VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[chaughton22]

This would be so great, if only it were animated

Is this game really not animated? If not, that seems like a huge oversight in 2020.

 

[MoarDakka123]

Some scenes are, not sure what criteria is used to pick which ones.

Actually, the only stuff that immediately comes to mind that isn't animated is stuff from earlier releases, maybe it's just because it's older material?

 

[Theba]

That is the charm of this game, there is no any of the base HS animations, almost every animation in here is made pic by pic. That is what makes this game unique, in my opinion.

 

[Spfjolietjake]

I honestly believe nothing needs to change on this vn. There are others, hundreds that will get players their 'cest, harem and "animation" cravings fix. Instead of suggesting changing this one.

 

[TD1900]

Is this game really not animated? If not, that seems like a huge oversight in 2020.

Let me put it this way: I wouldn't sell our project on the strength of the animation. GIL has learned a lot over the last couple of updates and has improved a ton in that area, but his crowning strength is his posing, attention to detail, and expressiveness.

If animations are a make or break thing for you, I would take a pass on this one.

 

[Retromancer]

I honestly believe nothing needs to change on this vn. There are others, hundreds that will get players their 'cest, harem and "animation" cravings fix. Instead of suggesting changing this one.

I wish I could like this 1,000 times

 

[chaughton22]

Let me put it this way: I wouldn't sell our project on the strength of the animation. GIL has learned a lot over the last couple of updates and has improved a ton in that area, but his crowning strength is his posing, attention to detail, and expressiveness.

If animations are a make or break thing for you, I would take a pass on this one.

Fair enough. I was just kinda surprised to see a game with HS models but no animated tag; typically those go hand in hand. Animations are not required for me to enjoy a game, but if a recent production game excludes them I tend to expect higher quality renders and more of them per scene. The text takes on much greater significance in conveying the action as well.

I'm seeing several posters singing very high praises for this, will give it a try and report back.

 

[madman11122]

I'm going to be honest, I enjoyed this so much I didn't even notice there weren't animations. I'm 100% invested in this story, the premise and execution are so good. This is very high quality erotica.

Spoiler: As far as the incest goes

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Spfjolietjake]

I'm going to be honest, I enjoyed this so much I didn't even notice there weren't animations. I'm 100% invested in this story, the premise and execution are so good. This is very high quality erotica.

Spoiler: As far as the incest goes

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I agree with the unspoiler part. I wouldn't hate the spoiler part but I won't be holding my breath. Regardless this vn is dark gust of fresh air here.

 

[Maviarab]

I agree with the unspoiler part. I wouldn't hate the spoiler part but I won't be holding my breath. Regardless this vn is dark gust of fresh air here.

I would hate it. It doesn't fit the story, the character ot the narrative.

For all the idiots asking for it/wanting it...the MC literally explains why he watches it and it isn't because he wants to fuck her!

 

[baka]

this game has potential. the huge amount of CG show that its not a slacker we are dealing with, but a person that are all about details. the dedication reminds me of PW and his game Project Sage.

so, I read about the harem need. well, as Spfjolietjake wrote theres other game with that fetish. why do all games need to be the same?
I never liked harem games, since its so unrealistic that all girls, no matter age just want to fuck the MC, and no matter how stupid, young or immature the Mc is, they all want him. the reason I dont like it is because I never put myself into the Mc, Im just an observer/manipulator and want to read/view hot scenes with the characters. so all dudes and girls in the game are a go for me.

I hope all girls in this game can be corrupted and be played with and not just with the Mc, but with all kind of stereotypes, the old, the obese, the nerd, the bastard, the perv. all kinds of male characters having a go with the girls!

 

[Spfjolietjake]

I would hate it. It doesn't firt the story, the character ot the narrative.

For all the idiots asking for it/wanting it...the MC literally explains why he watches it and it isn't because he wants to fuck her!

I don't really hate anything in my defense if it's optional. If it wasn't then yeah it would not be cool. But that's just me. Atleast I'm not an idiot because I never asked for it

 

[Maviarab]

I don't really hate anything in my defense if it's optional. If it wasn't then yeah it would not be cool. But that's just me. Atleast I'm not an idiot because I never asked for it

Ya know I don't mince my words by now Spf hehe.

