sorco2003

Engaged Member
Donor
Sep 3, 2020
2,055
15,003
Digging through code isn't what any dev intends a player to do. Making blind choices is how games are intended to be played, and walkthrough mods are provided because some players hate uncertainty. I am certain that you make more consequential choices on a daily basis intuitively, because real life has no walkthrough.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

But maybe that's me, and maybe all the variable just offer flavours of dialogue. We don't know what the variables might trigger in season 5. If the game is interesting enough, you play it without worrying about the time, if not, rage quitting is a thing.
I would like to add two things to the consideration:
Handling decision with unique variables makes coding when they are used a bit of a nightmare, given the amount of variables that can determine something, and more in a game like this where the amount of LI is already a nightmare in itself.
And secondly, many times the variables are set to make the player nervous, or to anticipate what could happen... I remember two right now MHY (they still don't agree if it's horny or hate you, and it's taken several chapters to make any sense) and jealuosy in BaDIK, which still has no real consequences but it's there and can be used at any time...
 

Penfold Mole

Engaged Member
Respected User
May 22, 2017
3,264
8,252
Another ignore list material
You likely know this particular Kemal Ataturk from the recent past as lolashola, who just a few days ago shed his skin and got himself a shiny new look to keep fooling you reading his brainfarts and waste your time and nerves answering him, in case you haven't added him or his former identity to your ignore list yet.
 
Last edited:

yossa999

Engaged Member
Dec 5, 2020
2,957
20,018
I do plan on trying a run like that, it's a bit pre-emptive to really do much more than follow the story driven paths because the other paths have no real choices to make right now, and there's no way to guess what all the options will do.

Edit: Hey yossa999 don't be sad, I'm going to be patient for all the variables, so many adventures to choose :)
A sad pathetic fuck is what the MC will become on that path of being an ignorant asshole. :(
Please, don't do this, there are special games for that shit :)

Vic would probably still be the only one his friend (or at least someone who cares about him regardeless anything.) This is how I understand the "semi-dark" path in the current version.

As far as I understand, originally it was assumed that MC would be a dark psycho edgelord without a consciense or regrets on the dark path, he would dominate all these weaklings and will make them his pet toys and slaves.

I think this is why there is still butthurt about the abolition of the dark path.
 

BobTheDuck

Engaged Member
Dec 24, 2018
2,268
13,567
A sad pathetic fuck is what the MC will become on that path of being an ignorant asshole. :(
Please, don't do this, there are special games for that shit :)

Vic would probably still be the only one his friend (or at least someone who cares about him regardeless anything.) This is how I understand the "semi-dark" path in the current version.

As far as I understand, originally it was assumed that MC would be a dark psycho edgelord without a consciense or regrets on the dark path, he would dominate all these weaklings and will make them his pet toys and slaves.

I think this is why there is still butthurt about the abolition of the dark path.
Oh, I will do it just to see how coach hill, Anna etc get involved. You probably don't have to be an asshole to anyone, just be promiscuious. Like alt the locker scene appears if you don't kiss Bella. I'm not interested in doing it for the roleplay of it, just curious to see all of the story Ocean's written at some point. It's not going to be high on my list of playthroughs though.
 

Mortarion

Well-Known Member
Donor
Oct 22, 2017
1,862
6,847
You likely know this particular Kemal Ataturk from the recent past as lolashola, who just a few days ago shed his skin and got himself a shiny new look to keep fooling you reading his brainfarts and waste your time and nerves answering him, in case you haven't added him or his former identity to your ignore list yet.
Wow, that moron has even deleted all his posts in this thread. Only a couple of quotes are still there.
My message was crap, looks like the quote system is not able to find a post if the name from the poster has changed.

Anyway, nice catch mate!
 
Last edited:

John972

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2018
1,214
3,818
A sad pathetic fuck is what the MC will become on that path of being an ignorant asshole. :(
Please, don't do this, there are special games for that shit :)

Vic would probably still be the only one his friend (or at least someone who cares about him regardeless anything.) This is how I understand the "semi-dark" path in the current version.

As far as I understand, originally it was assumed that MC would be a dark psycho edgelord without a consciense or regrets on the dark path, he would dominate all these weaklings and will make them his pet toys and slaves.

I think this is why there is still butthurt about the abolition of the dark path.
Oh, I will do it just to see how coach hill, Anna etc get involved. You probably don't have to be an asshole to anyone, just be promiscuious. Like alt the locker scene appears if you don't kiss Bella. I'm not interested in doing it for the roleplay of it, just curious to see all of the story Ocean's written at some point. It's not going to be high on my list of playthroughs though.
With Ch 4.5, I did try an "Asshole MC" playthrough, just for shits & giggles. That involved simply rejecting and being rude to everyone. Obviously, the game was rather uneventful, i.e. NPCs reacted to the MC's behaviour appropriately

I did notice at the time that acting like a dick too often toward any LI seemed to pretty much kill options with them later in the playthrough. Some options, scenes, and dialogues that appear on a normal playthrough, seemed to disappear on an "Asshole MC" playthrough.
 

