I apologize in advance, but I think this is probably the largest post I’m likely to ever do here (unless I wind up developing a game or something). I’ll use spoilers to minimize the size as much as possible. TLDR Version: I have WAY too much free time on my hands at work and should probably be ignored by anyone who doesn’t want to hurt their brain cells.
Well, he was taken against his will and force drafted into their crime syndicate with no option to decline or leave, for an indefinite amount of time. WHY she did it would quite frankly be rather irrelevant to me if I were in his place. I'd rather have an average life than work for murderous mobsters, even if there is a lot of money to be had. I will wait, however, and see what's up with these assassination attempts on him, that might tide me over. But until then I consider them hostile.
100% agree with this vibe and it is my biggest complaint of the game (really only complaint so far as I like every NPC, the pacing, the setting, and the intrigue – though extremely displeased with the MC).
As an avid pen & paper gamer in my much younger days, I tend do the same.
Another long time P&P player, so figured I’d give my thoughts regarding how the MC differs from how I would prefer him to play it. What really frustrates me is that the main character just seems to say okie dokie and go along with everything and has only token push back with a minimal attempt to find out more information.
I understand these may all vary widely from the intended story being told, but the lack of these options really saddened me. What I would like the MC to say or do in certain scenes (I tend to be a pretty antagonistic person, and in the MC’s position I would double down on it for the same reasons oidex mentions above, but I genuinely hope are never implemented as it would probably get the MC killed pretty quickly for being too mouthy/rude):
pretty large wall of text, you’ve been warned 8^D
For all my complaints about these scenes, I do actually like the game a lot and am very happy about the story development so far and this is on my short list of favorite games (though why I don’t have a dream sequence with Luna after that date I do not understand – give us the sexy dreams for our psychotic murderhobo girlfriend already!!!! and before anyone says it, yes I understand rendering scenes take time and yadda yadda and all that jazz, but I was very disappointed I didn’t get a new dream after this scene as it was probably my favorite of the game so far), but as a role player it just really irks me how quickly the MC accepts the situation and is willing to jump into it willy-nilly.
it could be, his impetuous attitude and his complaints with Cordia about treating him like a kid could suggest that he has resentment, but aside from that he seems like a nice guy, it could play out like you said, or it could lead to a early death because or his wish to prove himself as a grown man that will be the next Don, seems like the next part of the story will be Hope and Antonio going after that crazy guy I forgot the name, so that's why I think it wouldn't take long for Antonio to die if the dev goes for this storyline, he already has everything set up for it
but if he is not an asshole and he doesn't die, would be awkward to get sexually involved with Isabel, I don't think that even her would want that, she seems to really love him when she speaks about how relations usually play out with the heads of important families, would be weird to see her go full slut and cheat on Antonio, there is just no reason for it, he didn't blame her for the loss of their child and Isabel seems grateful for it
I really like the emotion that it gives us for him, but I don’t know that I agree about him being a nice guy. I really haven’t gotten that vibe from his character yet. He doesn’t like you or you being treated like more than a slave, and he is apparently dismissive of his wife. Yes he doesn’t blame her for the miscarriage, but it appears that though he doesn’t blame her, he sure as hell doesn’t do much with her now (unless my understanding of the relationship from the table scene is wrong). The wife clearly dotes on him, but he seems like a cold fish towards her to her frustration and that is why she is open towards flirting with you (again, I may be misinterpreting their relationship).
I would actually love to see his character developed further (another reason I don’t want him to die early) because I think he makes a really interesting potential antagonist (doubly so if he is the one trying to kill you) and provides potential plot hooks:
not as bad as the last one (I promise)
But yeah, in either case I guess she takes it as her responsibility and duty to take care of MC
I really don’t get this vibe from her. Yes, she needs him alive because of the contract, but other she hasn’t really proven that she is taking care of him (at least from MC point of view) beyond paying lip service to it. She is refusing to give him info about the contract even when his life is directly threatened because of it and she knows the length to which he is willing to risk his own safety by trying to find more information. She hasn’t gotten a new copy of the book that everyone lives their lives by in the families (which leaves him open to mistakes that can cost him his life). This leaves MC open to being influenced against the family by someone else getting a hold of his contract and using it against him depending on what the contract is about. She also has allowed him to be poisoned in her home (no known investigation has been done to find out who poisoned him) and placed him in a position to be used as bait for those trying to kill him (no other legit reason to have him accompany the sisters in their punishment, though my thoughts on the contract below would probably change the legit reason aspect, but from MC POV there wasn’t a good justification and he actually called her out on it somewhat).
Makes me a bit curious about what she actually knows and her motives.
Completely agree with you on this and I think the reason is probably tied to the contract.
My thoughts on the contract:
Assuming anyone has survived this, and their eyes haven’t burst out of their skulls yet, you now know a little about how my warped mind works.