- Dec 1, 2019
- 8,766
- 14,874
You have the right to any such content Hopes created. You do not have the right to demand a certain amount or a certain timeframe for that - as you correctly stated those terms are set by the creator. If in doubt, ask before subbing. As with any business you have to gather all data you need for your decision before doing it, any wrong assumptions on somebody's part about pecularities are not part of a contract you enter. Here you can probably argue that - with this tier existing - this stuff must exist in general.There's a lot of things wrong with this. What you defined is something called as charity. Where you just pay to support someone or some cause.
While there is an aspect of support in Patreon, there is an equal aspect of business. The only difference is that this transaction is done in good faith between the content creator and the subscriber. The content creator is solely in control of the terms here though.
Let's take the example of Hopes . There is a 30$ tier where this is what is promised,
So say I am part of this tier for the last year, do you think I have the right the ask the creator to deliver this? Assuming that the creator has not delivered any such unique art, do I have a right for a refund for 12 months in this case? One can say, you can just unsubscribe but as a subscriber you are completely at the mercy of the content creator to deliver on the promises of the tier and the subscriber cannot do anything except to keep waiting.
- Access to all kinds of unique art and unused content which got cut from the game
Many content creators have taken advantage of this very fact and milking subscribers without delivering. Delaying content for months and even years in some cases.
The reason we cannot apply this to Hopes here is that he has been pretty up front with his communication. But saying that a subscriber on Patreon has no right to complain is heading down a dangerous path.
But as for "charity" - if you read the "Mission and Vision" of patreon (I don't know which overused synergetic proactive paradigm of a buzzword they actually use - maybe it's "Our Philosophy" or something like that) you'll see that it is more or less exactly that. Founded so that creators can go on creating without having to deliver anything tangible and you - as a man of culture and supporter of the arts - help them doing that. Thus the name. (Nevermind that it helps Patreon since it takes away the responsibility to actually check what's going on with their projects ...)
Yes, there are certain limits to what an artist can do (as I said: "you get all access to tapes from my recording sessions" is probably only feasible if such tapes exist), but again as you state, if the artist communicates clearly and correctly what they are doing and answers possible questions truthfully, you can still complain (everybody can complain about everything, freedom of speech and such stuff) but you would be wrong. But, for the record, in this thread I am talking about this game, its dev and his behavior.