Old Man Al

Well-Known Member
Jan 18, 2022
1,054
7,459
...
You can play the game and be an arsehole to everyone (that includes rejecting LIs). Guess what? You come away with nothing ('none of this fantasy "every LI (and their mothers) just wants to fuck me" bollocks).
A VN in which (word)choices and consequences define who wants to have sex with the MC, which just makes it realistic enough that it feels like not every women in there just stumbled and fell on MCs dick via accident?
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Penfold Mole

Engaged Member
Respected User
May 22, 2017
3,264
8,252
My message was crap, looks like the quote system is not able to find a post if the name from the poster has changed.

Anyway, nice catch mate!
You can find his messages (at least the ones that haven't been deleted by the moderators or himself) the normal way, just by typing "Kemal Ataturk" into the user name box in the thread search and leaving the search phrase box empty.
You can find all the posts where his existing or deleted posts have been quoted under his former name by someone else by typing "lolashola" into the search box and leaving the user name box empty.
You certainly can, but do you really want to? I mean, you know what you'll find there... :HideThePain:
 

yossa999

Engaged Member
Dec 5, 2020
2,957
20,018
With Ch 4.5, I did try an "Asshole MC" playthrough, just for shits & giggles. That involved simply rejecting and being rude to everyone. Obviously, the game was rather uneventful, i.e. NPCs reacted to the MC's behaviour appropriately

I did notice at the time that acting like a dick too often toward any LI seemed to pretty much kill options with them later in the playthrough. Some options, scenes, and dialogues that appear on a normal playthrough, seemed to disappear on an "Asshole MC" playthrough.
One of the things I like about this game. An MC, being either a Massive DIK or a Massive CHICK in the SG world, will not have the same success as the one who acts according to the situation, is considerate of other characters, and does not hesitate to use common sense.

Let's take the Zara storyline.
First he teases and annoys her, and then publicly humiliates her. However, he attracts her interest. Now he is not just one of these pathetic weaklings, like Trey, but an arrogant and cocky boor who needs to be put in his place. Then he allows her to take revenge and feel like a winner for a while.

Further, when they meet at Nick's house, through manipulation, teasing and small concessions, he achieves that they become almost friends. And having achieved this, he then constantly maintains a balance, on the one hand, not allowing Zara's dominant nature to take over and spoil their growing friendship, and on the other hand, not going too far and showing that he cares about her and respects her.

It is not surprising that at the end of the fifth chapter she jumps with joy around him when she finds out that he will live in their house for some time. Was it just because of the opportunity to train together? Fuck if I'll buy it. No, that too, it's like a topping in a breadroll, but she's genuinely glad to be in his company and spend time with him.

Would he have achieved such an attitude from her on a purely dark path? I don’t think so, she would still feel insulted and humiliated and would try in every possible way to fight him. But she wouldn’t have accepted a slime from a purely light path either, she would probably have bullied him, if only because she doesn’t respect weaklings.

MC sets boundaries early on, has no qualms about being an asshole when it's needed, but rewards Zara for respecting boundaries and allowing her to play within those boundaries.

This is something that many other games do poorly: they are too straightforward. If they allow the MC to be evil or good, then he is either a complete moron and a sociopath, or he is so sweet, caring and helpful that most girls would puke from such a slime. But female game characters doesn't notice that. Cardboard cunts.
 

BobTheDuck

Engaged Member
Dec 24, 2018
2,268
13,567
One of the things I like about this game. An MC, being either a Massive DIK or a Massive CHICK in the SG world, will not have the same success as the one who acts according to the situation, is considerate of other characters, and does not hesitate to use common sense.

Let's take the Zara storyline.
First he teases and annoys her, and then publicly humiliates her. However, he attracts her interest. Now he is not just one of these pathetic weaklings, like Trey, but an arrogant and cocky boor who needs to be put in his place. Then he allows her to take revenge and feel like a winner for a while.

Further, when they meet at Nick's house, through manipulation, teasing and small concessions, he achieves that they become almost friends. And having achieved this, he then constantly maintains a balance, on the one hand, not allowing Zara's dominant nature to take over and spoil their growing friendship, and on the other hand, not going too far and showing that he cares about her and respects her.

It is not surprising that at the end of the fifth chapter she jumps with joy around him when she finds out that he will live in their house for some time. Was it just because of the opportunity to train together? Fuck if I'll buy it. No, that too, it's like a topping in a breadroll, but she's genuinely glad to be in his company and spend time with him.

