I feel like Amy has a chance to top Melissa's story, since they have a longer history together and being childhood friend/crush. It would be very hard though, Melissa is just perfect for MC
Melissa's story was too awesome. I doubt anything else can top it. It was not just the story and the "fit", it was also how the story was presented IMO. Melissa's very clear interest in Cole (the PC) and the very akward way she tried to approach it... Detentions so they would be together, hiring him so she would have his company, her "OK, let's do naughty stuff but not kisses, we're not a couple!" approach etc.
Nina's part was sweet, funny and interesting too, but not like Melissa. With Amy, I expect it to be something like that. Although I expect heavy drama with her and her family.
Doing Melissa story before Nina seems ... ouchy. Melissa is clearly interested for Cole even in the Nina Path, although she backs down in the end (aside of the Switch end). Nina in Melissa's story is less invested in Cole. You don't feel like you break her heart or anything. She's a bit jealous that she loses her BFF to a rich,
tall woman she dislikes but that is it.
I agree with Vainglorious. Nina deserves better. Hopefully there's more to her later.
Nah, Nina's story is complete. She will also have content with Amy since they're firends.
Maybe even a threesome since Nina doesn't mind her.