I think people need to check the title of the game again.
Well, talking with ghosts may very well be a narative device, but it also indicates serious mental issues. Especially if they lead to panic attacks and whatnot. Paranoid schizophrenia comes to mind first. And seeing how much more malicious Davis became in the last episode, that's plausible. PTSD also plays a role there. He may very well be losing his marbles, to be honest.The thing is that some people don't see or play the MC as such a tortured soul in this game. I mean, there are events to show the player that he likely has poor mental health, like seeing ghosts of his dead friends a lot and having conversations with them, and an obvious mask of "Cassanova/womanizer" that he plays up to hide who he really is, plus there are other characters – mainly Els – telling him that he's not well or that he should be attending sessions with the other veterans. The most important symptom here though is the way he is slowly processing his memories, and the fact he is experiencing them like they are new and just uncovered. Plus he seemingly can't face what happened on the day that Zaina died, or speak of it (at least that's where it seems his block is when talking with the therapist). But that absence is tough to notice unless you're specifically looking for what isn't there.
On the other hand, the MC has a very successful MMA career that he's moving forward, a close group of friends who support him, no unhealthy addictions or other crutches to deal with any supposed issues, and he generally acts laid back and chill in his reactions to everything. Seeing Zaina and Davis can easily come across to the player as just the MC's internal dialog. Or that he is still in love with Zaina and just misses her. Honestly, to me these scenes often feel more like a narrative device that limits the need for too many unwanted flashbacks. The presence of these "ghosts" just doesn't feel menacing or unhealthy, in a "You must start fires, because the world must burn!" kind of way.
So I can see why others have said that Els felt like she was forcing herself too much into the MC's personal space – and perhaps gaslighting him – during the initial poolside talk when a lot of this first gets dumped on the player. It was only in the most recent chapter that we got a real sense of illness with the clearly dangerous panic attack. And this was also the only time in the story when the MC talked out loud to his ghosts – it happened during the therapy session – where he forgot he was in the middle of a real-world conversation at the time.
The extent of the MC's character is a lot better established now, with a more solid sense of his injuries, but I still sometimes feel it clashes with his other behaviours, and so it can feel more "angsty" than "serious" at times.
To bring this all back around to the love interests, I think who you choose can simply depend on how well that main storyline lands for you. And for some I think it feels like those issues are something the MC will work his way through in time on his own, as he needs to. I'm probably more in your camp than otherwise. To me, Vi sees the MC too much as her "Knight in shining armour", and so I feel she will have difficulty being there fully to support him when he's broken in some manner in the future (whether that's due to these traumas, or just in general because life is never without challenges). So other LIs do seem like a better fit to me as well, but I think it all comes down to whether the MC is played as a tortured soul or just a moderately stressed war veteran.
The fact that Valentine plays cool and collected most of the time shows how mentally tough he is, and not how he's healthy at all.
100% agreed about Vi. She will be more of a burden, than being of help if Valentine's mental status deteriorates, shall I say, further.
Kana has no knowledge of anything. She really is oblivious to Valentine's problems, fixated on herself.
Amrit is, like I said before, an airhead jock. She wouldn't be able to do shit, even if she noticed, which isn't like if he really exhibits some unmistakable symptoms.
Ines proved that she will try her best to help, but still, she is a teenager. I honestly don't expect Valentine to dump his problems on her at all. Besides, calming someone having a panic attack is one thing, dealing with something like a schizophrenic is a whole other thing.
Serena is just interested in getting some.
McNab is a lame best friend.
But Els... Els is certainly something else. We already know she'll force Valentine to get better, if she has to. She'll drag him by the balls, if she needs to.
And even though none of them, including puny McNab, would have any chance if Valentine's PTSD is triggered and he went all survivalist mode, at least Els may be able to protect herself from the worst. Just remember how lucky Ines was, when Valentine punched through the air, while not knowing she was there. She would've been hospitalised, if not dead if that landed.
Mental health aside, Valentine will face an unstable and violent opponent. Presumably, Marshman will pull some shit, and hurt Valentine. And even if he doesn't, the nature of the sport and the "injury points" indicate that there will be some stuff... Then we'll have a man broken not just mentally but physically in our hand. Who would you rather have by your bedside if you were Valentine at that point?
To be honest, this AVN has so much potential. The possibilities are almost infinite. It can go great, it can turn very dark... And this is exactly why I spend so much time on it. And unless Elspeth screwed Valentine in the past, that we don't know yet, she is the only choice. Think about it. In addition to everything, Sir Valentine sounds awesome for an American.
Last edited: