- Nov 14, 2017
- 66,681
- 33,615
still quite a long ago.I had to do some research but it was in the episode when Carmen got him a bottle of Blood in the bath tub
still quite a long ago.I had to do some research but it was in the episode when Carmen got him a bottle of Blood in the bath tub
Not sure why you feel the insult is necessary but I suspect you addressed what I said earlier because I used the expression NTR. But I am not talking about the sexual kink, but the fact that there is a strong bond between Sharon and Astrid, possibly at the expense of the MC. And I think there is in fact desire involved, in the sense that the inner beast is driven by carnal desires and that Sharon had to center herself after being confronted with Astrid the first time. It's more that loss of control, the ability of Astrid to bring Sharon out of balance and manipulate her despite Sharons best efforts to prevent that. I'd like to know more about the nature of their former relationship and what lever Astrid is using to have that effect on Sharon. It's a mystery so far.Some morons have tried to attribute various kinks to the story
Yeah. Thanks but no thanks. I'm here to comment on and enjoy this VN. Unless the writers decide to direct us at outside sources to which this world they've created adhere, I'm really not interested in endless speculation about how this story might fit with various vampire mythologies, novels, games, or game systems. You're not trying to figure out the plot lines presented here. You're trying to reverse engineer the structure and fabric that the writers developed to create this VN. Plot lines are analyzed based on the content and plot presented in the writing, no speculating about which parts of other writing they may have based their writing on.Several good comments in this latest batch.
c3p0 I don't think this is 6 pages
...
Just do this please, REALLY, please at least read the story, go to the VtM wiki and read the synopsis, look up ancient Greek and Sumerian mythology, if you really want to try and tear down the plot lines we are all working on trying to figure out. Those sources will at least let you make intelligent additions to the conversation.
Peace
Several good comments in this latest batch.
c3p0 I don't think this is 6 pages
The fight....
It will be a big bad assed fur ball in my opinion. Ereskigal will not directly be involved, she will invoke her bloodline powers and force the Nos to turn on the Scottstown crew. There might be some extras in that battle, as Virgil could be in town. Eloise is in town. Malia and Glitter could well be in town, Glitter is for sure...I think it is safe to assume Fabian is gone, and Cindy, Astrid (if you gave her up) and Calisto of course. So it could quite literally be the Nos against all others, or the Nos and add ons against all the Scottstown crew. I think there is a small chance that Frank and Merrick might fight for the Scottstown crew, but I would not want to bet on it.
I am leaning against a direct intervention by Virgil unless he sees a value in saving the MC's life, which I do not think he really does except for the possibility of exposing Calisto again. He could have other agents in town though, we shall see I guess.
Scottstown crew is going to get it's ass kicked. That means deaths.- Laurie is definitely going to die in this. Will she be brought back by Sharon? That goes back to the variable we keep discussing. I think that Laurie going down is going to shred the MC mentally and emotionally, and he is definitely going to get more soul stain if you have developed his powers properly. Truthfully I think it will be a pretty powerful moment that is going to reveal to any survivors just how big a deal Calisto and her childer are. Think is in the middle of this fight, if he opens the power of speed/celerity up. Add that to Claws, Invisibility, Vicious Strength, Whispers, his obvious psychic visions, his heightened senses.... he is going to be a nightmare.
I could be completely wrong.... The MC might not do any of the above. If he has not gotten the powers, then he will use the dagger. A smarter move for him is to give the dagger to Sharon, and use his powers.
Sharon will be taken out of the fight if she has a high SharonSavesLaurie score. She will be saving Laurie.
Andrew is going to kill shit until he goes down... that could happen. Think of the cost to Sharon if she has to choose to save Laurie due to her love of the MC, or Andrew her friend and faithful servant.
Ivy is not going to be much help I am thinking... probably in shock at seeing all the crazy shit.
If Frank and Merrick switch sides then it would still be poor odds. If they don't then it is going to basically be Andrew and the MC breaking bad. That is my bet.
Outline of fights in Rebirth-
1- The woods. Something brushed past Sharon and nearly killed her, forcing her to feed on the MC's blood. This was planned and the thing was most likely Calisto herself as she has the most skill and control over her powers and could scrape Sharon and put her down. Now Sharon is probably unnaturally tough, like a Fortitude power, which would fit what I believe her VtM clan equivalent is, which is Ventrue. She has Presence, some increased senses, and her Domination (eyes) thing.
