- Nov 14, 2017
- 61,348
- 30,805
- Thread starter Crazygamer43
- Start date
If it was another guy, why would CNG say this on Discord:
The only reason Patreon would have any influence over Becca's true parentage would be if she was actually blood-related to Frank, which is clearly a big no no for them. If it was another random guy that Shannon slept with, where is the problem for Patreon? At this point, you are purposefully being ignorant. There are far too many clues in the story that indicate Frank is the daddy but CNG couldn't confirm it. Now, he can.
- Nov 14, 2017
- 61,348
- 30,805
shanlon (dev) said so. to avoid patreon's wrath. now that move to ss is ahead frank gets/mightget promoted to blood father.
- Nov 20, 2017
- 4,933
- 12,034
The Patreon page only shows "under review" so their is a chance that the page may come back alive and if so Becha still will only be offical child of Shannon and her biological father and it will never be confirm if her fathter would be Frank.
- Mar 10, 2024
- 1,306
- 1,876
I feel like if Rebecca was by chance his Shannon would use it as a weapon. Get back child support or something can't see her not using it to her advantage.
- Aug 4, 2022
- 1,764
- 3,422
What child support? They were married until recently, Becca's of age. And she's the one paying him alimony. Not saying she couldn't find some way to use it, but that one doesn't sound like it'd fly - I'm no lawyer tho.
And the groundwork has already been placed in the game to all but confirm it. That way it will not be a left-field revelation when the truth comes out. As the game stands right now, without the real world situation with Patreon, there is only one man mentioned in the game that could be Becca's father, and that is Frank. All the "Shannon was cheating" is speculation. We know for a fact that Shannon was dating Frank for six months. We know for a fact that Frank slept with Shannon shortly before she was shipped away. We know for a fact that she was shipped away in a totally random way. We know for a fact that Becca was born when Shannon was 16 and still in school. We know for a fact that Shannon met Trevor when she left school. We do not know for a fact that Shannon was sleeping with anyone else. That could have been teenage BS rumors that people made up to explain why Shannon left.
The pregnancy was kept a secret by Shannon's parents. It kinda defeats the purpose of keeping it a secret if you tell other people about it. Her parents probably kept her financially supported. Then, when she finally got reaquinted and got married, he was paying into the family. By the time of the divorce, Becca was already 23. Laws depend on where you live, but if the child is over 18 before a petition for child support is even entered, you could be shit out of luck. All of this could also be a way to bring Shannon back into the story. She will be massively pissed off that her daughters just left without a word and when she finds out where her daughters are living and who got them the apartment, she would get even angrier. She might have kept this secret safe to drop on Frank when it would hurt him the most.
- Nov 14, 2017
- 61,348
- 30,805
doubt even in God Blessed America can get retroactive child support (unless has really good lawyer and gets dumb judge) especially since Frank lived with her and kids most of their childhood.
She doesn't know what Frank and Becky do behind locked doors.
- Nov 21, 2017
- 198
- 394
Considering we still don't know what Phase 1&2 were for Becca's plan, with how smart she seems to be, pretty much all bets are off for what she knows. Along with how much and when she plans to illuminate to Frank.
All of this, of course, is taking for granted that Frank is indeed her dad.
If that is the case, I'm guessing she knows Frank is bio-dad, has for a long time, and it may have even fed her fetishes.
How she is/was going to see what Frank thought, and made him aware somehow, is still anyone's guess.
Doubtful it bothers her, or really ever has for that matter, but considering how he reacts to the idea of Abby joining the harem, she's likely cautious in how she wants to approach such a subject.
It is going to be interesting to see the justifications she comes up with after having repeatedly said, after the divorce, that none of them were actually related anymore.
In addition, she used that particular point in favor of her arguments for them to get together, so that might come back to bite her.
All of this, of course, is taking for granted that Frank is indeed her dad.
If that is the case, I'm guessing she knows Frank is bio-dad, has for a long time, and it may have even fed her fetishes.
How she is/was going to see what Frank thought, and made him aware somehow, is still anyone's guess.
Doubtful it bothers her, or really ever has for that matter, but considering how he reacts to the idea of Abby joining the harem, she's likely cautious in how she wants to approach such a subject.
