VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Shawnchapp]

That's all there is. It's been a while since I've played but it seemed to do what it said WT wise. Think stats are what matters the most more than a choice if I remember right. The mod seems like it might be buggy atm.

ah well im at the first sandbox event (the bar) and the mod doesn't help at all i didn't even know there was 3 different options and I'm not sure what the best option is like do i dance with Mina do i dance with the other girl or do i dance with both... i have no clue Lol might have to unren this myself and take a peek Lol

 

[SonsOfLiberty]

ah well im at the first sandbox event (the bar) and the mod doesn't help at all i didn't even know there was 3 different options and I'm not sure what the best option is like do i dance with Mina do i dance with the other girl or do i dance with both... i have no clue Lol might have to unren this myself and take a peek Lol

By looking at the comments, not sure if the mod is bugged with old saves or it's just bugged in general.

 

[Shawnchapp]

By looking at the comments, not sure if the mod is bugged with old saves or it's just bugged in general.

it seems to being working as intented... i'm on a fresh instal and a new save and haven't has any issues with it showing stat changes.. which i assume thats all its suppose to do and not tell you what choices are good/bad.. like even in the first real choice with the girl (to join the club) you can 100% take advantage of her as long as you apologize to her afterwards there is 0 conquencess but if you don't say sorry you will lock yourself out of content and the mod doesn't mention this at all... so i think its just badly named... its not really a walkthrough it just a stats highlighter... which is helpfully don't get me wrong but not so much for people like me who want the choice guide to get most scenes in one playthrough (i don;'t really have time to do multiply playthoughs for games.)

 

[itfod]

is there an actual walkthorugh mod for this game? or just the pdf? i'm well aware of the "walkthorugh mod" linked in the OP buts that just a stats highlighter not a walkthrough that tells you best choices or where choices can lead.

Is there a PDF that covered the new update? I skimmed the previous posts, but didn't see any.

 

[Shawnchapp]

Is there a PDF that covered the new update? I skimmed the previous posts, but didn't see any.

Idk I'm just using the one linked in the OP im still in the prologue i think so its still works for me Lol

 

[itfod]

Idk I'm just using the one linked in the OP im still in the prologue i think so its still works for me Lol

Ah, that's one of the best walkthroughs I've seen for this game. it doesn't cover the new update, but it's bloody good.

 

[Shawnchapp]

Ah, that's one of the best walkthroughs I've seen for this game. it doesn't cover the new update, but it's bloody good.

Good to know, thanks

 

[Castellanvon]

God the character writing is so good. One of the very few games on this website where I actually slow down and read everything. All the girls are amazing but shout outs to the MC for always impressing me by how eloquent they can be at just expressing and making sense the complicated parts of life.

 

[Ungawa]

As close to Pale Carnations as possible, with a good story and also plenty of choice. I also like the corruption part, if you like it too.

Story-wise and lower level, there's Cohabitation by Redux which is about corruption within a household. It's completed but a very slow burn from what I recall.

Harem Hotel has a LOT going on content wise, but the story is not as dark as Pale Carnations

Depraved Awakening and City of Broken Dreamers certainly are darker and you might find similarities. I haven't played them to comment.

Finally, Countess in Crimson would have a small village, magic, and you trying to be either a decent guy or an asshole who also corrupts or enchants the women you'll be involved with.

Sadly, I don't play too many really dark and corrupt games similar to Pale Carnations, but that should give you a few options to begin to find what you want and get a similar feeling.

 

[mtdaag]

Please name a few NTR games that you played, that made you such an expert on NTR.

Lol. Lmao even.

 

[itfod]

Hey, weird question.

I'm going through the memories, and I've got an old one locked off - go to the gym with Mina.

I'm really confused, because I thought I had already hit everything prior to this update... is anybody else seeing this? Is it a bug, or did I miss a scene somehow?

 

[TD1900]

Hey, weird question.

I'm going through the memories, and I've got an old one locked off - go to the gym with Mina.

I'm really confused, because I thought I had already hit everything prior to this update... is anybody else seeing this? Is it a bug, or did I miss a scene somehow?

Aaaaaaah, crap.

It's an old scene that someone requested I add to the gallery. I intended to add a bit of code at the start of the week3up3 script to retroactively unlock it for anyone who had the minaGym variable on their save, but it seems like I never did.

