VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[ZunMadun]

Funny you mention that: This is the part where I just now quit the game. My body revolted at the thought of performing with any of the girls (both on and off stage). There should have been an option to walk, or to threaten to quit (that would ruin the exhibition) and you have to nominate another guy to step up or someone like Jacob who really doesn't want to is forced to perform in your place and now hates you forever, as does Hana. Or they straight up disappear you and it's game over. I wouldn't mind if the whole club took turns with each of them, just so long as I didn't have to.

There is a secret option for that actually.
You need to open the menu and then very carefully click "QUIT GAME" and then choose yes. You need to be very careful because if you do it incorrectly you will simply quit the game and won't see the secret ending.

Good luck

 

[hey1388]

This would be so great , it look very very nice !

 

[Porthos#1]

Great game. A little disturbing how easy it is to follow MC down the rabbit hole into this life, but I really like the creativity of the game.

 

[Porthos#1]

It was a long time since I played this masterpiece and I waited days before taking it back. But I must say it made me remember why I renewed my annual support on pateron months before this new chapter. Actually I have to agree with those who adore Mina and Hana, me too, but from a sexual point of view the top remains Felicia followed by Rosalind. Veronica a little less, i'm not a fan of women bodybuilders, even if she is an interesting character.
Good Job Mutt&Jeff!!

Agreed, almost 100%. I'd reverse Felicia and Rosalind personally, but great summary of characters!

 

[TD1900]

This update was f*cking disturbing... Especially Rosalind's exhibition scene was just nerve-wracking... Honestly, I can't understand what the writer wants to do with this f*cked-up story and why make things more extreme with every update...

I don't understand why you play every single update.

 

[MrBigs949]

This update was f*cking disturbing... Especially Rosalind's exhibition scene was just nerve-wracking... Honestly, I can't understand what the writer wants to do with this f*cked-up story and why make things more extreme with every update...

Well, then you don't have to play it.

Even I can't play it or bring myself to play it (played up to the end of week one), but that is my own personal problem. I'll "stomach" it when it releases entirely.

I tip my hat to the writer/developers. This is well-crafted and well written. That fact that it can be gut-wrenching is a credit in my mind to the creativity and narration of the characters.

Devs. Well done.

 

[anomkarsa]

Realistically what can the MC do in his position? He's a broke boy college student that's been enticed into a foreign environment he's not used to.

The game gives you choices to have the mc give in to the implied sadism deep inside him or you can have him help and protect the girls as much as he possibly can in the situation that he is in. He has no real power in the club (not yet anyway) yet in each exhibition so far you can have the MC take it easy on the girls and treat them with affection and encourage them to get them through the ordeal of each contest, instead of treating them like dirt and humiliating them.

Taking those choices is clearly building affection between the MC and the three girls because he's treating them like humans in a competion where everyone else sees them as objects. I think the devs have done a stellar job with a unique premise of a game that's not just another harem collect em' all or a college simulator.

Also if we're being realistic for a moment and these were real women being forced into this predicament then they would be far worse off than just suffering (so far) mostly humiliation on stage in front of strangers.

 

[GMDominance]

I don't understand why you play every single update.

Oh boy imagine the reaction when he play Starless

 

[Idontplay]

I don't understand why you play every single update.

Maybe he is a masochist.

 

[midway_02]

No incest ?

 

[TD1900]

No incest ?

None. Just a protagonist who bizarrely watches his mother's porno tapes.

 

[Cricco]

Incest < Edwyn finally confronting Victoria about the porn < Ian getting his idiot brain fucked by stupid at the realization that the only woman he ever respected isn't the Virgin Mary

 

[Bikinirt]

Can anyone give me save file

 

[Garen]

Agreed, almost 100%. I'd reverse Felicia and Rosalind personally, but great summary of characters!

You can essentially replace the first line with anything but with the second line following. That sums up how I feel about Rosalind at all times. She's too beautiful.

None. Just a protagonist who bizarrely watches his mother's porno tapes.

And I'm also loving the trauma revisiting subplot Roselind's got going for Edwin. It's my favourite ongoing plotline of the bunch.

 

[Bikinirt]

How to unlock this?
I hold her and accept his birthday present2 but it doesn't unlock

 

[camube]

That depends. MC can be really mean at times. It also depends on your [tough] stat.
And in the cases MC seems to care for the girls, it's only for a purpose : make them seem more 'enthusiastic'.
'Enthusiastic' is better for business. Depressed girls are bad for business. If [tough] is high, there are scenes where MC reminds everybody how bad he is inside.

When did the scene where MC reminds everyone "how bad he is inside" happened? I think my toughness stat might be pretty low

 

[Ranting Old Man]

Likely an Unpopular Opinion incoming:

There should be a way for MC and Killian to share Mina.

Paths that would be cool,
MC, Mina, Hana
MC, Killian, Mina
MC, Felicia, Mina
MC, Felicia, Killian
MC, Mina, Hana, Killian
MC, Mina, Felicia, Killian
MC, Rose, Killian
MC, Veronica, Killian
MC, Rose, Veronica , Felicia
MC, Rose, Felicia
MC, Felicia, Veronica
MC, Veronica, Mina

Honestly I doubt all of that is possible so the top 3 for me would be.
MC, Mina, Hana
MC, Mina, Killian
MC, Mina, Felicia

I just think since Killian is so adamant about the bromance and since he can't clearly keep Mina on his own, her feelings for MC developing, and his own feelings for her would ultimately lead to the outcome that the only way he could have his cake and eat it too is too convince them all to become a thruple/Open relationship.

There was already a few hints that we might get a MC, Mina, Hana outcome if we play our cards right and i generally hope that this happens. The 3 would all have good chemistry and this outcome makes the most sense so far.

I think MC, Mina and Felicia is also foreshadowed a little bit but in my opinion this one should be the hardest to aquire, Mina already hints that she doesn't really trust Felicia completely and Felicia obviously wants to remain a free bird. I think this outcome would be more like Felicia becoming an occasional 3rd party rather than a commited lover.

I think that Veronica and Mina with MC is another path hinted at and it would be hot but i think this one would likely create the most controversy. I can already see the screaming and fits that would take place, people generally have a fear of muscular women who are into women in these games, they automatically view them as competition even with how unrealistic the outcome they fear is to come to pass. I for one can't see Mina betraying the MC and same with Veronica. If you have them both on romance I think it would probably and most likely, the most loyal union of all based on their personalities.

Hope this gets people talking. Later.

 

[Thomas247]

For the last Carnation Event is Veronica supposed to lose? Because no matter how I try to replay the game, she ends losing the last contest and will be punished on Monday...

 

[TD1900]

For the last Carnation Event is Veronica supposed to lose? Because no matter how I try to replay the game, she ends losing the last contest and will be punished on Monday...

No, you can have Felicia lose, Veronica lose, Veronica & Felicia lose (in the event all 3 votes go to Rosalind), and you can have all 3 lose (if they tie by getting 1 vote each).

Hana's vote is fixed to Rosalind, the audience vote is fixed to decisions made in Ch3Up2 and Ch3Up3, and Kathleen's vote is tied to the decisions you make during exhibition 2. It is, admittedly, pretty arcane to unravel without a walk through.

 

[camube]

For the last Carnation Event is Veronica supposed to lose? Because no matter how I try to replay the game, she ends losing the last contest and will be punished on Monday...

no you can have any of the three wins

What you choose during Exhibitions (remember the Week Theme), would determine who wins Kathleen's vote.
Hana's vote is fixed though.