Unity Abandoned Monster Girl Island [v0.44.3] [Redamz]

[HumanRug]

I wouldn't be surprised if he contacts all those devs/modders people and threatens them.

Threaten with what? Telling them that if they work in the game it'll get completed? That if they work on the game he'll lose his followers?
No, wait, nevermind the latter. They're so deep infatuated with him that abandoning his side would be an impossible task for them to perform.

 

[DeccuSkurabu]

I always come in here looking to reply or clarify something. But never do, Last time I tried to my post got deleted. Lets try this again tho. I frequent this board and site but lurk, I'm a admin on the MGI discord and friends with Red. If there's anything I can clarify or if you all want to know please ask. Lots a' shit here is plain wrong. I can also understand the hate flung his way here despite being his friend, not saying I agree. 100% honesty whatever i can tell you guys i will.

 

[Kitsune241]

I always come in here looking to reply or clarify something. But never do, Last time I tried to my post got deleted. Lets try this again tho. I frequent this board and site but lurk, I'm a admin on the MGI discord and friends with Red. If there's anything I can clarify or if you all want to know please ask. Lots a' shit here is plain wrong. I can also understand the hate flung his way here despite being his friend, not saying I agree. 100% honesty whatever i can tell you guys i will.

Honestly, unless you have access to and permission to post previews that Redamz himself hasn't shared, just save yourself the trouble.
There's not much you could say that wouldn't just sound like an empty promise at this point. Words are cheap and until Redamz actually releases something not many people are going to trust anything he or his friends say.

 

[DeccuSkurabu]

Honestly, unless you have access to and permission to post previews that Redamz himself hasn't shared, just save yourself the trouble.
There's not much you could say that wouldn't just sound like an empty promise at this point. Words are cheap and until Redamz actually releases something not many people are going to trust anything he or his friends say.

Permission to post? no. 1. I don't want legal trouble over something like that so don't expect it from anyone but Red. 2. I really wouldn't want to throw away trust like that for no reason.
Do i have insight into what's been worked on that people haven't seen , reasoning for a lot of the shit people question, and clarifications to the endless amount of inaccuracies posted here? yes.
Not trying to be hostile, in my post I just want to clear some things up and hopefully help some people move past this.
If you're expecting me to tell you if characters have more scenes or what new characters are coming down the line I do have the answers to most of that, but I'm not going to share it for reasons stated above.
If you want to know what to expect in the future if anything at all, or what actually happened with patreon I can 100% answer that.

 

[DR is The Man]

If there's anything I can clarify or if you all want to know please ask. Lots a' shit here is plain wrong.

Lurker coming outta the fog just to ask what are the things that are "plain wrong" in this thread?

 

[DeccuSkurabu]

Lurker coming outta the fog just to ask what are the things that are "plain wrong" in this thread?

The closing of the patreon is one that always drives me absolutely insane. Having talked to him while it was happening i can say 90% of the time when it's discussed here it's wrong as hell. He closed it because they asked him to remove what they classified as "incest" (Halloween build with Ara and Faranne), After discussing they weren't willing to budge so he closed it down. After a bit they asked him to come back, but he was already done and they still wanted him to remove said content (Imo most of it was being stubborn about it) also the "patreon under review" thing people saw is what just happens to inactive patreon pages.
The Patreon was mostly active until the end. I won't comment on people saying shit like "milking it" and so forth as I am 100% biased. But even to this day he is still working on content i would say is atleast related.

 

[DocRipper]

The closing of the patreon is one that always drives me absolutely insane. Having talked to him while it was happening i can say 90% of the time when it's discussed here it's wrong as hell. He closed it because they asked him to remove what they classified as "incest" (Halloween build with Ara and Faranne), After discussing they weren't willing to budge so he closed it down. After a bit they asked him to come back, but he was already done and they still wanted him to remove said content (Imo most of it was being stubborn about it) also the "patreon under review" thing people saw is what just happens to inactive patreon pages.
The Patreon was mostly active until the end. I won't comment on people saying shit like "milking it" and so forth as I am 100% biased. But even to this day he is still working on content i would say is atleast related.

We know this ... No big secret, some of us remember it. Rather, it's Timeline after "Patreon-incident".
Why arrogance on all sides? Why Red act like a madman and posted nonsense? Why betrayal? Why not another platform like SS where there were no restrictions? Most people were ready to leave Patreon and follow Red somewhere else. Everyone realized that the rules were tightening and a lot of projects would disappear from Patreon..


PS: anonamon did an interesting piece of work, right?

 

[DR is The Man]

The closing of the patreon is one that always drives me absolutely insane.

So outta the whole thread that is the most "plain wrong" thing?

But even to this day he is still working on content i would say is atleast related.