 

[OctoPriest]

Hoooly crap Elias just... wow. Don't get me wrong, totally get it's a fictionalized setting, but... All the talk of railroads, modernization, and him being so proud of our 'manifest destiny'? MAJOR oof. Don't regret a thing.

For those outside the US: 'Manifest Destiny' was the belief in America's Godly given right to tame the West (which largely was aided by the two major railroad lines connecting) and rule coast to coast; the justification used for the wide scale genocide of the Native Americans.

Yeah, mister holier than thou can go screw himself. lol

 

[TangerineTango]

Out of curiosity and hypotheticals, what year does the game take place in? The only confirmed dates in the game that I remember were 2009 (the sex tapes of the mom).

 

[itfod]

Aaaaaaah, crap.

It's an old scene that someone requested I add to the gallery. I intended to add a bit of code at the start of the week3up3 script to retroactively unlock it for anyone who had the minaGym variable on their save, but it seems like I never did.

Thanks for the clarification!

Also, weird question - How do you get Hana to call you Daddy? I've seen it in the memories, but not in my playthrough, so one of my stats must be too low, i think.

 

[TD1900]

Out of curiosity and hypotheticals, what year does the game take place in? The only confirmed dates in the game that I remember were 2009 (the sex tapes of the mom).

The distant future of 2020.

Also, weird question - How do you get Hana to call you Daddy? I've seen it in the memories, but not in my playthrough, so one of my stats must be too low, i think.

At the near start of the encounter, there's a choice: "You'll both forget your anxieties." / "You'll have this bitch calling you daddy." What you pick there changes the context of some of the dialogue.

 

[critic specialized in NTR]

Spoiler: MC mom

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Eonor]

Made a compressed Android port of Pale Carnations Chapter 4 Update 3 with Lunarmist's walkthrough mod.

Got some basic gestures loaded in: swipe up for save menu, swipe down to hide UI, swipe left to rollback and swipe right to skip. Save files are now stored in the Documents folder. This sometimes means that you may need to close and re-open the port after installing so the save folder is properly created.

Due to the size of this game, I've split it out so you will need to install the apk, run it to get it to create the game folder that can be found in your Documents folder: Documents/Eonor/e.palecarnations/game. Then move the archive.rpa file into that folder and re-run the port.

Please let me know if you encounter any issues with the ports and I'll see what I can do to get them sorted.

Link:

You must be registered to see the links

 

[JohnEffinDoe]

Can someone please spare a save with Rosalind Deal im not able to select the second option plz

 

[YuNobi1]

As close to Pale Carnations as possible, with a good story and also plenty of choice. I also like the corruption part, if you like it too.

Harem Hotel has a LOT going on content wise, but the story is not as dark as Pale Carnations

Depraved Awakening and City of Broken Dreamers

All personal recommendations:

I would classify Maids and Maidens as "in the same vein" as Pale Carnations in that they're both HS games where MC dominates (or romances) various women, but the age and power dynamic is different between MCs, but there is no bondage (...yet? Indications of future content).

Harem Hotel is the HS corrupting dominating sibling to Hail Dicktator's DAZ3D BDSM focus. Both have MC managing a hotel hosting a growing ensemble of lovely employees/residents.

The Headmaster is a good HS game that emphasizes the "D" in bdsm set in a "high school". Think: you swapped places with Kathleen and are directing her how to Dom the house girls (like which spanking tool to use, and when), with newer content allowing you to take a more "direct" approach.

Depraved Awakening and City of Broken Dreamers are certainly good but darker storytelling from the same dev, though I wouldn't call them "like PC" as there's not much Dom or corruption content in CoBD (it's been a while since DA wrapped up, so I might have forgotten some content).

Another game with some potential "dark content" would be Karlsson's Gambit. Heavy focus on femdom, but optional maledom and malesub paths with quite a lot of player choice.

However, THE BEST corruption game that I can recommend is A Mother's Love. I highly recommend this game regardless, but if you like Rosalind as a sexually insecure MILF, and the choice to romance or corrupt/Dom her, then this game was MADE for you. Pay no attention to the "Abandoned" tag, the dev is currently posting progression updates after a year-long hiatus.

There are other story, choice, bdsm, or corruption games I could recommend, but I wouldn't classify them as "like PC" considering style and/or niche/targeted audience.