Fayn Arawn

Well-Known Member
May 24, 2019
1,166
2,449
1) The Brenna Ophelia Hunter one I'd like to point out seems shot on his Balcony? If this is the "Final Solution" ending, so to speak, then we can strike out the "switches bodies with Sterling" possibility, since he would be doing this in Sterling's room (if we assume we as the audience can still see his "real" body in the sex scene). This is most definitely that bad ending tho if we are to assume all plot lines have been spoiled, but we still have no idea how we got there to begin with.

Especially since, again, Hunter hasn't set foot in his room ever since Drew showed up, and if we have to assume What If 7 is SOMEWHAT Canon in the way the characters interact (IE, Hunter considers Drew transitioning into becoming a woman akin to "losing his heir and son" so to speak (Hence Ophelia not wanting to hear her father talk like that about Drew in the massage bad ending (as well as not wanting to hear him talk shit about her mom either), in a classic "Cis Parent of Trans Kid" shit scenario), then he and Drew probably didn't leave on the best of terms after she "let him down" by deciding to become a woman after discovering herself.

This to say, for him to be on that Balcony to face fucks Ophelia and Brenna while drinking wine, things have to have changed enough that he feels 1) Safe enough not to expect Sterling to tackle him off the balcony and 2) Not to have Drew to interrupt him.

Which means, btw, removing Sterling from the equation, and not expect Lucia to retaliate in their cold war for removing her main fix for cock (And let's face it, even if she needed another source, I'm pretty sure she'd still pick Drew over Hunter any day given how she ticks way more kinks for her than him).
Yeah, that's the balcony outside Hunter's room. I don't have a clue how the situation unfolded, but I'm kinda hoping the ladies get bent over the railing and are witnessed from below!

The body swap theory has pretty much been shot down by WWG himself, saying on Discord that it'd be redundant after Hunter has impersonated Sterling earlier in the game.

2) Tiff's one is weird. Like, it looks a bit too "zany," don't know how to put it, he might be just sneaking up on her after asking for a "health check up" so to speak but then why not use the new Nurse character for that too? She isn't in her maid uniform either so she isn't cleaning for him, the context is missing.
She's seems to be giving Sterling a weird look, as if to say "are you feeling ok?" Maybe Hunter is hiding, or Sterling is hallucinating his presence?

3) You'd expect someone smothering Catherine with her breasts not to be part of a NTR ending, especially since the breasts are too white to be Drew's, yet here it is. Place is too well lit to be during the date night, so I'm assuming this is happening at Rebecca's farm, probably leading to the dog misdirection. So, like, is her Grandmother fucking Catherine then? Why would that be NTR?
Catherine is upside down in her own bedroom (based on the floor behind her), looking up past her boobs at somebody, possibly hanging from them.

3) The Brenna/Drew thing is one of those "could mean anything" scenarios honestly. Like, especially with Drew, she seems almost shocked in getting an erection there to begin with. Brenna also seems to be venting to her about something, which I am assuming probably happens in relation to something you make Sterling do, and probably because Drew is a psychologist and couple counselor, meaning she's probably seeking her professional help maybe.

I am still a firm "Drew isn't Evil she's Morally Grey at best" truther, so I'll srtick to that for now, my best guess is either the vents are doing their thing (get it, vents filling them with sex drugs while Brenna is "venting"? While Drew might be an IMPOSTOR? LIKE AMOGUS?).

Or maybe not even that, like...

Ok, Brenna and Sterling meet Drew's new Girlfriend, "Brenna's past," so to speak. She was probably one of her old high school classmates or some shit.

Now, you hear her and Drew banging loudly in Hunter's room while downstairs with Brenna, this might lead to the two of them also fucking, who knows, be as it may, at some point the new girl will try to fuck Sterling, probably while he's expected to do something NON SEXUAL with Brenna, and you can accept or not.

If you do accept, you get a sex scene with some random ass girl. Now, let's assume, for the sake of argument, that the thing the MC was supposed to do with Brenna was talk with Drew about their relationship but on a professional capacity (maybe without revealing to her the discussion it's about them, who knows), and since the MC is getting late cause he's fucking the random girl, she starts venting with Drew about him.

