I truly doubt the endings of PC being this black and white once they arrive. TD hinted that there will be "good", "evil" and something of "neutral" endings for both Edwin staying in the Club as well as leaving. The neutral ones I think will be short and not very in depth, since an important part of the game is how Edwin copes with his morals, temptation, love interests and the Club. As TD stated, one day Edwin has to decide if he stays or leaves, but it is very much how we played the game under which circumstances this happens.If this choice would be only between running away (with his Li) leaving everyone else behind, or falling for the Club and embracing it's gruel debauchery, it would be an extremely dissapointing and unsatisfying End in my eyes. At least for all of us that don't want to embrace our Darker side.
If i could wish for a way to End PC i would wish for something like the old Fallouts did for their Endings, especially Fallout 2 comes to my mind. Like having 2 or 3 "Main Endings" lets call them Good, Evil and maybe a Bad End if MC stays non committal until the End, and after this show us how the Story Arcs/ Endings of the other (side) Characters and if/how they where influenced by us and give us some closure on them with that.
Of course this would mean quite a lot of work for Scripting and Writing but i think it would be worth the effort.
Many pages ago I wrote my Theory what might be the various Ends of PC with Edwin and Hana a couple. What we learned in the meantime seems to indicate I am not too far away (outside the curveball endings)from what will come.
- One is the pure Love route, which might see the end of the club at high moral levels or massive reforms done, with the mending of fences between Hana and August in addition. No to just slight/medium corruption of Hana (if MC and Hana want to test out a couple things, if they like it).
- Next is a positive Love route with MC and Hana (maybe Ian as well) being groomed to be the successors of the current leaders at PC. Would surly feature reforms too, if morals are good. There are hints of this if you play the Hana route and talk to August and Chuck often. And it becomes clear that August wants to repair the damage in his relationship with his daughter, he just does not really know how, cue us MCs.
Corruption could range from zero (Hana is shown to be pragmatic and thinking clearly on most things) over some/medium corruption (encouraged curiosity despite not convinced at start) to full corruption, if the MC likes his SO to be a loose cannon in bed.
e.g. testing porn acting (too much hints of it not only for Hana but others as well), girl-girl, sharing/swinging or a couple shifts in PC to see how it is. (while the majority does not, there are, most often hobby, prostitutes who like doing it)
- Another path would be the Dark Love one, Hana and the MC are a devoted couple, but the MC likes Hana to be as uninhibited and slutty as she can be and this Edwin is no angel too. This path naturally would feature major corruption efforts, like the ones above and additional ones like e.g. Hana "testdriving" August. See one of the dreams Edwin has in game, which is close to this scenario.
- The final path would be two-pronged depending on corruption level. In this storyline MC and Hana would be friends (maybe with benefits) and if Hana stays uncorrupted or just a bit, then MC helps her getting free of PC, in the case of a strongly corrupted Hana she is in PC for longer.