RustyV

Conversation Conqueror
Game Developer
Dec 30, 2017
6,663
30,706
Have you not met Elena yet? Or Jennifer?
The appearance of Elena and especially Jennifer have bothered me from the beginning of DMD. For my taste Jennifer is just not sexually attractive, which for me takes away from any scene she is in.
Many of the body proportions of both Elena and Jennifer appear young. Such as their larger heads in relation to their body size, or lack of some well developed sexual characteristics.
As far as D appearing to be 16 that is much more eye-of-the-beholder. There are 16 year old girls who look like D (we often call them cheerleaders) but girls into their 20's have D's body as well. That is why you have to check a girl's ID with much more scrutiny.
If you compare Sophie from Melody to Elena there is a difference. IMO maybe as a result of the Patreon Purge Sophie appears as a petite woman with more adult body proportions.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

armion82

Devoted Member
Mar 28, 2017
11,932
16,017
The appearance of Elena and especially Jennifer have bothered me from the beginning of DMD. For my taste Jennifer is just not sexually attractive, which for me takes away from any scene she is in.
Many of the body proportions of both Elena and Jennifer appear young. Such as their larger heads in relation to their body size, or lack of some well developed sexual characteristics.
As far as D appearing to be 16 that is much more eye-of-the-beholder. There are 16 year old girls who look like D (we often call them cheerleaders) but girls into their 20's have D's body as well. That is why you have to check a girl's ID with much more scrutiny.
If you compare Sophie from Melody to Elena there is a difference. IMO maybe as a result of the Patreon Purge Sophie appears as a petite woman with more adult body proportions.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Well.Good that you have a choice if you want Elena and Sophie:)
BTW I am still wondering what is the suprise for Elena for winning the poll.
 

fried

Almost
Moderator
Donor
Nov 11, 2017
2,311
6,079
You know, the "they look too young to me, I apparently don't live in the real world" posts are finally sliding by me, for a change!

...

OK, maybe not.

I think RustyV's critique of Jennifer's relative head size is probably the most meaningful I've seen over the past year or so, but even that is more an artistic/modelling issue than anything else, IMHO. I suspect that happened because MrDots may have tried to make a balance of proportions for her body that didn't quite fit - e.g., if he used the Growing Up product for Genesis 3 Female to make a petite body (and, that's a common toolset these days), that tends to leave heads relatively larger than expected and manual adjustment is often needed.

As mentioned in past flareups of this topic, you can get an idea of their relative sizes from here:



Jennifer is obviously petite, but she's not a kid - I know young women who look the same size or smaller, for example. A coworker of mine was the same relative height with an even smaller chest. There is an Assistant working at our dentist's office who is about 4'6" and rather thin, with a very young face ... and she's in her 20s.

People complaining about underage appearances may be more sensitized to that topic in this case, I feel: the characters' dialogue and actions are clearly intended to offer that they are older teens and/or younger adults in this adult game.
 
Jul 20, 2017
297
511
Thanks for telling me how to get a tag corrected even if we disagree on this, sincerely. I had no idea how to. XD Guess that shows how new to f95 I am huh.
 

Tristrix

Member
Jun 30, 2019
209
429
You know, the "they look too young to me, I apparently don't live in the real world" posts are finally sliding by me, for a change!

...

OK, maybe not.

I think RustyV's critique of Jennifer's relative head size is probably the most meaningful I've seen over the past year or so, but even that is more an artistic/modelling issue than anything else, IMHO. I suspect that happened because MrDots may have tried to make a balance of proportions for her body that didn't quite fit - e.g., if he used the Growing Up product for Genesis 3 Female to make a petite body (and, that's a common toolset these days), that tends to leave heads relatively larger than expected and manual adjustment is often needed.

As mentioned in past flareups of this topic, you can get an idea of their relative sizes from here:



Jennifer is obviously petite, but she's not a kid - I know young women who look the same size or smaller, for example. A coworker of mine was the same relative height with an even smaller chest. There is an Assistant working at our dentist's office who is about 4'6" and rather thin, with a very young face ... and she's in her 20s.

