VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[baka]

Is there some avoidable NTR for Hana planned?

if u ask me there should be some choices here. I mean, Hana/Mina are LI but the whole game is about corruption and depravity.
the NTR I can see here is "sharing", where the Mc is playing with his "girlfriends" as he wishes. Mina is ready to be corrupted and used, as she seems to be the perfect sub for this while Hana is a challenge but not impossible.
my scenario for Hana would be that the Mc is pushing her into exhibitionism and later into outdoor sex and eventually private stripshow where she hide her face with a mask while "patrons" enjoy the show. and later when shes ready she will enjoy some gloryhole. for Mina is kind of "bucket-list" that eventually will involve other males as well, its just a matter of time.

 

[thememeguy123]

Sorry, i dont like this take.
In my first run, i want to see what happens when you choose by your own thinking, i can later try to get the ending i want with help, but i feel following someone else since the beginning kill the experience

you don't need to be sorry to have a different opinion on something. I don't want to replay the game so I just get to where I originally wanted to get anyway, all the mod shows is how your choices affect the relationships for the characters, imo I'm not following someone else but myself that way, the mod doesn't tell me what I should choose does it? enjoy your game however you want

 

[dolfe67]

if u ask me there should be some choices here. I mean, Hana/Mina are LI but the whole game is about corruption and depravity.
the NTR I can see here is "sharing", where the Mc is playing with his "girlfriends" as he wishes. Mina is ready to be corrupted and used, as she seems to be the perfect sub for this while Hana is a challenge but not impossible.
my scenario for Hana would be that the Mc is pushing her into exhibitionism and later into outdoor sex and eventually private stripshow where she hide her face with a mask while "patrons" enjoy the show. and later when shes ready she will enjoy some gloryhole. for Mina is kind of "bucket-list" that eventually will involve other males as well, its just a matter of time.

It's sharing though, it's different from NTR. Unless you consider NTR everything where MC is not the only male.

A scenario maybe would be that Hana is mad at MC for cheating with Mina, and then she plots together with Mina to tie him up to a chair and they have sex each other while the MC's only able to watch. And after that they break up with him.

 

[baka]

that can work in a "bad choices" scenario if the Mc is acting like a bastard.
they can punish the Mc for being a dick by giving him a last show before kicking his ass.
if instead he play the right cards, they accept his harem-fetish and let him do whatever.

as for "ntr" yeah, if u are talking netorare. but we also have netorase that is willingly/sharing.
we have too little netorase in games so it could be fresh to include that.
but I dont mind bad-ends if the DEV wants it.

 

[Bill Temple]

A scenario maybe would be that Hana is mad at MC for cheating with Mina, and then she plots together with Mina to tie him up to a chair and they have sex each other while the MC's only able to watch. And after that they break up with him.

If we're going for real NTR, a scenario could be Hana is mad at MC for cheating with Mina. After a long day at the club, MC gets an email from Hana with subject line "You'll love this!" and just a link to PH. The faces are blurred but it's clearly Hana and Mina and Warren! MC starts crying as he unbuttons his pants and slides the box of tissues closer...

 

[Maviarab]

Jesus guys...enough with the NTR bollox...none if it is likely to ever happen.

 

[Ottoeight]

Jesus guys...enough with the NTR bollox...none if it is likely to ever happen.

I don't know who is nonsensically more annoying: whether these "let's hope Edwin will be cucked" dudes or those who want to see his mom banged by the Club's patrons.

 

[RC-1138 Boss]

It's moments like this one that make me miss the facepalm reaction. Even after the developers shuting them down some still insist on their delusions.

 

[Blueray]

when's the next update coming out?

 

[midnightotaku]

I don't know who is nonsensically more annoying: whether these "let's hope Edwin will be cucked" dudes or those who want to see his mom banged by the Club's patrons.

why not? If there's a scenario that fits makes sense, I could see it happening. Different strokes for different folks. It can be just one of the potential paths, depending on your choices. It would mean *gasp* decisions you make in a game could have actual negative consequences instead literally 99% of other games where you get a harem ending with 3-no, 4-5-6 some

 

[RC-1138 Boss]

why not? If there's a scenario that fits makes sense, I could see it happening. Different strokes for different folks. It can be just one of the potential paths, depending on your choices. It would mean *gasp* decisions you make in a game could have actual negative consequences instead literally 99% of other games where you get a harem ending with 3-no, 4-5-6 some

Because developers already said no. Multiple times.
So stop trying to shoehorn it here.

 

[Simpgor]

Because developers already said no. Multiple times.

Yes but who are the developers of the game to say how the game will be developed?

 

[dolfe67]

Because developers already said no. Multiple times.
So stop trying to shoehorn it here.

Yes but why can't someone share his thoughts about what if it could be the case? Because you don't like it? We can discuss even unlikely scenario without asking for it to be in the game.

 

[Simpgor]

Yes but why can't someone share his thoughts about what if it could be the case? Because you don't like it? We can discuss even unlikely scenario without asking for it to be in the game.

They were asking for it to be in the game? Otherwise there is no need to add the point about "making it different from 99% of games".

It's not about how you, him, me, or the other guy feel about NTR (or Incest/whatever niche ass fetish you want in every game) the dev has said they won't be included. On top of that I really doubt the impetus of change will come from someone here instead of you know....any of the people who support them.....

 

[xslayermkdx]

View attachment 3363323

Mina looks beautiful like always but i think its better with Tails makes her Specific & Unique

 

[baka]

They were asking for it to be in the game? Otherwise there is no need to add the point about "making it different from 99% of games".

I see a few issues here.
1. if someone is spamming and repeatedly trying to force his own needs using words that can be insulting and demanding, Im all for it to shut this dude down.
2. people that shut down everyone that share their thoughts about what they wish or not because its goes against their own needs. those for me are the problem here.

there need to be a balance here. I dislike both 1 & 2 as they are equally annoying. those "police" dudes that thinks they have the last-saying and think they are allowed to disrespect others. but also people that dont want to understand and egoistically want to have their way are equally annoying, but, maybe they are the same kind of people, the only difference is that in 1 their needs are not satisfied while in 2 it is and they defend it like dogs because they dont want competition and dont want to share it to anyone else.

 

[Pagoramix]

Achtually!
Well, as far as i know which is not very far, anykind of sexual intercourse of a love interest that does not involve the main character is considered NTR around here. So with that very wide definition, the flashback scene of Hana with the singer at the beginning of the game might very well be considered NTR. Much alike, every time Kathleen or Killian is sexually involved with a carnation, it might also be tagged as NTR since there is somekind of a love route for each one. It would even be hard netorare since they are more or less blackmailed into it(Felicia apart).

I'd like to add that i love the game as it is and am not asking anyone to change anything to it.
The creators probably chose carefully which tag to put, and i totaly understand why they did so.
What i do like though is watching the world burn

 

[Ottoeight]

 

[AlphaBit]

Bonus Art: Price Of Pride
This will become a transition screen next update.

 

[RC-1138 Boss]

Veronica is indeed a beast.