As she vents, the vents start venting too, followed by Drew growing hard in a combination of Brenna talking about fucking her brother, the vents, and maybe also overhearing Sterling fucking her Girlfriend downstairs (another reason for Brenna's vent, since she knows she shouldn't feel jealous or bad about it but she still feels like shit because he prioritized some random new girl over something she stressed was important for her).

Hence Brenna Drew sex scene to get over/get one over Sterling.
Hey, you've got two #3's!

Keep in mind that Drew can summon an erection at will (as demonstrated in the chapter 10 bad end with Tiff). Just a possibility: I think after talking with Brenna about all the unexplained horniness in the house, Drew may purposefully display a boner and be like "oh no, it's affecting me too!" and ask Brenna to "help" her get it under control.
 

dartred

Forum Fanatic
Game Developer
Aug 30, 2017
4,573
8,799
it's the new save on the front page and not a patch you copy and pasted from the last update?
 

edison23

Newbie
Mar 15, 2021
15
4
it's the new save on the front page and not a patch you copy and pasted from the last update?
I downloaded What if Vol 8 and it said that a patch is required so I thought that it might be the uncensored patch from lewdpatcher I clicked on it and downloaded it then installed it into my game folder and it still told me the message. I also looked at the save file from the extras and it only game me stuff from the main game
 

edison23

Newbie
Mar 15, 2021
15
4
I downloaded What if Vol 8 and it said that a patch is required so I thought that it might be the uncensored patch from lewdpatcher I clicked on it and downloaded it then installed it into my game folder and it still told me the message. I also looked at the save file from the extras and it only game me stuff from the main game
Nvm I managed to make it work
 

dartred

Forum Fanatic
Game Developer
Aug 30, 2017
4,573
8,799
oh, that's good. What did you end up doing to fix it? Just so i can have knowledge for the next guy who has problems.
 

SuddenReal

Well-Known Member
Jun 21, 2017
1,579
2,417
I got you:
Thanks. So, let's see... Topless pictures... Fake e-mail account... only thing that "clearly" states a physical affair is David's response of "I can't wait to have you inside me". That's the one that should be open for interpretation. And still I believe it somehow is. I'm sure the story will twist someway to show it was a sitcom level of miscommunication. After all, it's specifically mentioned that David responded to one. We didn't get the "I can't wait" e-mail from a random response, but from the one that Sterling checked out BECAUSE David responded. So, this seems a pretty one sided relationship.

I know, I know, it seems I'm grasping at straws, but let's be honest, most fan theories about anything really are based on less (see the "Drew is actually a good guy and will fall for Sterling and be his bottom" theories).
 

Fayn Arawn

Well-Known Member
May 24, 2019
1,166
2,449
Thanks. So, let's see... Topless pictures... Fake e-mail account... only thing that "clearly" states a physical affair is David's response of "I can't wait to have you inside me". That's the one that should be open for interpretation. And still I believe it somehow is. I'm sure the story will twist someway to show it was a sitcom level of miscommunication. After all, it's specifically mentioned that David responded to one. We didn't get the "I can't wait" e-mail from a random response, but from the one that Sterling checked out BECAUSE David responded. So, this seems a pretty one sided relationship.

I know, I know, it seems I'm grasping at straws, but let's be honest, most fan theories about anything really are based on less (see the "Drew is actually a good guy and will fall for Sterling and be his bottom" theories).
We've seen enough plot twists to know that anything could happen, but I will be astonished if Sterling is misinterpreting the emails, because there's a preponderance of evidence:

"Waiting for you lover" - The use of the term "lover" implies physical intimacy.

TexAveryWolf@hushmail(dot)com - First there's reference to the classic cartoon character known for lustful reactions, then there's an email service that sounds intended for discreet communication.

Topless Photo - This is pretty damning, especially attached to the aforementioned "lover" email.

"I can't wait to have you inside me" - This almost seems too obvious. By itself I could see this as an unfortunately worded reference to Drew using her therapy skills to get "inside" David's mind.

