- Thread starter GIL3D
- Start date
-
- Tags
- 3dcg ahegao anal sex animated bdsm big ass big tits bukkake cheating creampie exhibitionism female domination groping group sex handjob humiliation lactation lesbian male domination male protagonist masturbation milf mobile game multiple penetration oral sex prostitution romance sex toys spanking teasing titfuck urination vaginal sex voyeurism
I'm slapping on an older comment I made, but I'll note some that I specifically like for their writing. Note that mediocre writing is kind of where I draw the line ('No D&D is better than bad D&D', they say), so none of the ones listed should at least strike you with bad writing. Callisto is probably the weakest writing-wise off the top of my head, probably the weakest entry overall, but other than that I think all entries here have, at the very least, alright writing.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
EDIT Wow, the first spoiler basically just paraphrased everything I said the first time around, hahah! Well, at least I have consistent views, I guess.
Last edited:
*raises eyebrow*
I'm a clean-cut guy and I would date Hana in a heartbeat. She's adorable.
And I don't have a tattoo fetish, it just doesn't really register as a big thing to me. Same with all this constant "NTR" stuff you see in every single thread. Not a fetish but it's not a "OMG I will never play this game!" thing for me either.
I'm with you in that it's a weirdly superficial view, but I don't really think it's fair to put someone over the coals for a comment they made almost a year ago.
Not putting anyone over the coals. I just thought it was an odd over-generalization to make. Everyone has different preferences, regardless of what they look like.
Is it considered bad etiquette here to reply to old posts? I was reading through them for fun, and when you do that you occasionally feel the need to reply to something. Personally I don't see how discussing the game or its characters could ever be a negative thing in a thread designed for that exact purpose, though I can see the point that it's different if the post I'm replying to isn't really about the characters or the story.
Well, yes, maybe? I mean, it's not exactly rude or anything like that, but my take on it is that bringing up the point or subject of the old post is fine, but I think we - especially in these days of rampant cancel culture - need to take a step back and be mindful of pointing fingers and going "Hey, you! That thing you said long ago!"
For example, I haven't really used Facebook in years, but if someone suddenly brought up some old status update (even if I said something completely innocuous) I'd... feel kind of iffy, you know? Like, regardless of whether I stood by that opinion or not, it would feel like poor form to be on the receiving end of it.
Again, that's just my opinion. Etiquette is weird like that. Personally, I might go more along the lines of "So, I saw this old comment that said [STUFF], and it got me thinking, what are the implications of [SPOOKY IDEA THAT SEEMS TO FIT]?", for example.
Last edited:
- Jan 28, 2018
- 1,250
- 1,371
Same... but even still, he's got first dibs, and I hate jumping in and betrayign his trust when he's such a bro.
- Jun 25, 2018
- 467
- 1,661
Replying to old posts isn't a bad thing, on the contrary, it can lead to some interesting discussions.
Regarding Hana, in general I hate tattooed women, IMO they are disfiguring themselves but since it's an erotic game and they aren't realistically looking anyway it doesn't bother me. And I disagree that Edwin is a "clean-cut guy", he's as much of a deviant as most perverts in Carnations Club (well, depending on our choices but if we want to see most of the content he is a lecherous young man who fucks everything that moves with some very sadistic tendencies).
I admittedly came into this game biased against Mina with more of an interest towards felicia but I'll be damned if her innocence played out in a game filled with depravity didnt draw me in. I also love that Hana plays against type of your normal tattooed chick.
Interesting that in this game that only two lis are actually available with everybody else being in a relationship
Interesting that in this game that only two lis are actually available with everybody else being in a relationship
Killian shapes up to be a great friend over the game so far. Not only in the scenes with him, but Mina for instance mentions that Killian speaks well and often about the MC. My MC will surely try to become friends with Mina, but he will NOT sabotage their relationship. No way my Edwin doing this to his friends!
I think Killian actually knows on a deeper level that Mina is special to him, there are a couple of scenes to this effect, but his upbringing and former relationships have left him too jaded to fully recognise that Mina is a type of person he won´t meet often or ever again over his lifetime.
My MC will definitely try to help him see this and help their relationship.