2- Feral Nos. I believe the Feral Nos was the last survivor from the bunker, and served as a blood slave for Ereshkigal until she was driven insane, which cost her a lot of her powers, and drove her to that feral state. I think she was Markus' sire.
3- Hunters vs MC. Hunters lost either due to you developing your powers and beating their asses, or Andrew rescuing you.
4- Merrick's ill fated attempt to attack the MC. Vicious Strength is a bitch.
5- This update. I "Think" this will be all the Nos vs basically Andrew, Laurie, Sharon and the MC. Ivy probably not a combat monster in the least, though she was sensitive to the presence in the cave.... that does make her interesting.
6- Virgil vs Calisto round 2. Probably epic. Probably lots of fatalities. Not Calisto. Not the MC. Could have some initial smackdowns on Marcius by the MC, which would be satisfying.
7- Ereshkigal rising- blood bath
8- Inanna rising- blood bath
(7 and 8 ideally would occur roughly at the same time, or it will not be pretty... well fuck that, it is not going to be pretty regardless lol)
9- The sisters duke it out. All bets are off on survivors..... (Calisto, MC, Sharon, Carmen, Laurie, Ivy, and all the mortals, Fabian,Cindy, Roland, and all the Archons, are all on the block.... who knows who lives)
Change of topic.....
Sharon has the wrong view of ghouls/thralls. Yes Andrew is in fact stronger than a normal human and functions as the mule quite often. He is also a veteran of WW2 based on age calculations and his military knowledge and weapon skills.
He is not more powerful than Laurie.
Laurie already has heightened senses, several examples of that, and yes, Andrew wear sunglasses at night, but if he had Auspex like powers it would not impede him. Laurie is stronger than her build would otherwise indicate. She is also probably more durable.
She has high intuition which likely comes from the visionary gene if you want to call it that. She also has been fed more frequently than Andrew during the course of the story. Sharon starves him to try and keep him as human and independent as possible, but he is lacking in many powers he could have picked up in 70 years of service.
Some morons have tried to attribute various kinks to the story, because they refuse to understand the explanations or just are not getting it. This is a story about vampires and a war between two big bloodlines, with some extras thrown in. It is not written as a sex novel. Never has been the intent.
Misogyny is not present except in certain characters. They two most powerful vampires in the game (and contenders for the world) are females. Carmen, who would have been useful to bring, is a strong female, and I am betting, she becomes the MC's childe. Sharon is nominally in charge of Scottstown, even though we know that the MC really is. There are several powerful women in this novel, and it bears repeating Calisto, Inanna, Ereshkigal, are women, and are the top 3 powers in this game.
To address the wouldn't it be great if Laurie was XYZ, well, yeah it would be better for her in all likelihood to remain the ghoul/thrall of the MC for a long time instead of being a relatively weaker bloodline's vampire...... It would be cool if I could find the USB key I have 1000 bitcoins on too.... but too many moves and that fucker was lost. Laurie will either die, or she will be Sharon's childe. I am betting all my gonads on that.
I predict that no matter how this fight plays out, there will be people who want to argue about it.
I am good with that, as long as it stays civil. Through civil disagreement we might refine the theories about where we are going.
Just do this please, REALLY, please at least read the story, go to the VtM wiki and read the synopsis, look up ancient Greek and Sumerian mythology, if you really want to try and tear down the plot lines we are all working on trying to figure out. Those sources will at least let you make intelligent additions to the conversation.
Peace
While that is true
With all of us speculating in episode 2 what generation MC was.
We all basically came to the conclusion that MC is a 5th generation. Like with 99% certainty.
While Sharon and Astrid were 13th generation The only thing we thought was that Markus was definitely the biggest threat to us
Since Virgil or the other chars were not introduced yet
Vision girl is likely 2nd generation but im not that good with greek Mythology while Arigon can explain it better then meSorry if you've answered these questions before feel free to just link me your previous answers. Maybe I missed something because I haven't replayed the game so Act 1/2 is pretty faded in my memory but who is Inanna? The girl you see in the visions? I guess the thing in the water is Ereshkigal (did they use that name in game? I don't remember seeing it).
