VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Maccabbee]

If the developer conquers his greed and moves to another platform where INCEST is possible, then yes.

I love how you think it's greedy to get paid to develop a game that has insane costs involved, in addition to a massive time commitment.

 

[Draim]

I love how you think it's greedy to get paid to develop a game that has insane costs involved, in addition to a massive time commitment.

THE GAME WOULDN'T HAVE GOTTEN ANY WORSE IF EDWIN HAD FUCKED HIS MOTHER.

 

[Maccabbee]

THE GAME WOULDN'T HAVE GOTTEN ANY WORSE IF EDWIN HAD FUCKED HIS MOTHER.

Say you're bitter without saying the word bitter?

 

[The Senior Perv]

THE GAME WOULDN'T HAVE GOTTEN ANY WORSE IF EDWIN HAD FUCKED HIS MOTHER.

Devs aren't just interested in incest, that's it. It's not their kink. Not every AVN needs to have us bang mommy/older-younger sis/auntie/cousin or any other family member.

And what do you mean by 'gotten any worse'? Pale Carnations is awesome. The worst thing about it is waiting during the development time.

 

[Draim]

Devs aren't just interested in incest, that's it. It's not their kink.

You've played this game, haven't you? HOW MANY TIMES HAVE THEY RAISED THE TOPIC OF EDWIN'S MOTHER BEING A WHORE? THAT EDWIN EVEN KEEPS HER VIDEOS WITH HIM. IS IT ALL JUST LIKE THAT? JUST TO TEASE? EVERYONE OBVIOUSLY WANTS INCEST.

 

[Maccabbee]

You've played this game, haven't you? HOW MANY TIMES HAVE THEY RAISED THE TOPIC OF EDWIN'S MOTHER BEING A WHORE? THAT EDWIN EVEN KEEPS HER VIDEOS WITH HIM. IS IT ALL JUST LIKE THAT? JUST TO TEASE? EVERYONE OBVIOUSLY WANTS INCEST.

You're wrong. Edwin has the videos, watches them, but he never masturbates to them. It's not attraction. It's the shock of the spectacle of seeing his mother doing that.

I'd say that is far more likely to be the cause of his sexual sadism than it is to lead to any incest. He wants to fuck Ian's mom, not his own.

 

[Draim]

You're wrong. Edwin has the videos, watches them, but he never masturbates to them. It's not attraction. It's the shock of the spectacle of seeing his mother doing that.

I'd say that is far more likely to be the cause of his sexual sadism than it is to lead to any incest. He wants to fuck Ian's mom, not his own.

Okay. Fuck it. Forget it.

 

[Julius Kingsley]

You've played this game, haven't you? HOW MANY TIMES HAVE THEY RAISED THE TOPIC OF EDWIN'S MOTHER BEING A WHORE? THAT EDWIN EVEN KEEPS HER VIDEOS WITH HIM. IS IT ALL JUST LIKE THAT? JUST TO TEASE? EVERYONE OBVIOUSLY WANTS INCEST.

Adding incest to the story at this point serves no purpose. I guess the devs did this to themselves by making her hot. Obviously everyone wants to see her get fucked. Personally I don’t care. I hope she stays a plot device and a moral anchor. The dev could always make an incest scene and sell it separately for everyone calling for it. Might as well make some money off it.

 

[Julius Kingsley]

Hi again!
I have read your commentaries so far and as I said, great to follow a new player what and how he sees the game. now that you are in quite a bit a question: Do you see why I consider Hana, Felicia and Sophia the most interesting female characters and LIs in the game, honorable mentioning of Vicki, Dalia and Andrea? Mina leads those who are interesting, but not as much as the earlier mentioned characters, like Kath, Rosi and Veronica.
Since we cannot have enough of them:
View attachment 4991752
View attachment 4991754
View attachment 4991756

Hi there. Felicia and Hana are my favorites right now. I haven’t seen much of Sophia yet. All I know is that she only does what Abel tells her, and Chuck wants to beat her for some sick reason. Mina was growing on me but her personality shift felt a little drastic so I’ll wait and see. I’m starting the Week 2 event tonight so I guess I still have a lot to see.

 

[Maccabbee]

Hi there. Felicia and Hana are my favorites right now. I haven’t seen much of Sophia yet. All I know is that she only does what Abel tells her, and Chuck wants to beat her for some sick reason. Mina was growing on me but her personality shift felt a little drastic so I’ll wait and see. I’m starting the Week 2 event tonight so I guess I still have a lot to see.

FYI: ALL of Chuck's reasons are sick. That's his whole personality.

 

[Julius Kingsley]

FYI: ALL of Chuck's reasons are sick. That's his whole personality.

Yeah, never liked him. Out of the three i prefer August. He's a piece of shit, but a piece of shit I can get behind.

 

[Maccabbee]

Yeah, never liked him. Out of the three i prefer August. He's a piece of shit, but a piece of shit I can get behind.

Yeah, but topping Kat is really fun!

 

[DETROIT123_io]

I am so happy that victoria got a animated scene . I wanna see her so much and what different things she did in the past . i dont mind if she gets fucked by someone in present time .

The scene appeared in my memories/replay section without happening in the game . Wierd

 

[DETROIT123_io]

Hi again!
I have read your commentaries so far and as I said, great to follow a new player what and how he sees the game. now that you are in quite a bit a question: Do you see why I consider Hana, Felicia and Sophia the most interesting female characters and LIs in the game, honorable mentioning of Vicki, Dalia and Andrea? Mina leads those who are interesting, but not as much as the earlier mentioned characters, like Kath, Rosi and Veronica.
Since we cannot have enough of them:
View attachment 4991752
View attachment 4991754
View attachment 4991756

I agree with your statement . Btw how is Vicky a LI?

 

[Turret]

I agree with your statement . Btw how is Vicky a LI?

Hi! Sorry, might have been a bit unclearly phrased. I meant the interesting female characters, both LIs and NPCs. Vicki will never be a LI, but she is one of the more intersting characters in the game.

 

[The Senior Perv]

Bonus Art: Iron Rose

This will become a transition image next update.

 

[Julius Kingsley]

I noticed this game has a lot of fans who care and discuss it daily, but there’s no wiki? You guys should start making one. It would be fun.

 

[Elduriel]

I noticed this game has a lot of fans who care and discuss it daily, but there’s no wiki? You guys should start making one. It would be fun.

eh it's not like it has a lore or anything like some fantasy games etc., don't really need a wiki for this

 

[Julius Kingsley]

eh it's not like it has a lore or anything like some fantasy games etc., don't really need a wiki for this

But there are a lot of characters, routes, and branches. And it's not something exclusive to fantasy games. BADIK, SG, WIAB.. they all have a wiki.

 

[Vic Sage]

Yeah, Hana is my favorite out of the two right now too. But I still want to see where it goes with Mina. Spoil me a little to quell my curiosity. Is the Mina lover thing exclusive on her part or not? Like, is there any indication she might start seeing other people to explore her fantasies more?

There is a scene where a guy hits on Mina and you decide how your MC feels about that.