Both those women are awesome and I'd have to say that I like Scarlett more between the two. Without spoiling anything, I like how the mc impacted life so much that he became unforgettable (and irresistible) to her. I really hope it's not revealed later that the mc is actually the father of her daughters. I mean it could be possible! Wouldn't that be a twist! But I feel as though that wouldn't be the best choice in writing
It is very likely that is the case, though.
There are already some signs that the story MC has been told does not line up with what actually happened.
Started with the fact that his dad was nowhere to be found. Not in the power plant and not in several colleges MC did search him at.
Over the instance with Skylar and her mom who obviously recognized MC, fled and forbade her daughter to ever go near him again.
To the job interview the mystery guy sent him to and stated that that would be very important.
But that said it is not a 08/15 story and there still are some unknown twists coming up.
For instance what is Rileys part in the story. Is she good or only good in bed?
What about Shelby and her ... sperm donor (he is certainly not a dad).
What is the story impact of darci, her mom and her grandma? Will her mom be so grateful towards MC she was rescued she jumps his dick and forces a creampie resulting in darci 9 month later?
Honestly "MC is the father of the girls he fucks" is only a part of the story, there are a bunch more elements to the game.