It is going to be interesting to see the justifications she comes up with after having repeatedly said, after the divorce, that none of them were actually related anymore.
In addition, she used that particular point in favor of her arguments for them to get together, so that might come back to bite her.
- Jul 25, 2017
- 316
- 1,472
I'm not going to comment on the whole 'What is NTR in a broad sense" because that is kind of a personal decision on what all qualifies and my biggest issue with Single Again is the slow pace and writing (as my review states).
However, to answer your question directly and without sarcasm or hyperbole. I will try to give you the facts, and let you form your own opinion, as opposed to just giving you my opinion and stating it as fact.
The items I am calling NTR in this game come in 2 areas, I'll explain them and you can decide if that "ntr" is to you.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
There are some other minor ideas along this route in the game, but in regards to the comment I made (that you quoted), there were the two that, for me, qualify the game for the NTR tag.
My Opinion - to be clear not a fact now - is that regardless of where the 'canon' story is found, if it IS canon all tags should apply. I also believe that once an instance of a tag is enough the game warrants that tag. The Dev has the option to explain why and context.
Hope this helps you understand where my post was originating from and to make your own decision.
If you have been careful, in Frank's "dreams/nightmares", a "mysterious" woman, he phoned him, making him miss a work appointment, for a "emergency" at home. Here, he discovered the betrayal. If they guess and I imagine right, he was Becca. Probably, she "wanted to" separate her mother from Frank, and then "gather" the people "who deserve", both to protect Abby, who was mistreated because of the similarity with Jessica, and not to have to undergo more, nor her, Nor Lilith.
This could mean that Shannon knew, what Becca is Frank's daughter. I don't find it logical. Once they got married, at the beginning of the relationship, things were going well. There is no reason, to hide the truth. For me, Shannon, he had immediately fucked just transferred, after left Frank, therefore, does not know who Becca's father is.
"Oh hey sweetie by the way you know my 10 year old daughter I never let you meet until now? Ya, I think she's yours."
Yaaaaa, that would've gone over well. Shannunt had plenty of reason to hide Becca's true parentage, especially given how manipulative she is.
- Jan 12, 2021
- 1,553
- 2,503
I absolutely agree with you. I've always been someone who absolutely doubted that Becca was Trevor's daughter because Shannon had to have graduated from school, gotten a job, met Trevor and started dating him within a month. And it never really would have explained why her parents more or less disowned her. A teenage pregnancy in the late 90s would be embarrassing enough for her parents to do something like that, depending on what makes them tick.
And let's be honest, the way she always upsets Lilly with her incest kink would be totally in character for Becca.
- Jul 12, 2020
- 8,945
- 20,210
It really wouldn't unless you come from bible belt USA or a devout catholic family/area.
- Jan 12, 2021
- 1,553
- 2,503
I imagined something along the lines of the latter. If we assume that the story is set in 2019, then we can assume that Frank and Shannon were born around 1980. Without knowing the exact age of the parents, we can assume that they were born around the 1960s. Even if we know relatively little about Frank's parents, we can assume from the flashbacks that they are rather liberal or at least relatively "easy going". My assumption is that they took Jess in quite willingly when she was disowned by her family while pregnant. I would even assume that his mother accepted Jess as part of the family very early on, since if I recall correctly, her reaction when Jess told her that Frank had proposed was something along the lines of "It's about time!".
We don't know much about Shannon's parents, except that they abandoned their daughter when she was pregnant. I guess it's a "What are our neighbors going to think of this? Our 16-year-old daughter pregnant. Oh, the disgrace!"
I would put her parents in the moderately conservative corner, if my assumption is correct, whereas with Frank's parents I assume that they may have been influenced by the hippie era, or had rather conservative parents themselves and therefore wanted to do things differently with their children.
What you can definitely say is that Shannon's family has been rather toxic, which has then carried over to Shannon herself. And if it wasn't for Frank, Becca and Abby, Lilly would most likely be next in the cycle of toxicity.
- Feb 24, 2021
- 629
- 2,056
As I recall, the story starts on "Thursday, March 30th" without specifying the year. The only years in the near past or future where March 30th lands on a Thursday are 2017, 2023, and 2028 (the next one after that is 2034, but I doubt it's that far into the future).
