm kind of astonished a moderator would tell anyone they basically can't speak the devs name in their games thread.
 

Badjourasmix

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 22, 2017
7,264
16,404
For those who have not understood: ICSTOR is milking its fat cows to get as much as it can do, of course it is unscrupulous and greedy. But let me tell you, as a developer he is tremendously good.
That is actually the saddest part. You look at the game and it has such a huge potential, but the dev just gives up on it.
 

Badjourasmix

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 22, 2017
7,264
16,404
Dev fatigue, see TITS. It makes 30k a month on patreon but the main dev just has been doing this work for too long that it's a chore and a headache to his current life.
Dev fatigue seems like a very poor excuse, the game has been in development for over 2 years, and he released like 8 updates with new content in that time. And he hasn't even released an update in a year now.
 

Real Deggy

Member
May 27, 2020
111
175
They're all pretty much carbon copies of each other. It's a shame cause they have decent quality. I had a lot of hopes for Milfy City when I found it. That was before I started looking through this thread.
Yeah but even those games never really had a proper ending he just gets bored and rushes the endings. His problem is that he can't commit to anything until the end
Really is a pattern at this point.
i
Honestly I feel like that's the majority of adult games I've played. Can't remember the last time an ending wasn't just a rushed last screen threesome or one still image of your pregnant love interest.
Good point, as much hate as ICSTOR gets his case isn't really that special when it comes to rushed endings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lookoverthere
3.80 star(s) 445 Votes