Just sick of every thread...want, want, want...don't like this...change that...wah blah.

 

[SharkVampire]

this game has potential. the huge amount of CG show that its not a slacker we are dealing with, but a person that are all about details. the dedication reminds me of PW and his game Project Sage.

so, I read about the harem need. well, as Spfjolietjake wrote theres other game with that fetish. why do all games need to be the same?
I never liked harem games, since its so unrealistic that all girls, no matter age just want to fuck the MC, and no matter how stupid, young or immature the Mc is, they all want him. the reason I dont like it is because I never put myself into the Mc, Im just an observer/manipulator and want to read/view hot scenes with the characters. so all dudes and girls in the game are a go for me.

I hope all girls in this game can be corrupted and be played with and not just with the Mc, but with all kind of stereotypes, the old, the obese, the nerd, the bastard, the perv. all kinds of male characters having a go with the girls!

Both hands up on this post, I agree with every word
Except ugly bastards part

 

[Spfjolietjake]

Ya know I don't mince my words by now Spf hehe.

Just sick of every thread...want, want, want...don't like this...change that...wah blah.

Haha yup I do know you enough now and I totally get what you are saying. Some topics give me a eye twitch I swear.

I really do hope this vn stays unchanged the devs have made such a unique vn I want to see where they take it. So fingers crossed

 

[Xill]

Haha yup I do know you enough now and I totally get what you are saying. Some topics give me a eye twitch I swear.

I really do hope this vn stays unchanged the devs have made such a unique vn I want to see where they take it. So fingers crossed

I never liked the idea of the dev giving into the opinions of people of how the game's vision should be.

I like all kinds of games. Incest, non-incest. Harem, non-harem. Non-ntr, not so much ntr. Always irks me a bit when people complain about stuff that are perfectly fine. For example if the game isn't like the tons of other games on this site and people wanting it to be like one even though that's not what the dev wants. OR if the game is exactly like the other hundreds on this site but still has good quality and is in general a good game but people want to change it so its more unique, but thats not what the dev wants. Devs can then get bored, burnt out or completely cancel the project which is sad. Worst thing to see on this site is the "abandoned" tag. Especially on a game you like.

About Victoria, you can still appreciate her hotness even if she isn't a LI. I sure as hell will. That one render of her while shes soaking wet and wraped in a towel makes her look really sexy. She's still part of the game so why not? It would be like someone saying "hey, these backgrounds look really nice". Then someone else comes and says "you cant fuck em, so why bother?".

 

[Spfjolietjake]

I never liked the idea of the dev giving into the opinions of people of how the game's vision should be.

I like all kinds of games. Incest, non-incest. Harem, non-harem. Non-ntr, not so much ntr. Always irks me a bit when people complain about stuff that are perfectly fine. For example if the game isn't like the tons of other games on this site and people wanting it to be like one even though that's not what the dev wants. OR if the game is exactly like the other hundreds on this site but still has good quality and is in general a good game but people want to change it so its more unique, but thats not what the dev wants. Devs can then get bored, burnt out or completely cancel the project which is sad. Worst thing to see on this site is the "abandoned" tag. Especially on a game you like.

I agree with most of that. But ntr lovers and ntr haters both have zealots that go into threads that have or don't have whichever they want so they try to bully for it's inclusion or exclusion.

I would have to be blind to not admit Victoria is hot, but I wouldn't hold my breath on any play with her besides maybe scenes from the stash the mc has. Imo anyway

 

[baka]

my favorite girl is Hana, she is my LI. but I want to corrupt her as well! and a lot!

 

[Xill]

I agree with most of that. But ntr lovers and ntr haters both have zealots that go into threads that have or don't have whichever they want so they try to bully for it's inclusion or exclusion.

Ignore them and they go away.

my favorite girl is Hana, she is my LI. but I want to corrupt her as well! and a lot!

Veronica is mine. I just love how fit she is.

Then I think after that it's:

1. Hana
2. Felicia & Kathleen
3. Rosalinde & Mina

 

[Spfjolietjake]

I have a soft spot for Rosalinde, no idea why. Felicia is fun as hell. Mina I just want to steal away cause Ian so doesn't deserve her.

But honestly after all that said I don't have a real favorite. I'm enjoying them all but none I want to be my ride or die.