ok, pros and cons?
pro: I like a "happy" harem game, where the goal is to win them over, and have it be a fun, mutual thing. And I like a MC who is a decent person, and the MC isn't out to hurt any of the girls, cares for them, and wants them to be happy. All good things, in my book.
I like a game where giving oral sex to the girls is something the MC is happy to do. In many games, he either doesn't at all, doesn't want to, does it insanely briefly, or it is depicted as a subservient thing to do. Personally, I'm a fan of "her pussy looks tasty. I'm gonna make her cum with her thighs wrapped around my head like a vice."
I like SOME character development. Sofi, for example. Hurt, looking to rebuild trust, wanting someone who can be a confidant and a mentor. The way her panic attacks were presented. It makes her less a "porn game character" and more just a "character," which is entirely the right direction.
I love the art. Some of the hyper-exaggeration that is common in porn game render art is not here, or toned down to more reasonable levels.
I love the branching narrative. I wish it were clearer how many branches there were, where they might lead, or if you could start one branch but move to another... as well as how much unique content each branch has. But I love a branching narrative because it feels more like you're actually in control of an outcome.
Cons? The pacing. You go from not seeing your ex in years to being back in the house with her, making an impression on your daughters, and then fucking her and moving in, in one day. I know people want to get into things and not be bogged down by a slow start, but progress with all the girls seems too fast.
Lack of character development. Your daughters have next to no personality before they fall for you, and then their personality is "I want to fuck daddy," where one is a gamer and more sexually innocent than your average 4 year old, and the other is... well, outside of the gym occasionally and being super sexually aggressive, I don't know what she is.
Bugs. Bath time with the older daughter when I took her virginity? She references "yesterday's bath." There was no bath the day before. Little things like that, where it seems some reference is made to something I never played through.
Inconsistent story telling. First Emily is teasing Elly about having a thing for me, and pressuring her to openly say "yes, I want to fuck daddy." Then she is shocked later when she thinks Elly has a thing for me. Ada knows what cheating is an understands impropriety, but doesn't know what semen is. Fuck Emily in the kitchen and my sister walks in and makes a crack about how it's no big deal, she's seen it all before, but then later Emily is shocked to be around her naked and our fling has to stay hidden from her. Wife makes reference to past incest on my part, and again, we can't expose the relationship between my sister and myself to her. Everyone knows the security cameras are up, and no one seems to consider that I record everything in the house and see them all sleep, masturbate, fuck, piss, shit, shower, etc.
Look, I like it. I want to wait, significantly, before downloading updates (probably wait a half dozen updates or so), so I get a lot more content and not a smidgen of new content, but I do plan to keep following this game. I did have fun playing it, and I look forward to coming back to it. But, especially in character development, this game could use a lot of work.
Do I recommend it? Yes.
Does it have potential? Yes.
Do I think it could be as good as the art and aspects of the writing suggest it should be? No, sadly. I'm sure I'll still enjoy the end product, though.
