Ghostboy031

Active Member
Jan 2, 2019
563
890
Is it because the spin offs have NTR?

I was wondering this, but why did the thread add NTR to the title? That title is not there in the what if. It's just adding negative attention and misleading the main game. The thread title is always updated to match the name of the file's update. In this case just "what if vol 7". So why was the NTR added when the dev didn't name it that way?

I was wondering if a mod can remove that from the thread title. It would stop a lot of people from thinking the game just turned full NTR.
Or people could you know......read the game description?
 

ScareKing

Member
May 27, 2017
287
243
By the way, I would be more than happy to see more of Peyton in almost any context. I'm happy to have her join the MC's harem, although I'm not sure there's any reasonable way that would happen, unless maybe it involved her getting to be with Tiff.
I'm getting ideas for What Ifs now, too... Peyton and Drew double teaming, heh. 6 boobs + 2 dicks = 1 glorious Tiff sandwich.
Same, i think Peyton and Drew would be nice additions, and Peyton and Drew double teaming any girl would be realy nice, maybe we see something like that in What Ifs but i dont believe we going to see Peyton in "action" out of that.
 

bigguy_foryou

Well-Known Member
Jun 8, 2018
1,104
971
It literally says there is an OFF switch..... so if people see NTR that's on them and their stupidity and deserve it.
Not before you click on the game it doesn't. If you're just seeing it appear under latest updates and have never seen the game before all it says is the title, "Power Vacuum [What If... Vol. 7 NTR] [What? Why? Games]". And people not interested in NTR are just not going to bother clicking.
 

acewinz

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Oct 15, 2018
2,554
7,476
In the Main Game, Hunter has been described by the developer as a Wile E. Coyote type character, always chasing the girls and instead ending up failing (and increasingly getting injured in comedic ways). The NTR is restricted to the Bad Ends which are by nature designed to be pretty easily avoidable but can also be fully deactivated never to be seen again. There is NO on-going story route that allows for NTR, only Bad Ends.

The What Ifs are voted on, and the NTR fans keep winning the votes. There is, I believe, ONE What If to date that is not NTR, where Sterling embraces his role as harem master and goes hog wild with all the women in sight.

The idea that development time is being taken away from the main game to produce the What If episodes has been repeatedly refuted by the dev along with an explanation of why that's not true, but some people (mostly people who really REALLY hate NTR) refuse to believe him. This has been made worse by the fact the the last few updates to the main game have gradually taken longer to complete. However, that fact was predicted and we were warned about it. The official stance of the dev is that the updates are taking longer because they are bigger, include more girls each time, and have more animations. The official explanation from the dev on why the What If episodes do not cause a delay is that he always had a set work schedule for development of the main game, which he has stuck to, and the work he is putting into the What Ifs he is doing during what had previously been his days off.

EDIT: To be clear, there is metric ton of non-NTR content in this game, most of it beautifully animated. It's one of the hottest games I've ever played. It is also written to be comedic a lot of the time. I personally do NOT like feeling helpless to avoid rivals and NTR, but I never feel that way while playing this. Hunter never feels like a real threat to me in the same way as the NTR threat characters in a lot of other games. He is essentially a parody of NTR characters. He is a hideous buffoon that the women have no interest in romantically and are not attracted to at all. He is a creep that is always lurking, but as long as you follow the story and don't watch the optional and easily avoided NTR Bad Ends, he consistently comes off as comedic foil with ridiculous schemes that constantly backfire in humorous ways.
That is one way to look at it. I just want to say that I like Power Vacuum overall, and was an early supporter because of the comedy, quality, and heartfelt moments with the cast and MC. I even thought the initial method of including optional "parody" NTR funny and innovative compared to the other versions out there, but just initially. It has become something else now. It started as a little "light hearted", relatively, way of including the fetish, while not really denigrating (my main concern) the characters, because it starts with short instance brought about through drugs or trickery of the girls and a MC who choose that path, and like you say restricted to "bad ends". But it "evolved" unfortunately... obviously because of how much money it is bringing in.

While "non-canon", the characters themselves stay in character during the bad ends and the what-if's, meaning that pretty much every female character in the game not only has the potential to become a relatively mindless cock-sleeve, but does so far more easily for the NTR scenarios (albeit, not as easily as your typical NTR), even when initially there is an excuse/lever to push them into it it is still very damaging to their characters as far as the main game is considered imho, especially in their treatment of Sterling in many of the scenarios. One canon part of the game itself that is proof that this is more of a multi-verse reality than random bad ends, is the fact the Gramps did to the MC's dad and his immediate family exactly what happens to the MC in the NTR situations. The MC never has (as is usual with NTR), an easier road (which is realistic, but hardly fair compared to the NTR).

Then add in all the girls first times going all the way, are almost always NTR, and you cannot tell me as a developer that a considerable portion of time and resources (rendering alone!) that could be spent on the main game are not instead being spent on the "What-if's" to bring in more cash overall across a longer development time, at a determent to the main game for vanilla players. I am quite positive the overall content NTR-vs non, is probably pretty even all together, but for a game where that started as non-canon side stuff... that doesn't seem to be the case now. There is also the potentially darker aspect I worry about, that everything happening in the main line of the game, is just a method for Gramps to train Sterling into being a new kind of seducer, one that uses feelings rather than drugs to achieve the same ends. Which while better, is still in it's own way a subversion of the "battle" between the two. Just a theory, but a scary one.

