Most incest games bore me a bit when it's all nicey nicey and the daughters are really up for getting with the father and he's all like 'no no I can't you're my daughter' until they win him over. It is however super spicey if a father is being domineering and controlling and basically forcing his daughters into doing a bunch of degrading things for his pleasure. So the pictures with the girls crying on the banner definitely caught my attention.
I think it needs to be said at the start that you can't go into the negative with all 3 girls, it says "taking kindness or austerity to exaggerations can lead to unpleasant surprises" but that's really not clear... I didn't mind so much as I wasn't interested in the older one so I can have her as my token positive girl, but woulda liked a heads up and not had to start over.
The language doesn't flow quite right, but it's fine enough, and I get it if it's not the dev's native language I couldn't imagine making something in another one. The renders were good, I was surprised as it says the dev is using a potato laptop and I thought that wouldn't really allow for these kinda daz ones and honeyselect is the fallback that lowspec folks have to use.
I liked a good chunk of the cast. I've got a thing for sweet little innocent blondes with brunette eyebrows (dunno why that's important), and girls that look like they've made some bad life choices so the younger 2 daughters are right up my alley. I also thought the red-head and her anorexia plotline could be hot (I'm hoping that means she's kinda got those tight skinny abs, but dunno if game models allow for that).
So yeah overall I enjoyed it, I'm hoping it'll get appropriately dark on the strict paths, bit of a shame so far all the hotness is just in his dreams but it makes sense given how early on it is. I'm also hoping there won't be a bunch of stat annoyances where if you're going for the negative stuff you'll need to get it down enough but not too much without ever knowing what those values are until it happens... or else it'll be pretty annoying to play without a cheatmod where you can adjust them on the fly.
Edit: Oh and the menu is aligned too far up, it means the start button (or history during the game) overlaps with whatever the title of the page (like Preferences, Load, etc)
16 Years Later v0.2 - Walkthrough Mod v0.1
Given that for some negative values would be a good thing, then for a walkthrough I think it'd be most handy for it just to show what stat changes the options give, and then use the green highlighting to show if there's smut down that particular line so if people are be okay with losing (or gaining) some points to get it they can see it's there too.