I actually did some speculation around the Becca's parentage in previous posts (links to all my previous posts in that particular post, actually), and all info below is based on this previous research. And yes, I plan to repeat myself a bit here (those previous posts have more details about my research and prior speculations).
Becca's character bio says that she's 23, and the time the story starts is said to be 15 days after her recent birthday. In a flashback to "July, 22nd. Twenty four years ago", MC/Frank is said to have been moping around in his room for a month after Shannon abrubtly left, so late June (in the flashback, Jessica tells MC/Frank "You've had a month to sit around and mope." - assuming one month exactly, Shannon moved away June 22nd).
Math would say that Becca was conceived on or around June 8th in the year of the flashback (assuming
You must be registered to see the links
), or 2 weeks before Shannon left.So if CNG (the dev) has made all of this intentional, and didn't mess things up, that leaves us with two options:
- MC/Frank is Becca's biological father
- Shannon cheated on MC/Frank, and that unknown person is Becca's biological father
And given CNG's most recent comment about Becca's parentage can become canon, now that Patreon might be going away, I'd say option 1 is even more likely.
I'd also speculate that Shannon's silence on the matter might be because she actually cheated on MC/Frank around that time anyway, and is herself unsure who Becca's true biological father is. I mean, she cheated on MC/Frank (which was the tipping point for their divorce), who's to say that she hasn't cheated on him before? And asking for a DNA test to prove it would just confirm that she's unsure.
As for MC/Frank himself not having noticed before, is that he's that oblivious to that matter, and hasn't thought to do the math himself. Becca probably has noticed, has done the math, and might've even done a DNA test in secret to confirm it, and even after all that, is still on board with her newfound relationship with her father, but that's even further speculation from my end.
All of this is basically trying to predict the story of a movie sequel before they've started production on it, though.
We'll just have to wait and see how the story actually unfolds.
I'm fairly sure that CNG frequently makes oblique references to Becca's father because they know it riles up the Becca Parentage conspiracists. I do remember that in the early releases, if you named MC "closer" that the relationship between Frank/Abby went from "step/adopted" to blood-related. CNG may make Frank Becca's bio-dad if the patreon is shut down, but I'm 70% thinking that they're just screwing with people that fixate on it. And it was an unknown man's voice that phoned Frank and told him there was an emergency at home; I think it was a combination of Becca's machinations and her somehow(?) learning of and cooperating with the estate lawyers/private investigators. But I think it was likely the lawfirm/PI/Mrs. Lastoya making the decision to smarten Frank up considering he was going to come into some property and they probably discovered evidence of Shannon's adultery and didn't want her near the inheritance.
I think another, mundane, possibility is that CNG didn't have a timeline really locked down and this is all an oversight of their editing, which is mostly ok, but has some glaring screw ups.
Edit: considering how alarmed and put off Frank was early in the story of maybe being with Becca early on as she flirted with him the week before the divorce finalized (and this is with Frank actually knowing Becca had a huge crush on him when they first met/moved in,) I think Frank learning Becca was his actual biological daughter would result in him cutting her off of any sexual relationship. I mean, except this is a hentai game.
Edit2: Also about the latest update, I like that Abby did something she mentioned to Frank while she was Grabby Abby and after having sexy fun times w/ Lilly she immediately went to cuddle Frank. Sorry Lil, you just can't Big Spoon her like the best cuddler can.
I think another, mundane, possibility is that CNG didn't have a timeline really locked down and this is all an oversight of their editing, which is mostly ok, but has some glaring screw ups.
Edit: considering how alarmed and put off Frank was early in the story of maybe being with Becca early on as she flirted with him the week before the divorce finalized (and this is with Frank actually knowing Becca had a huge crush on him when they first met/moved in,) I think Frank learning Becca was his actual biological daughter would result in him cutting her off of any sexual relationship. I mean, except this is a hentai game.
Edit2: Also about the latest update, I like that Abby did something she mentioned to Frank while she was Grabby Abby and after having sexy fun times w/ Lilly she immediately went to cuddle Frank. Sorry Lil, you just can't Big Spoon her like the best cuddler can.
Last edited:
- Nov 14, 2017
- 61,348
- 30,805