It is what it is and you do what you do as a developer to make a game profitable within your desired wheelhouse, and this is an interesting game. But you are putting a bit more sugar on it all than is fair I think.
 

Fuxxzz

Member
Dec 26, 2018
340
369
Oh god, we are back to the same shit that happens every update. The eternal vanilla vs NTR discussion.
 

acewinz

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Oct 15, 2018
2,554
7,476
Oh god, we are back to the same shit that happens every update. The eternal vanilla vs NTR discussion.
On the contrary, if you read what I put, while I don't like it's implications on the characters, I just think it takes time away from the development of the main game. It's become a new form of milking it honestly.
 

SuddenReal

Well-Known Member
Jun 21, 2017
1,492
2,232
One canon part of the game itself that is proof that this is more of a multi-verse reality than random bad ends, is the fact the Gramps did to the MC's dad and his immediate family exactly what happens to the MC in the NTR situations.
Newsflash: antagonist who's been boasting he's done the same before is proven to have done the same before.
Then add in all the girls first times going all the way, are almost always NTR, and you cannot tell me as a developer that a considerable portion of time and resources (rendering alone!) that could be spent on the main game are not instead being spent on the "What-if's" to bring in more cash overall across a longer development time, at a determent to the main game for vanilla players.
You're mixing two different things. One is the bad endings of the main game, and the other are What Ifs, of which has been clearly stated before that there will be no sex with women who haven't had sex yet in the main game. So, to adress both points, the bad endings are part of the game. That's what makes the game. Second, it's been said time and time again, that the What Ifs are made in WWG's spare time, and thus don't take time away from development.
I am quite positive the overall content NTR-vs non, is probably pretty even all together, but for a game where that started as non-canon side stuff... that doesn't seem to be the case now.
No, it's still the case. NTR is only in the bad endings, of which there are two each chapter. The rest of the game is filled with non-NTR stuff, which includes more than two girls. So no, it's not "pretty even".
 

paginou

Member
Nov 20, 2018
149
144
Why... because when you attract a certain audience, in this case harem fans, and then add something like ntr, the direct antithesis, along the line, you have gone against what your core audience wants. Either you do both courses from the beginning or you don't do it at all. Look at what happened to Foot of the Mountains. Dev added a route into the game, and people were understandably pissed off. You can't cultivate a harem audience, then shoot the old switcheroo and expect it to go well.
 

What? Why? Games

Member
Game Developer
Sep 4, 2019
261
4,351
Why... because when you attract a certain audience, in this case harem fans, and then add something like ntr, the direct antithesis, along the line, you have gone against what your core audience wants. Either you do both courses from the beginning or you don't do it at all. Look at what happened to Foot of the Mountains. Dev added a route into the game, and people were understandably pissed off. You can't cultivate a harem audience, then shoot the old switcheroo and expect it to go well.
NTR was always a part of the game.
 

OnlyWorthyDevsMakeMoney

Well-Known Member
Oct 31, 2021
1,109
1,343
On the contrary, if you read what I put, while I don't like it's implications on the characters, I just think it takes time away from the development of the main game. It's become a new form of milking it honestly.
It has been said plenty of times that the WhatIfs don't interfere with the development of the main game.
Imagine that, you work 8 hours a day in an office, then, when you leave, you work elsewhere.
It's the same thing.
The dev works on whatifs only when his daily quota for the main game has been reached.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Cavpal

acewinz

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Oct 15, 2018
2,554
7,476
Newsflash: antagonist who's been boasting he's done the same before is proven to have done the same before.

You're mixing two different things. One is the bad endings of the main game, and the other are What Ifs, of which has been clearly stated before that there will be no sex with women who haven't had sex yet in the main game. So, to adress both points, the bad endings are part of the game. That's what makes the game. Second, it's been said time and time again, that the What Ifs are made in WWG's spare time, and thus don't take time away from development.

No, it's still the case. NTR is only in the bad endings, of which there are two each chapter. The rest of the game is filled with non-NTR stuff, which includes more than two girls. So no, it's not "pretty even".
Looks like you missed my first point.

Second point, I don't believe the "What-if's" are just a spare time thing. Even when I have seen they often reuse content from the main game to set the scene. Maybe I'm wrong, it happens.

Third, when taking the What-if's and main game together, yeah I feel it is pretty even, but just mho.

Oh god, we are back to the same shit that happens every update.
Sorry if it is a recurring issue. Just my two cents as a former patreon.

NTR was always a part of the game.
True, but it has become more of a focus since the inception. I understand that is what your audience seems to want if they keep winning votes for it and it is as much the fault of us former supporters for not sticking around to sway the votes. It is not an easy genre to mix and while I think it was a good effort, for me personally I just prefer it more separate. Different game/characters separate with some other proviso's, but this is your vision.
 
4.20 star(s) 368 Votes