VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Simpgor]

I mean, he doesn't know he's about to get humiliated. As far as he's concerned, owners of exclusive and secret sex club reached out to him with offer to join because he's highly successful, rich and famous.

What happens once he finds out the reality of it, well, guess we have yet to find out, too.


You may be looking at it from reverse: it'd be getting Mina involved in the club that could be possibly devastating for Felicia, not Mina getting to see her spread eagle and buck naked on the stage for perverts to jerk off to. Felicia is quite protective of Mina, much like a number of posters in this thread.

But other patron(s) of the club describe him as a prude don't they? Maybe they are just saying "prude compared to us who visits a sex club every week at minimum during the summer"
honestly beyond any legal/martial stuff I imagine he's going to have a worse time than Felica at the club lol especially if Edwin gets directly involved.

Ahhh you were right I was thinking about it the opposite way but Mina "wants" something "like" that doesn't she? And Kat can't rope her into anything beyond a single show (can't make Mina a carnation for just week 4). I kind of struggle to see a scenario where Mina trusts August/Elias/Kathleen/Chuck enough to preform a show "unwillingly" even more so if Mina ends up being involved in week 4 instead of 3. The only way I see Mina being "involved" at the club in the short term while "felica feels the need to protect her" is if Mina is "lured" under the guise of it just being Edwin/people watching but then the patrons get involved agaisnt her will......

I understand Mina "needing" to get involved at the club at some point but right now as "felicas issue to deal with in week 3/4" seems unlikely..... and downright impossible if you consider who the "guest" would be for Rose (to keep the competition "equal").....

 

[ffive]

Ahhh you were right I was thinking about it the opposite way but Mina "wants" something "like" that doesn't she?

Well, Mina has her bucket list but it doesn't stop people in the thread from crying for her to run away from August, even though they know it, does it? So i figure Felicia might feel similar way about it.

 

[Simpgor]

Well, Mina has her bucket list but it doesn't stop people in the thread from crying for her to run away from August, even though they know it, does it? So i figure Felicia might feel similar way about it.

You and I both know Felica respects Mina's desires/autonomy more than anybody here that being said if it was Sophia we were talking about.......

IMO the fact that only Rose has literally nobody else to "invite" to the club (either to be involved or just to watch) but her VERY underage daughter should alleviate any worries that people have about Mina (being pulled in) right now

Maybe the fact that I think it would be more interesting for Mina to willingly want to be involved in the club due to Ian break up/Edwin hook up is coloring my opinion though

 

[TD1900]

Then it just suddenly turns on a dime and say nah he's just a desperate whore who agreed to all this.

I mean, that's the gist of this porn game. The player character plays part in the sex stuff. Complaining about it is the same as complaining about how there isn't an option to tell Dr. Chuck to fuck off at the start. What is untrue is the assertion that the story turns on a dime and turns the player character into a whore.

He's already a whore by that point.

Irrespective of playing Kathleen's prop dick during the exhibition side of story, he became a whore the moment he accepted the job and compromised his values for money. There's no bait and switch there, because the game is about whores.

The Carnations, the player character's mother, and even Edwin himself.

Edwin is fairly set in stone for a player character. He's always hung up about his Mom's past as a porn star, he's a sadist at heart, and his heavy handed bloviating about being tested at the start is quickly answered by the scenario. It's pretty telling that the one time he outright rejects an exhibition task is when he perceives it posing as a personal risk.

The granularity in the player character's moral fiber comes from his choices along the way: how he treats the Carnations, how much he gets lost inside the role, and what he ultimately ends up doing pending a big come to God moment.

I get not digging the game because of being railroaded into being a wishy-washy hypocrite. In fact I'm surprised people seem as okay with it as they are. It's like shit or get off the horse, Edwin. Don't you know you're into a porn game? But ultimately that's just baked into premise, and is something I take less as actionable criticism and more as an incompatibility issue.

 

[Mtgwo]

Damn, that Mina preview... I already know what im picking if given the option haha.

 

[Zarathos27]

Sounds like he wants game over screens as an out and we know the player base loves that. /s

 

[Takkatakka]

Damn, that Mina preview... I already know what im picking if given the option haha.

August?

 

[Ass prefer]

He's already a whore by that point.

 

[Birdnman993]

He's already a whore by that point.

Well, at least he's an expensive whore, which I find funny and sad because this all started to pay for college, which is something that happens a lot in reality, with better or worse results.

 

[ArsenHumby]

I mean, that's the gist of this porn game. The player character plays part in the sex stuff. Complaining about it is the same as complaining about how there isn't an option to tell Dr. Chuck to fuck off at the start. What is untrue is the assertion that the story turns on a dime and turns the player character into a whore.

He's already a whore by that point.

Irrespective of playing Kathleen's prop dick during the exhibition side of story, he became a whore the moment he accepted the job and compromised his values for money. There's no bait and switch there, because the game is about whores.

The Carnations, the player character's mother, and even Edwin himself.

Edwin is fairly set in stone for a player character. He's always hung up about his Mom's past as a porn star, he's a sadist at heart, and his heavy handed bloviating about being tested at the start is quickly answered by the scenario. It's pretty telling that the one time he outright rejects an exhibition task is when he perceives it posing as a personal risk.

The granularity in the player character's moral fiber comes from his choices along the way: how he treats the Carnations, how much he gets lost inside the role, and what he ultimately ends up doing pending a big come to God moment.

I get not digging the game because of being railroaded into being a wishy-washy hypocrite. In fact I'm surprised people seem as okay with it as they are. It's like shit or get off the horse, Edwin. Don't you know you're into a porn game? But ultimately that's just baked into premise, and is something I take less as actionable criticism and more as an incompatibility issue.

The beauty about this game to me it's that it feels real, it's not the typical big dicked Mc gets all bitches type of game. Even if the game has been out for a few years now i haven't feel like updates disappoint at all, narrarive wise it's an interesting story and one of the few where i ask myself 'what would i do if i was...'. Another point is we know this seems to not be a harem game or an incest one, so it avoids the cliches we are accustomed. Not trying to hate other projects here but since i started my adventure in adult games in 2016, i have come to hate what i loved and come to love what i hated . Drama and corruption are my bread and butter now. Anyways what i'm trying to say is beautiful game dev.