People complaining about underage appearances may be more sensitized to that topic in this case, I feel: the characters' dialogue and actions are clearly intended to offer that they are older teens and/or younger adults in this adult game.
Cliche as it sounds, it's all a matter of taste. I don't see anyone in the current discussion suggesting there's anything wrong with the girls' appearance beyond pointing out that they're just not appealing to them personally. I realize the whole conversation can take on an ominous air if it comes off like someone is chastising you for being into petite girls but I'm certainly not doing that and I don't thing Rusty is either.

Y'all like what you like. Personally, I'll take Georgina over Jennifer any day of the week but if you think the MC can fit that giant fucking salami into Jennifer's 4'10", 90 pound body, best of luck to you. Try not to break her.
 

crugh2112

Well-Known Member
Oct 9, 2017
1,063
1,313
Cliche as it sounds, it's all a matter of taste. I don't see anyone in the current discussion suggesting there's anything wrong with the girls' appearance beyond pointing out that they're just not appealing to them personally. I realize the whole conversation can take on an ominous air if it comes off like someone is chastising you for being into petite girls but I'm certainly not doing that and I don't thing Rusty is either.

Y'all like what you like. Personally, I'll take Georgina over Jennifer any day of the week but if you think the MC can fit that giant fucking salami into Jennifer's 4'10", 90 pound body, best of luck to you. Try not to break her.
She and Mr. Panda along with her Mom's golden dildo have been getting ready for the schlong of destruction...
 

fried

Almost
Moderator
Donor
Nov 11, 2017
2,311
6,079
Cliche as it sounds, it's all a matter of taste. I don't see anyone in the current discussion suggesting there's anything wrong with the girls' appearance beyond pointing out that they're just not appealing to them personally. I realize the whole conversation can take on an ominous air if it comes off like someone is chastising you for being into petite girls but I'm certainly not doing that and I don't thing Rusty is either.

Y'all like what you like. Personally, I'll take Georgina over Jennifer any day of the week but if you think the MC can fit that giant fucking salami into Jennifer's 4'10", 90 pound body, best of luck to you. Try not to break her.
Curious assumption you've made, but my post had nothing to do with personal tastes :unsure:

"Ominous air?"

I say thee nay! This is about objective analysis, which all serious adult VN gamers must eventually master, lest they be thrown into the pit of unwarranted claims, worries and poorly organized game saves. Well, and potentially willful ignorance, of which there seems an awful lot these days online. It's almost as if anyone can connect to the Internet, join boards and type weird things.

On the more serious side, each time these "loli game!" claims flare up, as soon as people try to map these characters to either their relative actions or physiques in the game or our real world, it sounds far more like their personal sensitivity to the subject area than anything meaningful. Similar to people saying they definitely don't enjoy certain body (e.g., small-breasted) or character (e.g., trans) types compared to others (e.g., professional model proportions), so why must they be presented with those they don't like? It's inherently requesting that they see less of what they don't like, which is a valid request, but for a game that's as old as this one you are NOT going to get changes in long-standing characters at this time.

There are plenty of intentionally loli games out there, this is one which has different body types and otherwise legal age-acting and intended characters, by all appearances. We can debate details (and have, many times), but in the end it always ends up at the same point.
 

RustyV

Conversation Conqueror
Game Developer
Dec 30, 2017
6,663
30,706
Jennifer is obviously petite, but she's not a kid

I feel: the characters' dialogue and actions are clearly intended to offer that they are older teens and/or younger adults in this adult game.
That is valid.
For me it's just that Jennifer is not personally appealing as say Sophie, or even Ada (Parental Love).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jaun Karr and fried

dynamix911

Newbie
Dec 24, 2018
21
19
Started playing this a few days ago and I usually like to play games blind my first time then go back with a walkthrough to get stuff I missed. I guess I should've taken the warning when I saw the game has hard-fail states, but it always seemed like it was just an immediate choice that could easily be rolled back.

