Okay, IF you hadnt played the game at all and saw this What If, I'd say it was pretty hot. BUT having played the game already and having been over the moon over the previous Hunter/Brenna scene, I thought it was... alright. Which isnt WWG's fault honestly, it was written well and animated well, I guess it just didnt hit me well cause this what if is so much like something I've already seen.
I think in the future What If?'s should be scenarios that are much less likely to happen in the main storyline OR another chance at a scene that didnt go as far as it should or as well as most wanted (cough cough *a certain tiny redhead and a wrinkly old fart*). Just my thoughts though, from what I've read I hear the gold patrons decide the topics, but if he gave them three to choose from he could gain some control over the situation