Fair points regarding the date.
Not sure if "wrongdoings" is the correct word here, english is not my first language. What I meant was behaviour like quoted two posts above this one. Luna is (imo) rightfully mad at him and Gracie made a fair statement he'd better not be making moves behind her back and he responded by making them feel bad and like it's their fault. Same with his reaction after Luna finished her story and wanted to leave the room. Just a bit too much for my own liking. All in all it gives me the impression MC's relationships to those two are not at eye level.
So while when it comes to individual characters, for now Gracie and especially Luna are a bit ahead of Isabel, when it comes to relationships, I much prefer MC - Isabel. It simply feels more balanced to me. Just played her events again with couple different choices and I like the dynamics between them, the constant back and forth. Though who knows what might still come for Isabel's character, she is a black hole after all.
And fwiw, yes I noticed the "too weak" comments and I don't get those at all haha. While he's trying to stay under the radar, I never got the impression this whole Mafia/Underworld business would impress him too much. But that's just me.
English isn't my first language either.
I'm guessing you're referring to the 2 events "My name is Luna" (where MC tries to inquire about the Mysterious 6 from Wilfred, and Wilfred tells Luna about it making her mad, and how he responds after she tells her captive story) as well as "The Blizzard Princess" (where Gracie scares the bejesus out of him with that twisted "I'll hurt you" joke).
Well, some people may not like those scenes, but I feel pretty different about them.
1) Luna finds out MC wants to know about Mysterious 6:
Sure, Luna was 100% in the right, and even MC admits to himself saying "I poked my nose in where I didn't belong."
But I feel how MC acted (pretending to be mad following Pop's advice) was pretty necessary for Luna's arc in general. MC pretending to be mad brought a fair amount of needed levity (their interactions in the living room) before the whole very, very heavy and sorrowful story with the flashbacks.
If MC hadn't acted the way he did (and for example, just apologized), he would have never gotten Luna to open up to him.
By pretending to be mad and with the result of ongoing interaction with Luna, he was able to ask the question:
"Luna, why it it so bad that I should know of your past?" (or something along those lines).
2) MC's reaction after Luna tells her story:
Now this is a topic that I've seen mentioned few times before, with some people saying "Oh he's being insensitive and acting like an asshole to her."
But again, I see it differently.
After hearing Luna's story, MC says "I will help."
But Luna says "Don't be stupid. I've said my story, so soon we can all just go back to how we were before." (okay, not exact, but something along those lines)
Basically, she was shutting down his notion (not in any offensive way) that he will actually help her and was trying to divert his attention elsewhere.
In Luna's perspective, I guess she was trying to protect MC by dissuading him, but MC needed her to wake up and realize he's gonna help her no matter what (show her that he's stubborn).
Could he have tried to convey his reasoning in a more gentle way?
Perhaps. But there's no telling whether Luna would have listened to him in that approach.
With the way he acted, he really hammered his point across to her that he will not relent in his action of helping her (regarding Mysterious 6).
And some may disagree, but in my eyes that's exactly what Luna needed to hear (which Gracie eventually said saying "MC is not like mom or Uncle Wilfred. He will help you even if it makes you upset that he's not listening to you.")
3) Gracie's twisted "joke" after reconciliation with Isabel:
Yes, MC is using the cameras (or audio recorder, depending on player choice. I'm on cameras since I find it to be a much more interesting option), and he definitely is in the wrong doing that.
But she still made a joke in which she said "I will...... hurt you." which scared the shit out of the MC.
While it's not wrong for Gracie to possibly accuse MC of doing something behind her back (like spying on them), that sort of joke noone will find funny, and MC being upset with Gracie about it (when she says she was just kidding), I find to be a pretty normal behavior.
Having said that with the way Gracie is, one can say it's partly due to how sheltered she got raised, lacking in socialization and she lacks in understanding what people find acceptable or not.
So all in all, I find how MC acted in all situations to be acceptable.
Yes, he was in the wrong in all of these situations, but he's just doing what he has to do; whether it's to dig for the truth, making his point crystal clear across, or showing how a person generally reacts to another person acting in a scary way.
Isabel, I find to be.......... okay.
Her arc I find to be the least interesting out of all the main girls (for me, most interesting girl is Luna, then Cordia, then Gracie, then afterwards Isabel), but everyone's preferences will differ.
Some will prefer Luna. Some Gracie. Some Cordia, and others Isabel.