Was pretty unhappy when I got to day 13 and found out that my choice not to go to the police about Lucas 3 days ago caused me an unavoidable fail state that I'll have to replay a big chunk of the game to rectify. Are there more choices like this that can cause you to have to replay multiple days if you get them wrong in chapters 2 and 3?
 
Mar 7, 2018
427
596
You know, the "they look too young to me, I apparently don't live in the real world" posts are finally sliding by me, for a change!

...

OK, maybe not.

I think RustyV's critique of Jennifer's relative head size is probably the most meaningful I've seen over the past year or so, but even that is more an artistic/modelling issue than anything else, IMHO. I suspect that happened because MrDots may have tried to make a balance of proportions for her body that didn't quite fit - e.g., if he used the Growing Up product for Genesis 3 Female to make a petite body (and, that's a common toolset these days), that tends to leave heads relatively larger than expected and manual adjustment is often needed.

As mentioned in past flareups of this topic, you can get an idea of their relative sizes from here:



Jennifer is obviously petite, but she's not a kid - I know young women who look the same size or smaller, for example. A coworker of mine was the same relative height with an even smaller chest. There is an Assistant working at our dentist's office who is about 4'6" and rather thin, with a very young face ... and she's in her 20s.

People complaining about underage appearances may be more sensitized to that topic in this case, I feel: the characters' dialogue and actions are clearly intended to offer that they are older teens and/or younger adults in this adult game.
You are totally right, we have seen this discussion thousends of times, its just the usual, almost makes me not want to play this game anymore because i think MrDots has fell to their abuse and stoped making any scenes with the normal/petite women, no new in 6 months now... well good post again, i don't know how you can stand making them over and over, but good job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fried

fbass

Member
May 18, 2017
409
588
Started playing this a few days ago and I usually like to play games blind my first time then go back with a walkthrough to get stuff I missed. I guess I should've taken the warning when I saw the game has hard-fail states, but it always seemed like it was just an immediate choice that could easily be rolled back.

Was pretty unhappy when I got to day 13 and found out that my choice not to go to the police about Lucas 3 days ago caused me an unavoidable fail state that I'll have to replay a big chunk of the game to rectify. Are there more choices like this that can cause you to have to replay multiple days if you get them wrong in chapters 2 and 3?
The saves don't carry over, you pick your stats at the beginning of each new chapter. I usually try games the same as you but this one is 1000 times easier and better if you use the walk through
 

dynamix911

Newbie
Dec 24, 2018
21
19
The saves don't carry over, you pick your stats at the beginning of each new chapter. I usually try games the same as you but this one is 1000 times easier and better if you use the walk through
Thanks, that's good to know. I'll start playing with a walkthrough.
 

armion82

Devoted Member
Mar 28, 2017
11,932
16,017
Started playing this a few days ago and I usually like to play games blind my first time then go back with a walkthrough to get stuff I missed. I guess I should've taken the warning when I saw the game has hard-fail states, but it always seemed like it was just an immediate choice that could easily be rolled back.

Was pretty unhappy when I got to day 13 and found out that my choice not to go to the police about Lucas 3 days ago caused me an unavoidable fail state that I'll have to replay a big chunk of the game to rectify. Are there more choices like this that can cause you to have to replay multiple days if you get them wrong in chapters 2 and 3?
No.
Why you don't use saves?It's a rule when you play VN to save before a choice or a new scene.After all you can make like several thousands saves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RustyV

cxx

Message Maestro
Nov 14, 2017
58,135
28,856
if you think the MC can fit that giant fucking salami into Jennifer's 4'10", 90 pound body, best of luck to you. Try not to break her.
Elena is ~same size and she has taken mc's schlong easily. Just enuf lubrication and .............

Thanks, that's good to know. I'll start playing with a walkthrough.
good choice since there are few fails and best choices aren't always that clear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fried
3.80 star(s) 322 Votes