Would he have achieved such an attitude from her on a purely dark path? I don’t think so, she would still feel insulted and humiliated and would try in every possible way to fight him. But she wouldn’t have accepted a slime from a purely light path either, she would probably have bullied him, if only because she doesn’t respect weaklings.

MC sets boundaries early on, has no qualms about being an asshole when it's needed, but rewards Zara for respecting boundaries and allowing her to play within those boundaries.

This is something that many other games do poorly: they are too straightforward. If they allow the MC to be evil or good, then he is either a complete moron and a sociopath, or he is so sweet, caring and helpful that most girls would puke from such a slime. But female game characters doesn't notice that. Cardboard cunts.
Yes, to all of the above.

One of the valuable aspects (for me) of the game's story is the characters actually being different: they have clear likes and dislikes, they have mannerisms, different ways of speaking etc. Some devs writing is good, but everyone has the same mannerisms as the dev. Ocean's clearly though about what motivates each character and how they react to the situations. Some things they'll be indifferent to, other things become a big deal; so the differences in behaviour from some of the girls if you kiss Bella sets them up to be jealous, whereas before you were a nobody. Not knowing what the outcome will be of any decision for several chapters makes me think I should act how I think it most authentic to me.

Having said that, because different characters are distinct, everyone has different pieces of the puzzle. Depending on what path you are on you find out different parts of the back story. I'm wondering if there will be a path for Melanie, and how that will affect things with the current circle of friends Nika's developing. It's not that I want to watch the world burn, I'm just curious to find out all the angles of the story, especially as Ocean loves hiding clues in odd places.

Primarily though, I'll be a responsible Nika, because actions have consequences. :sneaky:
 

Krytax123

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2022
2,515
5,341
he is so sweet, caring and helpful that most girls would puke from such a slime. But female game characters doesn't notice that. Cardboard cunts.
Thats plays a big part in why i like ocean's avns.

Im just so tired of the always undertstanding and supportive, everybodys darling carebear mc (but of course only if the other person has tits otherwise who gives a fuck).

Even worse when they - like in most cases - are completly empty opinionless shells, their whole behavior and opinions shaped to please the LI. Thats the opposite of what - in my experience - women are into, they usually like guys with opinions (as long as they arent dumb and even then ..) who are able to discuss/convince them or other people too, it shows confidence (and sometimes intellect) which usually are appealing traits.

Sometimes it feels like these MC's are designed like 12 year old girls imagine their disney dream prince. Real women would get so utterly bored by bland guys like that in no time, its nonsensical.

And we havent even talked about the completly brainless MC's who do nothing else than obsessing about some girls bodys/tits/asses/whatever in their damaged brains driven only by hornyness like my dog at a certain time of a year lmao, just trying to hump every other dog around.


Yeah long story short, thats why i really like Nika and William and i like that they are flawed.

Esp William i would like maybe way less if normal avn mcs would be more balanced, because truth is, at this point i think he's a cocky, overconfident, reckless jerk. Not the biggest fan of guys like that usually.

But he's hilarious, charismatic, funny and just a very different experience to the usual avn protagonist which makes it very enjoyable for me.

And for both (Nika & Willy) it opens up a lot of potential character development over the time of the storys to work on their "flaws".
 
Last edited:

RNasc4444

Well-Known Member
Aug 16, 2022
1,262
5,231
I think this is why there is still butthurt about the abolition of the dark path.
I was never butthurt about the abolition of the dark path but I always thought that MC was at least interesting. The asshole, detached, inappropriate, emo and edgy MC that everyone complained about at the beggining was at the very least incredibly interesting to play as. Whereas the current one is just kinda boring, sad and pathetic. Like an ugly puppy that was abandoned and kicked around too much.

I've never cared for or sympathized much with either of Ocean's MC's but Willy at least retained a bit of "edge" after the rework while SG's MC was toned down to an almost unbearable state.

I know most people won't agree with this. But it's also why I was never able to let go of what SG was pre-rework. At least up to 3.0. That was the story I wanted to play. That was my undisputed #1 game. Then the retconning of scenes, dialogue and characters began and this game was never the same to me. The emotional heights previously achieved dwindled to that of an average VN. And that's why, while I still very much enjoy the setting, the side characters and the story, I doubt it will ever break my top 10 again. This is what I'm butthurt about. I will never see or get to play the version of this game that I truly loved.
 

Krytax123

Engaged Member
Dec 29, 2022
2,515
5,341
Yes, to all of the above.