Agreed, maybe we see some more scenes with her natural haircolour as well. In the concert flashback at the birthday party it seems that Hana´s natural hair is red or redish-blond.
I mentioned it before, I am a bit surprised I like Hana this much, since I am not a fan of heavy tattoos either. I don´t hate them, but I agree with you that in most cases the tattoos do not fit or lessen their beauty. Rarely I see "Tats" on women which really suit them. It is a testament to how wellmade Hana´s character is that we both like her this much.
In a certain way I look forward to when Edwin´s mom meets his future girlfriend (I am on the Hana path in my playthrough) for the first time. I doubt she envisions someone like her from the decriptions on how Hana is as a person.
I agree with you on Hana nand Mina personalities. I do not think there are only two loveinterests in the game, over the length of the game most, if not all female characters might be datable, but Hana and Mina are definitely the main LIs of Pale Carnations.
- Oct 31, 2018
- 487
- 1,027
I had to go to the first page and look for a screenshot with Hana to remember what kind of tattoos she got. My stance on tattoos is pretty much neutral, as long as they are tasteful. Atleast in real life. In visual novels only a small amount of characters usually have any tattoos. But when they do it gives them an exotic, out of the ordinary look, which I find incredibly attractive.
In this game I mostly get lost in the characters eyes. I‘m pretty sure it‘s a simple eye mod, but still, the colors are so vibrant. One time I think, that this character isn‘t really of interest to me and the moment after they get a close up shot showing them with a determined look or a lustful/mischievous smirk and I‘m all for that character again... makes it really hard to focus on one of them.
In this game I mostly get lost in the characters eyes. I‘m pretty sure it‘s a simple eye mod, but still, the colors are so vibrant. One time I think, that this character isn‘t really of interest to me and the moment after they get a close up shot showing them with a determined look or a lustful/mischievous smirk and I‘m all for that character again... makes it really hard to focus on one of them.
- Nov 14, 2020
- 1,223
- 3,584
I know what you mean. Mina is very cute and, the more time we spend with her, the more that I like her. I don't think Killian has treated Mina particularly well for a prolonged period of time. BUT Killian has been a true friend to the MC.
It leaves me with serious dilemma being torn in two contradictory directions, which is a credit to great storytelling.
So far I have tried to walk a path of difficult balancing. Not outright slagging Killian off to Mina but being there for her when she needs someone. I have to hope that she will break up with Killian amicably enough that Killian would mind too much the MC swooping in afterwards.
- Feb 2, 2019
- 23
- 32
As long as Edwin can fuck Mina's ass, the mission will be accomplished
Man, this might be insensitive or callous of me, but I don't think Killian's love and loyalty to MC is a reason to be friends with him. Friendly, sure, but I think true friendship needs to go deeper than that. I mean, for me, I have to appreciate you as a person in order to be friends with you.
Now, don't get me wrong, I get that puppy eyes can be fiercely disarming, but, just... ehh. I have to go sleep hours ago, but I'm sure I could rant on this for quite a while. Props to the dude who said he's gonna help Killian clean his act up though, I wouldn't have the patience for that.
Now, don't get me wrong, I get that puppy eyes can be fiercely disarming, but, just... ehh. I have to go sleep hours ago, but I'm sure I could rant on this for quite a while. Props to the dude who said he's gonna help Killian clean his act up though, I wouldn't have the patience for that.
- Aug 14, 2018
- 404
- 588
That's fair. It's very ambitious and clearly has a long way to go, but I like the path it's on.
- Aug 14, 2018
- 404
- 588
I made my point, but I'd rather talk about this game. It's much better. Besides, all non Pale Carnations talk is just gonna get nuked by the moderators.
My mistake for the way I worded it I wasnt implying that they were the only two love interests, I was saying that only two of the perspective love interests are single, Hana and Veronica. Everybody else is in some stage of a relationship
- Aug 14, 2018
- 404
- 588
My impression is that Rosalind's marriage is basically over. Not legally, but I'm not sure I'd put her at a "stage in a relationship" when her husband basically abandoned her to gangsters.
I mean... Rosalind is technically married, but I really don't think she's letting him back in even if he does come back.