Ok, really like this one. Have not read 2nd Chance.
The bad, the renders are not the greatest quality but certainly far from the worst I have seen (and do improve over the story to be fair). I do think there are far too many reused renders for scenes though. Animations, honestly are terrible, utterly terrible. I'll say it again, if can't do them properly (and I know what a PITA and time-sink they are) you're just better not having them at all. But that's my own perspective. Also refer back to reused renders again here. More effort to tell the story/show what is happening could be made (in line with this, a pet peeve of mine is dialogue/descriptions not matching what is seen).
The good, the story is great, content is up my alley for sure. Dialogue actually seems to be written by an adult and not a 14yo virgin. Sex dialogue also kept to a minimum which is also a preference for me (though I don't play/read VN's for the lewds). Sheets on beds! Gain huge marks for this alone, so many just don't bother and it irks the fuck out of me. Character models are nice, script is pretty good and the relations all happen in a reasonably organic way which is also another major plus point. Another major plus is the internal monologuing. I think you have it just right, too many VN's have far too much.
Third person narrative? Didn't bother me personally. Is it unusual in a VN? For sure but it's not a deal-breaker or jarring. I wonder if this comes from 2nd Chance which was test based? There are some slight issues with plot/what happens/MC's actions etc (like I think moving Jenny into the house was a little out there) but that is more expecting something from a character we are playing, but ultimately, we are not that person, so what 'we' would do/say in a given situation is different. I do think some things could have been expanded on, for example, when we find out THS are monitoring Jenny's phone...why did we not question if they are doing the same with us? Little things like that I would do/wonder/ask but our MC doesn't...
Regardless, enjoy this and looking forward to seeing where it goes.