One of the valuable aspects (for me) of the game's story is the characters actually being different: they have clear likes and dislikes, they have mannerisms, different ways of speaking etc. Some devs writing is good, but everyone has the same mannerisms as the dev. Ocean's clearly though about what motivates each character and how they react to the situations. Some things they'll be indifferent to, other things become a big deal; so the differences in behaviour from some of the girls if you kiss Bella sets them up to be jealous, whereas before you were a nobody. Not knowing what the outcome will be of any decision for several chapters makes me think I should act how I think it most authentic to me.

Having said that, because different characters are distinct, everyone has different pieces of the puzzle. Depending on what path you are on you find out different parts of the back story. I'm wondering if there will be a path for Melanie, and how that will affect things with the current circle of friends Nika's developing. It's not that I want to watch the world burn, I'm just curious to find out all the angles of the story, especially as Ocean loves hiding clues in odd places.

Primarily though, I'll be a responsible Nika, because actions have consequences. :sneaky:
I theorized a way back that there are maybe two type of avn players (there are way more types but just for this perspective). Maybe thats a reason why SG is this polarizing (plus no lewds yet of course).

For some people - like me - character and relationship development is the (or one of the) most important part(s) of an AVN. I dont mind the "Mainstory/plot" being slow and "dragging" if the characters are great and interact in a fun way with each other, if it feels "real" and belieavable.

If thats the case, the avn has won me over already and i dont mind the plot barely progressing, it kinda just means more time for character interactions. Its a unqiue case where i like "filler", i hate it in close to any other medium.

In a way in these avns the main-plot is used to enrich the relationship developments.


Than theres the second group, these people need a "comapct" story and plot progression to really enjoy it, character interactions and development feels wasted to them if it doesnt progress the story.

And relationship development is more like a flavor to the mainstory to make it more enjoyable.

Something like City of broken dreamers is right along their alley. The Plot is progressing all the time and everything is related to it, the LIs are (imo) not that much fleshed out and more "along for the ride" instead of being the center of attention.

And while CobD is of course a good avn, its barely enjoyable to me, in this case it feels kinda meaningless to me. Why bother with looking for 10 days (in the avn) or something like that into this guys life and barely get to know anyone before
the story is already over.

But to guys who like these type of avns it probably feels like theres barely anything happening in SG.
 

mostwanted8

Active Member
Mar 8, 2024
954
8,261
One of the things I like about this game. An MC, being either a Massive DIK or a Massive CHICK in the SG world, will not have the same success as the one who acts according to the situation, is considerate of other characters, and does not hesitate to use common sense.

Let's take the Zara storyline.
First he teases and annoys her, and then publicly humiliates her. However, he attracts her interest. Now he is not just one of these pathetic weaklings, like Trey, but an arrogant and cocky boor who needs to be put in his place. Then he allows her to take revenge and feel like a winner for a while.

Further, when they meet at Nick's house, through manipulation, teasing and small concessions, he achieves that they become almost friends. And having achieved this, he then constantly maintains a balance, on the one hand, not allowing Zara's dominant nature to take over and spoil their growing friendship, and on the other hand, not going too far and showing that he cares about her and respects her.

It is not surprising that at the end of the fifth chapter she jumps with joy around him when she finds out that he will live in their house for some time. Was it just because of the opportunity to train together? Fuck if I'll buy it. No, that too, it's like a topping in a breadroll, but she's genuinely glad to be in his company and spend time with him.

Would he have achieved such an attitude from her on a purely dark path? I don’t think so, she would still feel insulted and humiliated and would try in every possible way to fight him. But she wouldn’t have accepted a slime from a purely light path either, she would probably have bullied him, if only because she doesn’t respect weaklings.

MC sets boundaries early on, has no qualms about being an asshole when it's needed, but rewards Zara for respecting boundaries and allowing her to play within those boundaries.

This is something that many other games do poorly: they are too straightforward. If they allow the MC to be evil or good, then he is either a complete moron and a sociopath, or he is so sweet, caring and helpful that most girls would puke from such a slime. But female game characters doesn't notice that. Cardboard cunts.
So true. Zara and Nika’s relationship started with them as enemies. The humiliation from losing the basketball game in such fashion and being exposed publicly only pushed their rivalry further. Nika put the seed of doubt in her mind, “how can such a lowlife best me? No one bests me!”
Zara’s whole life revolves around her need for approval as seen in her flashback, it’s her childhood trauma. Nika didn’t give her any approval at first which used to make her mad. Now that he has her attention and respect she’s CRAVING that approval by being playful, almost flirty and lovey-dovey. She submitted to him in a way. It’s sad really, it mirrors the pain she suffered when she was a child trying to be worthy in someone else’s eyes. She wants HIM more than anyone else to recognize her as worthy now.
My hope is as Nika we’ll be able to show her that she doesn’t need to be #1 all the time and that she’s worthy and lovable as she is.
 
4.30 star(s) 555 Votes