The thing about this is that besides the extremely rare shallow updates that Red only posts on the discord server, not much is ever shown or truly talked about what he is working on for the game. The update that Red gave that insinuated that he has no longer had an interest in porn games and that it is bothersome to animate sex sequences so there will be no more kinda conflicts with the games original promise and leaves people with doubts that he will try to finish at all.

 

[DeccuSkurabu]

We know this ... No big secret

Im sure there were more factors at play at the time. I cant speak for him on that but i know some stuff in his life did happen and that's around the time updates ceased. I've always asked him to be more clear with his followers or people who cared, but he has a very nonchalant take on it all. I think he also just wanted more freedom on what direction to take the game in.

The update that Red gave that insinuated that he has no longer had an interest porn games and that it is bothersome to animate sex sequences so there will be no more kinda conflicts with the games original promise and leaves people with doubts that he will try to finish at all.

So deal is, I dont think he's ever been into porn content in games, In our friend group 3/4 of us play porn games in general, 2/4 of us play them alot, and only he is indifferent. I remember him saying a real long time ago that he didnt really want to make porn games to begin with? don't quote me on that one.

Now as for finishing the game, People tend to gloss over this a lot, but MGI is done as in whatever comes after will have no porn unless some crazy shit happens and Red changes his mind. I don't know why he wants to continue it in that way but hey that's his prerogative. That also clarifies what he meant when he said the game is done.

 

[snek774411]

Im sure there were more factors at play at the time. I cant speak for him on that but i know some stuff in his life did happen and that's around the time updates ceased. I've always asked him to be more clear with his followers or people who cared, but he has a very nonchalant take on it all. I think he also just wanted more freedom on what direction to take the game in.

Well that sucks a bit that he doesn't want to be more clear on it. Like good comunications is the best thing for a developer but it's his life.

So deal is, I dont think he's ever been into porn content in games, In our friend group 3/4 of us play porn games in general, 2/4 of us play them alot, and only he is indifferent. I remember him saying a real long time ago that he didnt really want to make porn games to begin with? don't quote me on that one.

Now as for finishing the game, People tend to gloss over this a lot, but MGI is done as in whatever comes after will have no porn unless some crazy shit happens and Red changes his mind. I don't know why he wants to continue it in that way but hey that's his prerogative. That also clarifies what he meant when he said the game is done.

So why make a porn game? Like From the start there was porn but suddenly he doesn't want it? Also in chapter 4 2 scenes are still missing so it can't be a finished game right? How is going to be the structure of the next game since most people wanted more sex scenes with their favorite girls but with what you sayd I don't think it will end well.

 

[lololaut]

Im sure there were more factors at play at the time. I cant speak for him on that but i know some stuff in his life did happen and that's around the time updates ceased. I've always asked him to be more clear with his followers or people who cared, but he has a very nonchalant take on it all. I think he also just wanted more freedom on what direction to take the game in.



So deal is, I dont think he's ever been into porn content in games, In our friend group 3/4 of us play porn games in general, 2/4 of us play them alot, and only he is indifferent. I remember him saying a real long time ago that he didnt really want to make porn games to begin with? don't quote me on that one.

Now as for finishing the game, People tend to gloss over this a lot, but MGI is done as in whatever comes after will have no porn unless some crazy shit happens and Red changes his mind. I don't know why he wants to continue it in that way but hey that's his prerogative. That also clarifies what he meant when he said the game is done.

just one question - why he keep the wall by only saying one a year "the game is still in dev".

i mean, if people payed money untill the closer of Patreon, a little obligated to show something, just a little bit it's the minimum, i mean, he started in what? 2015-2016 making the game? after 7+ year something out should have come, if not the completed game, something?

with this i don't want to down play the dev of a game, but if people paid me money to make a game it should be my 1st priority to keep in contact and alive, other then reassure that the game is coming alone and sometimes some photo/video to show, this one thing is not hard at all.
linking to "people paid money" it should be mandatory, even if you don't care or don't want to.
look to other games Discord, the dev and team are chatting and interacting with everyone (even the one who didn't paid a dime).

i think nobody forced him to make a game and start Patreon, but that action brings consequence.

 

[Absolute Zero]

Now as for finishing the game, People tend to gloss over this a lot, but MGI is done as in whatever comes after will have no porn unless some crazy shit happens and Red changes his mind. I don't know why he wants to continue it in that way but hey that's his prerogative. That also clarifies what he meant when he said the game is done.

Honestly speaking, there’s no point in Red continuing the game/story if the porn aspect will not be included. The overwhelming majority of people that got interested/started playing MGI was solely because they wanted to bang monster girls. No offense but MGI is not an IP that can be carried solely on its storytelling, world building, characters, etc… alone.

