Hungover00

Engaged Member
Apr 29, 2023
2,610
3,205
I'm currently going Fck buddy route with Hana and Lover route with Mina. In the new update, we gonna have a meeting at Hana's show and while talking with Mina, both Mina and MC made weird thoughts and face tbh. MC rethinking about being jealous. Mina made pretty weird face when I tried to kiss her upstairs and reject. Even when talking about having a date, she also acted really weird. Idk if being in a relationship with both Hana and Mina gonna give any consequences or not, but if yes, then I'm gonna go with Mina from now
If it was like my playthrough (also fuck buddy and casual lover) Mina didn't want to be a dirty secret, so you take her back down to the crowd and kiss her there. Not exactly rocket surgery.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ffive and Ottoeight

ymy42

Newbie
Jun 12, 2020
55
75
It seems pretty familiar to date Mina and continue to fuck women in the club or outside...

Ian yes...
Are we any different from him by acting like this?
 

Hungnoxu

Newbie
Jun 6, 2019
20
2
It seems pretty familiar to date Mina and continue to fuck women in the club or outside...

Ian yes...
Are we any different from him by acting like this?
welp, I tried to reject outside club segs as much as possible knowing that... Still had to do the club activities for money tho
 
  • Like
Reactions: ymy42

Turret

Forum Fanatic
Jun 23, 2017
4,475
7,673
It seems pretty familiar to date Mina and continue to fuck women in the club or outside...

Ian yes...
Are we any different from him by acting like this?
Not a big problem, I normally keep Mina a close friend, nothing more. Have just one save for the threesome path, most are for other playthrough variants.
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,615
10,092
Well, guys, I did it again.

I've just updated my mini-guides:

- Pale Carnations not-so-side characters: a guide to house girls and patrons

- Pale Carnations story timeline, scene by scene

This latest ch4, part5 update covers week 3, thursday and friday (18th-19th june): there's a lot going on and we have many scenes with quite a few variations (more than in the previous update!).

(links in the OP as well)
 

Fapparition

Member
Dec 25, 2022
280
861
Can anyone explain me what was Mina thinking in the Hana's show part? Like, she made a pretty weird face when I tried to kiss her or talked about date. I love both Mina and Hana but the game wont let me get both without any consequences so I'm gonna go with Mina till the end.
I assume you're talking about
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
and
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
The reason for Mina being down at the first one is because she thought Edwin brought her upstairs to hide from the crowd so they could have some fun. She thought Edwin is afraid of the fact that their relationship status will be known publicly (to Ian specifically). Well, that's according to Edwin, at least.

The second one confuses me as well. To get it you need to kiss Mina publicly and then cheer up for Hana.
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,615
10,092
There was no kissing. I'm not even on Hana's path in this save. Maybe devs overlooked this moment
Hana is talking to Jerrica. And Mina is simply waiting that Hana & Jerrica end their charade.

What is Mina thinking about? my guess is that she's upset because Jerrica is a bit hostile towards her - that's the real reason why Hana is quarrelling with Jerrica.

edit:

Not so sure now. If Edwin doesn't kiss her, then she is not upset.
 
Last edited:

ffive

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 19, 2022
7,982
18,819
Hana is talking to Jerrica. And Mina is simply waiting that Hana & Jerrica end their charade.

What is Mina thinking about? my guess is that she's upset because Jerrica is a bit hostile towards her - that's the real reason why Hana is quarrelling with Jerrica.
Given the quote in the screenshot, iirc Jerrica is giving Hana shit about Edwin. Whether Edwin and Hana actually fuck or kiss in public is quite irrelevant here, Mina can still feel quite upset/insecure over the idea of "this guy i like is being discussed in the context of being close [friend] with another girl".

There was no kissing. I'm not even on Hana's path in this save. Maybe devs overlooked this moment
When you say "i'm not on Hana's path" do you mean Hana GF path or no interactions at all? Did Edwin in your game go on a "date" with Hana and/or fuck?
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,615
10,092
Given the quote in the screenshot, iirc Jerrica is giving Hana shit about Edwin. Whether Edwin and Hana actually fuck or kiss in public is quite irrelevant here, Mina can still feel quite upset/insecure over the idea of "this guy i like is being discussed in the context of being close [friend] with another girl".
Only if they kissed on stage.

Anyway, if they don't kiss, Mina is not upset/pensive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ffive

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,615
10,092
Just friends. Not FB, not GF. So when Edwin comes on stage he only 'sings', no kissing happens
As I said, this scene has 2 variations: Mina upset/pensive and Mina merrily amused.

If you hang out with her till the end, but you end up taking her at the bar instead of cheering for Hana, Mina won't be pensive: she will be amused by Jerrica and Hana.
 

Hungnoxu

Newbie
Jun 6, 2019
20
2
I assume you're talking about
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
and
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
The reason for Mina being down at the first one is because she thought Edwin brought her upstairs to hide from the crowd so they could have some fun. She thought Edwin is afraid of the fact that their relationship status will be known publicly (to Ian specifically). Well, that's according to Edwin, at least.

The second one confuses me as well. To get it you need to kiss Mina publicly and then cheer up for Hana.
Holy, true, why didnt I think up sth like that? I thought she was having a problem with Edwin being with Hana and Edwin was having a problem with admitting that hes jealous. Damn, hopefully theres gonna be more of Mina's contents in the future
 

lorntehpwnzor

New Member
Nov 18, 2019
10
19
Why is this game teasing Lucy so hard? I'm serious. First in the competition of Victoria vs Lucy Ian is the one that gets to fuck her. And she gets to lose vs Victoria degrading her to a side character. Then in the scene where MC gets drugged by Kathleen he gets to fuck Harper and Dalia while Lucy "only" does a blowjob then boobjob. The Lesbian scene with Harper is a missed opportunity for a three some. But I'm glad she got to make a little comeback at the art exhibition. Still no vaginal sex.
This probably has been brought up before, but I just had to rant.
 

balboa2151

Member
Jun 10, 2023
360
347
soooo...I would like to get everyone's reasoning on which Carnation that they would like to see win? My list is as follows...although Felicia is absolutely positively amazing, beautiful and magnificently sexy I'm not picking her to win because although she might have her reasons they are not good enough to make me feel sorry for her when she has everything...Veronica...although I feel very sorry for her losing her gym it just doesn't do it for me...it could be also because she's not feminine enough for me even though she is beautiful ang built well...Rosa is the woman I want to win the contest...her daughter is all that she has, her husband was a total asshole for leaving her with that debt, she's so gentle and caring( how she waits on the MC while staying at his house) and her body is perfect to me...in my lowly opinion Rosa is there because she has no other choice. I don't know what the developers have in mund going forward but although I adore Mina and Hana I would love the opportunity to be able to choose Rosa at the end. I would love to hear everyone elses opinions, choices and reasonings . Thanks
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: zandalari
4.80 star(s) 530 Votes