You have a point, but if Cindy's story is going to be the same no matter what you choose (love, lust, try to help her relationship with Wade or just ignore the whole situation), then your choices are kind of meaningless, don't you think?. They would only affect how your Ian feels about her story. Plenty of games around where your choices don't really matter but it would feel weird in this game.What if the Cindy route inst supposed to be pure?
You are stealing her from one of your best friends,the whole Ian-Cindy route is toxic from the beggining...
I'm not saying there has to be a happy ending to her path, it's not pure and has many difficulties to overcome starting with the treasonous beginning and continuing with all the hiding from your group of friends, her starting career as a model or Ian's relationships with the other love interests. But Cindy's actions should be affected by Ian's decisions IMO.