So yeah, after all of that, I'm taking the emails at face value. I also think the affair serves a narrative function in severing any remaining emotional attachment Ophelia may have to David, clearing the way for Sterling to fully replace him.

"Does mom know?" - Sterling asks himself an interesting question. If David was having an affair, and Ophelia knew about it, what would she have done? Hide it from her children while attempting to save her marriage?
 
Last edited:

TrueJackal

Active Member
Jul 7, 2020
978
1,226
I'm with you here. It always make me wonder "how do they pee ? Do they do it standing up, or sitting down ? If the latter, do they have to wipe their balls afterwards :unsure:"
The writer decides if they pee from one hole, both, or if they can switch it at will.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Hermit76

FoolishFool0

Member
Nov 19, 2017
312
425
I mean, without getting into complicated discussions about gender ideology and intersex people and all that stuff, I think it's safe to assume if a AFAB person who presents as Female but who gets herself a cock via magical, supernatural, or parascientific means, either by her own will, by accident, or because of it is forced on her, all specifically so she can tie it to sexual intercourse and reproduction, then it all depends if whatever stuff grew her cock to begin with also happened to alter more of her internal phisyology.

This to say, is her cock now "connected" to her kidneys, or is it a vestigial limb not connected to the rest of the body, some sort of parasitic body attached to them? It should be a case by case thing, especially since most classic Futanari designs have the cock usually grow, with no balls, from the woman's clitoris, thus separated from her biological urethra.

Either way in the case of Ophelia it's the later, the cock literally only grew because she cannibalized and made grow her unborn son inside of her due to the pill, thus developing the "parassite" cock, so I'm 90% sure she would pee from her pussy.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Puma1978

PBS666

Engaged Member
Feb 19, 2019
3,262
3,073
Either way in the case of Ophelia it's the later, the cock literally only grew because she cannibalized and made grow her unborn son inside of her due to the pill, thus developing the "parassite" cock, so I'm 90% sure she would pee from her pussy.
So that means the urinary tract in her penis only serves for ejaculating her seminal fluid ? Certainly an acceptable theory.
But now I wonder, where does that seminal fluid come from ? Did she grow a prostate gland as well ?
So many questions...
 

Puma1978

Well-Known Member
Feb 25, 2022
1,632
2,093
I see the Futa nonsense episode is triggering a lot of rational thinking ...:)
I stay with Transgender is okay but Futa is nonsense ...i even dont know who has invented them.
There is a nice Dev (Sumatra 3D) in this forum just just working on a legal Fan- What If episode with original Devs blessing ...without Futanari.
Hope he is doing well and we can play it soon...i follow him on discord and he will release a Fan Episode Ophelia's Date Night hopefully next week.
 

Talmadge

Engaged Member
May 7, 2018
2,039
1,594
I just realized that I never played What If 7. Started it, but it's the beginning of the main game. Is it supposed to start that way? Or did I mistakingly DL the main game and put it as number 7? I'm confused. LoL
 

SonsOfLiberty

Discussion Dynamo
Compressor
Sep 3, 2022
26,580
234,672
I just realized that I never played What If 7. Started it, but it's the beginning of the main game. Is it supposed to start that way? Or did I mistakingly DL the main game and put it as number 7? I'm confused. LoL
It looks like it does, but after a few minutes the "new challenger" arrives and goes from there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Talmadge

ScareKing

Member
May 27, 2017
291
247
I just realized that I never played What If 7. Started it, but it's the beginning of the main game. Is it supposed to start that way? Or did I mistakingly DL the main game and put it as number 7? I'm confused. LoL
What Ifs works like, what would happen if something was different, so its "normal" to see a couple of scenes from the main game, and what ifs 7 and 8 need to use a patch to turn off the censor.
 

SuddenReal

Well-Known Member
Jun 21, 2017
1,579
2,417
I stay with Transgender is okay but Futa is nonsense ...i even dont know who has invented them.
That... that would be God... Although I doubt the rare natural occuring person with both genitals are as sexy (and well hung) as Hentai proclaims them to be.
 
4.10 star(s) 388 Votes