VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[FuDasRah]

It's a pretty good game and decent story line.

I haven't finished the game, not a complaint but I feel the female characters should all have varying breast sizes instead of all having the same size.
Also, maybe the choices we make should have some impact on how the story progresses and affects the relationships between the characters

Just my opinion.

Merry X'mas!

 

[Antherak]

I haven't finished the game, not a complaint but I feel the female characters should all have varying breast sizes instead of all having the same size.

devs said they like and prefer those sizes that's why almost every girls has massive tits.

Also, maybe the choices we make should have some impact on how the story progresses and affects the relationships between the characters

Choices DO have an impact and change way you interact with people. It also do affect relationships and most important characters even have scores to track how you get along with in the stats menu. Also certain thresholds activate special event with some girls if you meet them by the time the event would take place, some of them mutually exclusive.

 

[ShadowLordV1]

Was thinking the same about the breast sizes, but then again, even if there is variety, a lot of times the girls who have the breasts you like are not the characters you like - so here I could at least just neglect the breasts as a deciding factor.

With the choices I feel there is only so much you can do as a developer, otherwise nobody is happy, because the update is only 1/10th as long of a normal update, since they have to write 10 routes. Or there are basically 2 entirely different games, depending on an early branching plot choice that matters a lot. I would guess it's just a very limiting medium.

Honestly the concept of the story is already a bit unbelievable, let other games have girls with varying breast sizes, sometimes you need a proper game with all women being smoking hot.

 

[yomigu]

Is there a specific way I need to update the game from ch3up4 to ch4up1 if I was using that walkthrough mod? It was the one that showed the in game stat changes from certain choices. I also remember it allowed me to choose all the character traits at the start of the game. I tried copying over my saves folder from the ch3up4 game folder to the ch4up1 game folder. Then I installed the walkthrough mod linked here (https://f95zone.to/threads/pale-carnations-ch-4-update-1-mutt-jeff.50281/post-8360794). But when I run the ch4up1 game and load the save, it gives that error page. Am I doing something wrong?

 

[FuDasRah]

Choices DO have an impact and change way you interact with people. It also do affect relationships and most important characters even have scores to track how you get along with in the stats menu. Also certain thresholds activate special event with some girls if you meet them by the time the event would take place, some of them mutually exclusive.

Oh wait

The statistics button is greyed off for me in the main menu somehow.
Haven't had special events too.

 

[Gucch]

I think thats the case in the beginning if I remember correctly? Maybe you have not played very far yet?

Yep. That's the case in the beginning.

 

[redknight00]

 

[eman2004]

How often the game gets an update and is it regular

 

[Deleted member 4058859]

How often the game gets an update and is it regular

You can filter by the release tag on their patreon page:

You must be registered to see the links

You can check the changelog for amount of content per release. The project is well worth supporting if that is what you are considering.

 

[Zod666]

If i visit Mina game just ends saying its end of the build, after we fall asleep on the couch.
Every other choice continues the game into next day, is my game bugged? any way to fix it, i wanted to go with Mina route.

 

[TD1900]

If i visit Mina game just ends saying its end of the build, after we fall asleep on the couch.
Every other choice continues the game into next day, is my game bugged? any way to fix it, i wanted to go with Mina route.

The culprit is likely the mod you're using. If it's outdated, you've essentially replaced a current file with the Ch3Up4 one that still has the line of code calling the end of update screen at that exact spot.

 

[Zod666]

The culprit is likely the mod you're using. If it's outdated, you've essentially replaced a current file with the Ch3Up4 one that still has the line of code calling the end of update screen at that exact spot.

Thank You, updated the mod, all works again

 

[Axeleen]

Next you will be telling it is realistic to say the average penis size in the global human population must be around 25-30cm because most porn games say so.
Take the edge off and go learn some biology outside of videogames.

[...] you have absolutely no understanding of the differences between occurences and statistics.

Here is a girl who's boobs to frame ratio outweighs all main girls in PC except Rosalind:

You must be registered to see the links

Here's a girl whose boobs/frame ratio shatters any single girl in PC:

You must be registered to see the links

[...]

Curiously, I've never seen your answer about this message. Very surprising ! Surely, there must have been a connection issue when you tried to send the message I guess

 

[BrockLanders]

Their entire post history is just ad hominem garbage mixed with ironic /r/iamverysmart statements. Their account is just a pathetic friction machine. Steer clear and ignore.

 

[Axeleen]

Their entire post history is just ad hominem garbage mixed with ironic /r/iamverysmart statements. Their account is just a pathetic friction machine. Steer clear and ignore.

You really don't know what ad hominem means... I strictly only comment on this site when I see people giving erroneous information, and to ask for info myself.

 

[Idontplay]

This isn't the quarrel we need but the one we deserve.

 

[BrockLanders]

This isn't the quarrel we need but the one we deserve.

I have no idea because I took my own advice... and nothing of value was lost lol

 

[andhesgonewithmetoo]

You really don't know what ad hominem means... I strictly only comment on this site when I see people giving erroneous information, and to ask for info myself.

I've never seen someone with a more defective brain

https://f95zone.to/threads/pale-carnations-ch-4-update-1-mutt-jeff.50281/post-9587020

 

[Bill Temple]

I have no idea because I took my own advice... and nothing of value was lost lol

https://f95zone.to/threads/pale-carnations-ch-4-update-1-mutt-jeff.50281/post-9587020

I suggested that he would be more convincing by using less confrontational language, but he assured me that

... I hold absolutely no interest, let alone importance, in convincing others, and even less in them "accepting" this basic truth. I simply state a truth when I see someone babbling nonsense, and bask in the ridicule of their callow sophism trying to advocate for an assuredly erroneous idea. Let peasants be peasants.

I assume he dug up the pointless dispute from more than two weeks ago to demonstrate how little interest he has in convincing others.

It's always best to not feed the trolls.

 

[Bill Temple]

did any1 else go into this hoping that the girls would win and lose one round each? I got a tie between all 3 in the last round which took me by surprise

I try to split the wins between Fel and Vero, because I never let Rose win. I think deep-down that マゾビッチ MILF prefers it that way anyway.