Why would Virgil and Calisto fight? I didn't know they hated each other. If they hated each other why wouldn't they have fought any time in the past idk 1000 years as opposed to now? I mean it doesn't seem like either of them are hiding from the other and if they hate each other that much shouldn't something have happened already?
Okay so you're saying that MC is 5th gen so Calisto is 4th gen. From what I've read on the VTM wiki that's extremely low gen, there's not a whole lot of room left. Given that LikesBlondes said the "vision girl" is so much older than Calisto that she's basically a legend like Calisto is to Sharon and co. wouldn't that mean the "vision girl" is like 1st or 2nd gen?
Why would a 1st or 2nd gen insanely powerful vamp care about Calisto's random new childe?
Hmmm well the generation timing of vampires doesn't make a whole lot of sense, what did the 5th generation somehow just decide not to embrace anybody for 700 years?Vision girl is likely 2nd generation but im not that good with greek Mythology while Arigon can explain it better then me
Below i posted a basic list of generation and a time line of when they were created * Generation Wise
|*Generation*| Date of Embrace*|*Major Event*|
1. |14th|Yesterday| *
2. |13th|2000 AD| *
3. |12th|1950 AD| WWII
4. |11th|1900 AD| WWI
5. |10th|1800 AD| *
6. |9th|1700 AD | *
7. |8th|1500 AD| Columbian Exchange, End of the Reconquista|
8. |7th|1300 AD| Black Plague|
9. |6th|900 AD|| *
10. |5th|200 AD| Fall of Rome|
11. |4th|2500 BC| The Flood|
12. |3rd| ????|BC ?????
About your Question on why She would care about Calisto's new Child.
Like Ancient Vampires have to power to influence other vampires.
See with the creature (Ereshkigal) We saw in the cave she could influence the nos to bring her food.
So basically She has some influence over you. What we are basically thinking. What She is doing with MC is, Basically running a rescue mission.
To rescue herself from the underworld by killing her Sister Ereshkigal
Just use the timescale as a reference for a standart when most of these generations where created. If we take MC presumed 5th gen as example, that would mean most of the 5 gen are several thausand years old, doesn't change one thing about the MC, except that most other 5th gen would have a large advantage in age, experience, powerbase(minions, wealth, politics) ect.Hmmm well the generation timing of vampires doesn't make a whole lot of sense, what did the 5th generation somehow just decide not to embrace anybody for 700 years?
Calisto has in all likelihood no fucking clue that there is a such a powerfull vamp in there.That's weird but that aside okay so the influence part makes sense but what exactly does she expect the MC to do? Like if Ereshkigal is 2nd generation than she'd be way out of the MC's league and even Calisto's league in theory. I guess she'll scheme up something. Anyway thanks for clearing that up for me.
You don't remember seeing it, because neither has been named in the game. The VTM fans merely speculate those are their identities & generation/power. In fact we don't know yet who they are, how old they are, how powerful they are, or what their broader agendas are.Maybe I missed something ... but who is Inanna? ... I guess the thing in the water is Ereshkigal (did they use that name in game? I don't remember seeing it).
In game they aren't fighting & don't hate each other per se, again that's just speculation. They're likely competitors, because they're from different power structures (city gov. vs temple) but there's been no signs of open conflict between these individuals or groups in game.Why would Virgil and Calisto fight? I didn't know they hated each other.
We don't know why vision girl is linked to the MC, it's yet to be explained in game.Given that LikesBlondes said the "vision girl" is so much older than Calisto that she's basically a legend like Calisto is to Sharon and co. wouldn't that mean the "vision girl" is like 1st or 2nd gen?
Why would a 1st or 2nd gen insanely powerful vamp care about Calisto's random new childe?
Arigon Yes that's certainly true, the problem is your assumption that refers to vision girl. If anything it could more aptly apply to the thing in the water? The MC is asking Frode about his visions of the cave, rather than vision girls dreams (which he hasn't mentioned to anyone iirc). And Frode talks about Inanna struggling to escape, which the big bad is doing more so than vision girl. Conversely it could be refering to vision girl as the ultimate source of the visions (of the cave etc.). Assuming it's not a general reference to the continued existence of ancients. As I said, until they actually name the characters in game we don't know who they are.@Meushi Inanna is mentioned by name by the Skalds when Sharon and the MC visit. Tiamat also. Just correcting a small error in your post above.
