I'd say for me Jen is clearly the hottest one , then Olivia , Emma , Lea & Deb about equal to me. Not including Kim or Brie as they are 2 characters I have no interest in their paths.
Always nice to see the different views of the other players!
For me Jen, Lea and Olivia are the hottest girls and since I like Asian girls too, Kim is on the list as well. Emma is a bit below these 4. But that is just the hottness factor speaking, not the character factor. I have zero interest in the other girls, so I keep it friends there.
Character / personality wise : I like Emma the best while yeah she seems a bit simple yet I don't find her that boring. At the start of the game I did but around 1/2 way point I started to really get into her character and the build up to her lewd scenes were kind of hot after the first one because of her character to me.
For me, Emma could be a nice girlfriend if not for her "all men are dirt and the sole reason for anything bad in the world" worldview. I loath dogmatic people like these, it does not help that her "moderate" relationship with the MC is still in it´s infancy. The current possible paths with her are either you are an ass... to her or she is an ass... to you. No thanks! might become better when/if the more moderate relationship path comes around.
I found Olivia decent as a character, nice and all, but i dont want to be the 790th one to ride that train. I dont really like massive body counts. I did her 4some because i had the skills for it, and lets just say that going blind, you're missing a lot of scenes by not having the right skill. Oh well, im friends with her now and its fine.
You really miss out with Olivia! Yes, she is a wild one, but part of that comes from the damocles sword over her head. She could have one of the worst diseases known to man, Huntington´s! Knowing that her time on Earth could be more limited than normal, Olivia went for going in fullest. Her wildest streak is most probably over now since we can convince her
to test for HD, which is a 50/50 chance at best and she is lucky. She does not have it.Her personality is a great one. Not judging like Emma, fun to be with and a great friend. Definitely girlfriend material if you have no problems with her wild side. And that should not be problematic for most since Olivia might be wild but she wants to settle down with a nice guy now.
In my two Olivia paths I took "settling down with someone special" and then "Someone kind who sees the best..." and/or "Someone who can´t go hitchhiking without being asked...", which is directly meant Olivia. Showing you are ok with she did in the past and even find it a bit hot. And starting a relationship with a clean slate.
Then came Lea. I was liking her and everything, until i found out she's the yellow tree. I started to develop that way more by dropping red and ended up having a nice time and i picked her as my 1st crush. I didnt have do the internet stuff, as i figure itds gonna lead to sharing and im not too much into that either. Then came the sadface that she wanted to be the exclusive GF.
Another path you miss out on. Lea is an exhibitionist at heart and the internet stuff does not need to lead to sharing. Yes, there is the option to go down the sharing path, but you can also walk the path of just Lea and you, with her being an avid exhibitionist sharing pics and videos, but nothing else.