I didn’t say the mod creator is necessarily right, nothing’s really set in stone at the moment. That said, I’m really grateful they took the time to create such a cool and useful tool for us. Just because we can ourselves access the code and scripts doesn’t take away from the effort they put into it. Like I mentioned, I’m not sure if what this person claimed is true.
I never criticised the mod. I respect what modders do. I was more taking aim at the idea the mod could imply anything, when it's taking a wild guess at best (more detail on this at the end).
It seems like Jestur recently said that the girls might be jealous of the MC because of his relationships with others, and there could be a kind of "harem"-like situation, but solely with some of them.
Personally, I don’t think the drama with Jessica is final or that it shuts all doors for good. Maybe, as you did, it’s smarter to prioritize Jessica to get the best route with both her and Skylar. I indeed remember that the evening with Skylar gets cut short if you choose Jessica, but the dinner still happens (maybe a kind of continuity error). A make up dinner or friendly dinner that feels very much like a date between lovers, even though they officially call themselves "just friends" in the car after that, but oh well ...
Yes, Jestur has given occasional insight into what might be possible, and it seems clear to me that this will never be a full harem game, some choices will have to be made, but multiple girls are on the table if you make the right chocies. Time will tell if the Skylar/Jessica choice is a permanent one.
But at the time of the choice there were some people upset at having to choose, and Jestur's enigmatic response was (as I remember it) something along the lines of "if you make the right choice here you'll get another chance later".
He could have been playing with us, of course, maybe either choice is good.
The dinner still happening isn't an error. It's the two characters going out as friends. Which they'd agreed they would be no matter what he chose. The part you lose is only the romance/sex part. Skylar will continue to be an important part of both the story and the MC's life. I have female friends with whom I go out alone to dinner or drinks which to anyone observing might look like a date, but we're not interested in each other that way. We just value the experience of time to ourselves where we can focus on our own conversation in a way that's not possible in groups.
For me, I preferred the route with Skylar; she’s got more charm and personality compared to Jessica. Jessica feels a bit like the jealous, possessive type, a little capricious and definitely brocon girl with MC (on I patch). Overall, her character feels too much like a stereotype, IMO, so I’m curious to see if she’ll get more interesting later in the game.
I thought it was better for the MC to be a bit firmer and not be swayed by Jessica's whims. I prefer characters who make decisions and stick to them, those with real character who don’t get easily influenced.
I think it's possible, even if you follow Skylar's route at first, that Jessica might eventually accept the relationship and the tension between them will ease up a bit. Maybe she'll still be a little jealous, but if it ends up shutting down the option of a relationship with her for good, well, that just means she probably wasn't worth it for me.
Right before this choice, the MC thinks :
"There's a chance Jessica might eventually come around, but am I willing to risk that to keep seeing Skylar ?" This gives the impression that there’s still hope both girls could be open to dating him together. As for the question, my answer is yes, of course ! Sky is just the best one. ^^
P.S : I think, but I’m not sure, that the best choice to get in future the Jessica+Skylar route is to choose Skylar first, but I could be wrong, of course. There might be stronger reasons to believe that choosing Jessica may end up friendzoning Skylar at the end (but not hard evidence). This is just my gut feeling and take on it (after replaying the game today).
Edit : I’d suggest rereading the MC's monologue when he's torn between making Jessica happy at Skylar's expense, or the other way around. To me, the best decision, based on his thoughts, is when he chooses Sky. He steps up, showing that his feelings are stronger than jealousy and sensitivity of another one, and believes Jessica will eventually come around to the idea of him and Skylar being together. And from there, maybe even more in the future ? I'm just assuming for now.
I don't agree with all of this exactly, but I would not say your reasoning is invalid. Only different to mine. I agree with your evaluation of Skylar. She was in my signature for a long time, even after I made the choice. She is a beautiful person, in every way. Jessica is very much the jealous possessive type, at least with the MC. But also a really sweet girl. Go back to when she apologises to the MC for how she's treated Darci. And Darci telling him about Jessica's apology to her. You don't have to wait until after choosing her to see that side.
I agree that it's possible Jessica would get over her jealousy and join her two favourite people in their relationship.
Where I differ and why I chose as I did:
In my view the MC choosing to prioritise Jessica
is making a decision and sticking to it. It's not about being easily influenced. Before then he was going with what was fun, not thinking about the effect it might have on Jessica, which in context isn't wrong: the relationship with Skylar started before he had any idea Jessica might be hurt by it, and was initially two people having fun without intent to get serious. And I felt that Jessica's problem with him dating Skylar is that she wants him, but can't admit that to anyone, maybe not even herself. Yet. I understand that feeling. Jessica is the type of person who, I think, once she's made to feel safe, will lose her jealousy and possessiveness.
That's what informed my choice, despite overall preferring Skylar up to that point. I'm sympathetic to how Jessica feels. And I think the best route to both is to first make Jessica feel safe. I have no doubt at all that any time the MC says he wants to start up with Skylar again she will be in without hesitation. So I'm playing the long game. Once Jessica knows she can have the MC and share him equally with Skylar, I think she'll be into it.
This isn't to say that choosing Skylar is ignoring or not caring how Jessica feels. It's valid to say "I'm sorry this makes you uncomfortable, but she makes me happy, and I hope you can respect that." Jessica has no romantic claim on him, and "you can't date your sister's friends unless they say so" is stupid high school logic. Jessica really does care about the MC, and I trust that even if it did not lead to a three-way relationship she would come to be happy for them.
As you say, no hard evidence for either. We both have good reasons for our choices.
I’ve posted a screenshot with the mod active when that particular choice comes up below.
View attachment 4548139
Have you seen the scene without the mod?
I focus on the word "risk". And that each choice says you're on a different girl's path. Also I know that in the code a variable gets set based on your choice. Other than the ones that determine whose path(s) you're on. If that wasn't important, it wouldn't be set. The path variables would be enough to control the progression and, for instance, whether you get another scene after dinner, or the Jessica photo session.
It's level of importance may be low. But as someone who
has looked at the code, the mod's statement of "doesn't close a path" directly contradicts what's in there and how the story progresses from then. At the time of the choice, whichever you choose puts you not on the other's path. Maybe this isn't permanently closed, as in there will be an option to reopen later, but for now it definitely closes the other path.
And that's what I meant about not trusting mods to make story predictions. If this was a statement based on something in the code - or confirmed by the developer - it would be different.