I meant it didn't make sense in that generations should be roughly the same number of years apart even for immortals. Maybe this is just something you're supposed to ignore but to me it doesn't make sense that there's a large difference in the number of years between generations. Did a generation somehow have a pact not to make any more vampires for a while?Just use the timescale as a reference for a standart when most of these generations where created. If we take MC presumed 5th gen as example, that would mean most of the 5 gen are several thausand years old, doesn't change one thing about the MC, except that most other 5th gen would have a large advantage in age, experience, powerbase(minions, wealth, politics) ect.
Generation isn't about time, but potency of their blood. When a vamp embraces a new child it has a bit less blood potency as the creator and as such is weaker, one generation higher than him/her. The lower the generation the closer to the origin and more powerfull.
Okay fair enough so this is mostly extrapolation from outside the game. You mention here that Marcus's sire didn't know about it. I don't remember reading anything about Marcus's sire, when was this?The only established facts are thing in the water is old, because it's been underground for a long time, well before Markus was turned (he & his sire appear to have been unaware of it). From Frank's encounter we know she wants to get free & has been using Nos to do so, but they all expired before she got out.
well it was the dawn of farming so as the amount of cattle grew (as in number of humans) there must have been an explosion of vampires that threatened to wreak the world dry off blood so some vampires took responsibilities by villages and protected those villages from other vampires thus becoming living gods to that heard... eventually villages coalesced into alliances and civilizations!I meant it didn't make sense in that generations should be roughly the same number of years apart even for immortals. Maybe this is just something you're supposed to ignore but to me it doesn't make sense that there's a large difference in the number of years between generations. Did a generation somehow have a pact not to make any more vampires for a while?
why not both? i mean with some good luck you get a twins threesome!Make no mistake- All the characters in this novel are tools of Inanna, or tools of her sister Ereshkigal. Nothing more, nothing less. If she shows an interest, it is in HER best interest to do so.
When the MC & Markus go to recon the hideout the MC asks him if he's been here before. If you're on good terms with Markus he'll tell you about it.Okay fair enough so this is mostly extrapolation from outside the game. You mention here that Marcus's sire didn't know about it. I don't remember reading anything about Marcus's sire, when was this?
hiHmmm well the generation timing of vampires doesn't make a whole lot of sense, what did the 5th generation somehow just decide not to embrace anybody for 700 years?
That's weird but that aside okay so the influence part makes sense but what exactly does she expect the MC to do? Like if Ereshkigal is 2nd generation than she'd be way out of the MC's league and even Calisto's league in theory. I guess she'll scheme up something. Anyway thanks for clearing that up for me.
No Sir!!!!!!Not sure why you feel the insult is necessary but I suspect you addressed what I said earlier because I used the expression NTR. But I am not talking about the sexual kink, but the fact that there is a strong bond between Sharon and Astrid, possibly at the expense of the MC. And I think there is in fact desire involved, in the sense that the inner beast is driven by carnal desires and that Sharon had to center herself after being confronted with Astrid the first time. It's more that loss of control, the ability of Astrid to bring Sharon out of balance and manipulate her despite Sharons best efforts to prevent that. I'd like to know more about the nature of their former relationship and what lever Astrid is using to have that effect on Sharon. It's a mystery so far.
Oh I see I played the base version and I didn't tell Vergil about the feral being a nos so I guess that's why I missed it.There was a bug though, in the original release it only showed this stuff if you told Virgil the feral was a Nos, while clearly Markus is only supposed to confide in the MC if you didn't. The hotfix corrects this bug.
Yeah okay I can see that. It is a bit of a leap tbh but I guess with conservation of detail in games like these I could go either way on it.This is where Arigon gets his theory that the feral at the abandoned hospital is the deranged Ileana, because Ileana used to hang out near the big bad. Personally I think that's a giant leap, and there's no evidence in game yet that the feral was Ileana.