While I can empathize with his decision to no longer continue working on it (at least as an eroge game), I’ve lost all respect in him for not fulfilling what was originally promised.

Anyways, I appreciate the clarification.

 

[lololaut]

Honestly speaking, there’s no point in Red continuing the game/story if the porn aspect will not be included. The overwhelming majority of people that got interested/started playing MGI was solely because they wanted to bang monster girls. No offense but MGI is not an IP that can be carried solely on its storytelling, world building, characters, etc… alone.

While I can empathize with his decision to no longer continue working on it (at least as an eroge game), I’ve lost all respect in him for not fulfilling what was originally promised.

Anyways, I appreciate the clarification.

that make me think without doubt that he use the chance of closing Patreon to stop the porn game, and focus on the "story"... i fully agree with you, i mean, the story was good to be a porn game, not to be a standalone game.

basically RED is scammer, he took the money to do a thing and when he got bored, he just 360° the scope of the game without thinking twice....thankfully internet never forget

 

[snek774411]

Honestly speaking, there’s no point in Red continuing the game/story if the porn aspect will not be included. The overwhelming majority of people that got interested/started playing MGI was solely because they wanted to bang monster girls. No offense but MGI is not an IP that can be carried solely on its storytelling, world building, characters, etc… alone.

While I can empathize with his decision to no longer continue working on it (at least as an eroge game), I’ve lost all respect in him for not fulfilling what was originally promised.

Anyways, I appreciate the clarification.

Well my opinion on the story it's good.... for a porn game. You can even see that on his discord most people came for the porn but stayed cause the story was interesting. With focus only on the story I don't think it will hold up that much but maybe I am wrong.

 

[HumanRug]

But even to this day he is still working on content I would say is at least related.

Yeah, Redamz already said it, "at my own pace". I'd bet that means less than a line of code per month. If he really cares about his game, he'd be more enthusiastic about showing progress, even if people aren't paying him for steady updates.

 

[DeccuSkurabu]

Although he did say he was working on another project long before he decided to cut the porn. Maybe that one might have something in it? I can't really say what it relates to or what type of game. I'm not exactly a giant fan of MGI just friends with Red so I might need some clarifications on some parts regarding his future plans.
Also, as a fellow game dev (he taught me everything i know) i do think he should be a little more transparent, but like i said before it's ultimately his prerogative

Yeah, Redamz already said it, "at my own pace". I'd bet that means less than a line of code per month. If he really cares about his game, he'd be more enthusiastic about showing progress, even if people aren't paying him for steady updates.

In his defense he is mostly a very busy person, But when he is working on game dev he works on it a lot.

 

[Rejost]

There is no defending that piece of trash, no matter how you look at it.

 

[snek774411]

So who got bored?

 

[DocRipper]

Although he did say he was working on another project long before he decided to cut the porn. Maybe that one might have something in it? I can't really say what it relates to or what type of game. I'm not exactly a giant fan of MGI just friends with Red so I might need some clarifications on some parts regarding his future plans.
Also, as a fellow game dev (he taught me everything i know) i do think he should be a little more transparent, but like i said before it's ultimately his prerogative



In his defense he is mostly a very busy person, But when he is working on game dev he works on it a lot.

All of this raises more questions and the way Red proceeds is very questionable and sometimes adds fuel to the fire.
It can be said that Red is a very crazy dev who is unaware of what crowdfunding actually is, its problems and benefits, its responsibilities. He has major communication problems and can't solve problems in an adult way.
If he is actually moving forward on something - great,but he can't expect any trust..or money. Even if the project is good. He's approached everything in the worst possible way.

I don't want information about other projects, it doesn't matter. It's his business and we don't have money in it (hopefully no one is stupid enough to send him something outside the system).

But there is a question, and maybe you as his messenger/friend could convey to him whether it would be a good idea to officially leave MGI to someone to complete. Suddenly changing genre or killing porn is not a good thing. Red may as well continue with his spin-off non-porn project, he would still have the credit and come out of it with some honor. As the king of HQ monster girl orgies and the one who started it all and inspired others.....
...much worse projects. Well..MGP is good,but still no real gameplay.

It's actually sad when the king of monster girl porn suddenly hates porn.

 

[DR is The Man]

All of this raises more questions and the way Red proceeds is very questionable and sometimes adds fuel to the fire.
It can be said that Red is a very crazy dev who is unaware of what crowdfunding actually is, its problems and benefits, its responsibilities. He has major communication problems and can't solve problems in an adult way.

The confusing thing about that is when he was doing patreon there was a somewhat consistent feed of information about what he was devoting his development time to. This shows he at least has somewhat of an understanding of how to properly communicate about his work so there should have been updates beyond just text in a discord sever.