Yeah, I went through again, with skip turned on and chose Stay with "Libby" in the coffee house and got some more content that way, nothing physical but some visual and extra choices. I also redid the "Victoria" quest, choosing to lie this time(which I think is the wrong thing to do, I think you should be rewarded for telling the truth) and got her sex scene.
FWIW, I saw the exclamation on the shoes after the first playthrough but clicking on it acted like I had already seen the even, only got the "Nevermind" option.
If you see the "Never mind" option, you either have not yet met enough prerequisites to go to the café (for instance, if you hadn't had the MC talk to Libby in her room yet after the Prologue or something), or you had the MC go there on a weekend, in which case he wouldn't have the option to leave as of this version.
As far as
lying to Victoria, obviously realistically telling the truth is almost always the best option. However, in this particular case
she was feeling very self-conscious. So by making the other choice, it's not like
the MC is pulling the wool over her eyes; she even says she'll pretend to believe him (but with other words). But by not exacerbating
her existing doubts about herself by confirming the MC is getting it on with other women, she lets her guard down enough for the timing for sex to be accepted. She's not stupid; it's not like
the MC fools her or anything. But it's very easy
to lie to yourself if you can point to enough evidence — fake (the MC said he didn't) or not — to support your self-deception. Also, if you haven't yet had the MC go to the clothing store and met Penny (again, with Victoria this time), you should do so (afternoons, talk to Victoria in the living room). While there,
if the MC looks at Penny's butt plug, Victoria will notice — and get very turned on (as long as he praises how she looks beautiful, etc.), despite her initial reaction.