Okay thanks for the detailed post, let me first respond to this. What you say here could account for the varied time scale between generations because it took that long for the new vampires to successfully embrace their own children without being wiped out.The thing with trying to lay out a generation vs timeline is not a bad attempt to generalize things, though of course it will be wildly inaccurate in a lot of cases, as any generalization would be. Most of the vampires in VtM that are running around in the modern nights are less than 500 years old. They are 8th generation or higher. The weak blooded are the most recent. That does not mean that 14k years ago there were not 8th generation vampires, they just didn't survive or they gobbled their way up the food chain.
I feel like this is probably the weakest part of your theory as Markus doesn't seem to know he has this job or really anything about this super elder vampire. His sire apparently didn't know anything either. I guess there could have been an organization to take care of Ereshkigal at one point but there doesn't seem to be any evidence in game for this at all.Markus' sire and whomever came before her watched over Ereshkigal. (Markus and his sire are much much much less powerful than Calisto, I postulate that his sire inherited the job from a series of more ancient vampires who grew bored or careless or both, or were similarly mistreated by Ereshkigal as her Nos bunker brood was)
Oh I see I played the base version and I didn't tell Vergil about the feral being a nos so I guess that's why I missed it.
Yeah okay I can see that. It is a bit of a leap tbh but I guess with conservation of detail in games like these I could go either way on it.
Okay thanks for the detailed post, let me first respond to this. What you say here could account for the varied time scale between generations because it took that long for the new vampires to successfully embrace their own children without being wiped out.
So there could be multiple "8th generations" where it's wiped out a bunch until it's successfully established and you go to the 9th generation being wiped out a bunch. This is still highly unusual and to me strains credibility but it's a lot better than random time differences in generations for no reason.
I feel like this is probably the weakest part of your theory as Markus doesn't seem to know he has this job or really anything about this super elder vampire. His sire apparently didn't know anything either. I guess there could have been an organization to take care of Ereshkigal at one point but there doesn't seem to be any evidence in game for this at all.
If Inanna was able to take action to ensure that she is well served by Calisto shouldn't Ereshkigal have done the same to ensure that she had good servants of Calisto's level? Even if let's say she was asleep and so just got unlucky when her servants deserted but Inanna's didn't wouldn't her first step have been to build her power base by not driving those nos to insanity? Or is she just malevolent and can't help herself?
Reading through this it feels like Inanna has the definite upper hand on Ereshkigal and they're not quite equals.
Now that your reasoning is duly noted I can appreciate where you are coming from, I do have an issue with that though, Many of Us enjoy the theory crafting that is done on this thread... It is unique to F95 and It is something I have come to enjoy and I want to continue this venue. Are we to expect now that you will interject you view into the mix with the intent to disrupt what is arguably a very productive atmosphere IMO as I am sure many will agree. So can we agree to try to find common ground. This thread should be big enough for all of us. If you are not interested I understand but We will continue with what we have done in the past. And if you truly are not interested in our reverse engineering then ignore us please.Yeah. Thanks but no thanks. I'm here to comment on and enjoy this VN. Unless the writers decide to direct us at outside sources to which this world they've created adhere, I'm really not interested in endless speculation about how this story might fit with various vampire mythologies, novels, games, or game systems. You're not trying to figure out the plot lines presented here. You're trying to reverse engineer the structure and fabric that the writers developed to create this VN. Plot lines are analyzed based on the content and plot presented in the writing, no speculating about which parts of other writing they may have based their writing on.
Information not presented in this VN is uninteresting. I understand the drive of various commenters here to fit this VN's structure of vampire capabilities and social structure into other contexts, but I feel free to comment only based on the content presented here and will continue to so do.
he will post disruptive posts, he won't listen to your request, and he has been doing it for a while now.Now that your reasoning is duly noted I can appreciate where you are coming from, I do have an issue with that though, Many of Us enjoy the theory crafting that is done on this thread... It is unique to F95 and It is something I have come to enjoy and I want to continue this venue. Are we to expect now that you will interject you view into the mix with the intent to disrupt what is arguably a very productive atmosphere IMO as I am sure many will agree. So can we agree to try to find common ground. This thread should be big enough for all of us. If you are not interested I understand but We will continue with what we have done in the past. And if you truly are not interested in our reverse engineering then ignore us please.
Well I had to try.he will post disruptive posts, he won't listen to your request, and he has been doing it for a while now.