Mad King so after replaying the entire game there's another major issue. it involves the subtly that implies morgana knowing the twins are still alive. just after MC recovered from his poisoning, she gives signs of knowing what happened with them. and in conversation with MC's father just after, there's hinting that something other than MC's poisoning was supposed to happen.
then when MC and morgana have their first heart to heart just after gunther's first appearance, she doesn't tell MC she knew about the twins not being dead/betraying him. but anyways, she should damn well know another secret like the twins would damage her relationship with MC. she should have told him right then and there.
later on the island where you decide gunther's fate morgana still doesn't tell you about the twins... at this point i was thinking it'd be better if the twins were actually dead from the get go. the blow back on morgana is starting to become too much. there's also some issue with morgana talking about the gods judging gunther on her [i have desires] path. she rejects the gods now remember... her advocating for gunther's life will still make sense though, he may prove useful later on. and morgana's a bit of an idealist.
3rd strike she's out! just after deciding what to do with gunther morgana has another chance to tell mc about the twins. sorry mad king, at this point the twins need to remain dead. otherwise we can't trust morgana at all. i can actually forgive morgana for offering a seat on the council in desperation, but seeing as there was at least 2 major hints that she knew the twins live... yea... no. i can't trust her at this point. not fully.
also speaking of the twins, it seems my conjecture about the plot hole was right. they had no reason to leave the MC alive, even if he was in the process of dying. and with this update they are written as complete sociopaths and quite out of character too i might add. how can they so flawlessly deceive the MC for YEARS like that. sorry to say it
Mad King but you made a big oops in writing them this way. it just doesn't work.
some other small/mid-sized things that could be added/changed: