Sorry for stepping in here but honestly it kinda sounds like you're expecting to be able to make whatever choices feel best to you, yet you still expect to get a result that doesn't necessarily follow from those choices. It just doesn't work that way in any game. This is a very nice, wholesome game that almost invariably rewards the "goody-doody" (i like that phrase btw, nice) path and doesn't reward aloofness or hostility. If you want a girl, be nice to her, and always take the top option. It's that easy. If the top option doesn't work for you, by all means don't pick it but don't expect to be rewarded for it either.Because forgiving right off the bat and acting like a goody-doody just doesn't fit my style. That was my choice on the very first go at the game as well, but I had to retrack it because it locked me out of Sandra. I'll give it another go, but I remember trying it on the last update and the only ones I could go after was Fiona, Sun, and Tanya.
Similarly, there's only one route in the game right now. Maybe other options will result in other paths later but that's just not the case at the moment. That content doesn't exist. I know you're just enjoying the game and trying to help and that's cool but ya know. You gotta take the game for what it is.