VN Ren'Py A Man for All [Ep.14] [Venus Waltz]

[-CookieMonster666-]

That's what i just did. Interesting story, subpar LI's, too many forced sex scenes, cool fighting segments, feels like it was written by a 16 years old. A good 6.5/10 for me, but enjoyable nonetheless.

This is a discussion forum. I discussed my opinion on a game i just found and am curious how my opinions ressemble or differ from other people playing this game for a while.

Not everyone type a reply to just say: incest with mom when? Random npc touched a LI's hand, NTR crusade!! or to make a tierlist.

You missed the sarcasm. That post was saying that you were verbose in going over every aspect of the game. Just FYI.

As for the "forced sex", there actually isn't any. If you make choices (the white ones) that lead you down the path resulting in sex, that's your own decision. But you have choices to accept LIs or not. These decisions take you down the path to pursuing an LI (or side girl), which eventually results in sex with them. If you don't want sex with said girl, don't choose to pursue her (don't kiss her, don't say the MC has a crush on her, don't say the MC is fighting for her, don't choose sex after a lap dance, etc.). It's pretty straightforward IMO; you even have text like "(No sex)" or similar to tell you what the outcome of a choice will be. I can't understand how you might have gotten surprised by any sex scenes, TBH.

 

[Antherak]

You missed the sarcasm. That post was saying that you were verbose in going over every aspect of the game. Just FYI.

I admit i missed it. Harder to gauge sarcasm in an online post than irl with itonations and such, i'm sorry.

As for the "forced sex", there actually isn't any. If you make choices (the white ones) that lead you down the path resulting in sex, that's your own decision. But you have choices to accept LIs or not.

i didn't meant forced sex scenes as "unavoidables" scenes without a choice. I know you can skip them. I just meant that that i felt many scenes were so out of place (for example the one with Seo, the one with Lorelei, the random Jordan scenes), and were just added to pad the number of sex scenes per chapter and did not fit at all. Personally, if the dev's goal was 4 scenes per chapter for example, i would have preferred to try and fit 2 scenes with the same "main-ish" girls than a random very low-tier npc. Not to say a one night stand with a total stranger can't work, but you have to at least bring it in a somewhat believable fashion.

And as to why i usually click yes on almost everyone in harem games is because if not, most of the time you are missing a lot more content as it is made for you to get 'em all. The only characters i always avoid in harem or in general (unless i make a mistake in a choice) are gay, futa, trans or with animal-like type ones. Not my things.

For me, i prefer scenes that flow and fit with what is happening, rather than force the situations, even if it means few scenes in total. But i also understand it's a porn game and some people just want lots of it regardless of what happens. And to be fair, i prefer it happening this way in a harem game rather than a more solo girl oriented game.

 

[PaxHadrian17]

That's what i just did. Interesting story, subpar LI's, too many forced sex scenes, cool fighting segments, feels like it was written by a 16 years old. A good 6.5/10 for me, but enjoyable nonetheless.

This is a discussion forum. I discussed my opinion on a game i just found and am curious how my opinions ressemble or differ from other people playing this game for a while.

Not everyone type a reply to just say: incest with mom when? Random npc touched a LI's hand, NTR crusade!! or to make a tierlist.

I am enjoying this AVN even if I think you are not giving the creator much credit for writing style/story (written by a 16 year old is harsh but you are entitled to your opinion).

The title means, IMO, a Man for All - so a harem game.

This requires a significant departure from RL - suspension of belief - to be enjoyed for what it is.

Within the boundaries of the story being told, I think this is well written and rendered.

There are a variety of women - the All part of the title - and some appeal to me more than others (Harlow, Kate, Riley, Vanessa).

I also appreciate women like Erica, even if I would not choose to date them myself.

She looks worse now than she did 3 releases ago, for example (looks worse in terms of her motivation and interactions with the MC).

We still have more story to tell so I am not going to judge any of the women until AMFA is completed, including any epilogue moments.

Erica is, for all we know, a single mother who lost her child due to marrying a manipulative asshat who is preventing her from seeing her baby.

Her story could be that she will do almost Anything to find a way to be reunited with her child and that includes lies/manipulation of the MC so she can make $ to move to a better part of town and hire a good lawyer to get her child back.

In this scenario - if I was the MC, I would not appreciate the lies and manipulation, But I would understand the motivation.

At this stage - we just don't know.

While the creator is not going to win a Pulitzer for his writing, I feel like it is top third or better for the AVNs I've tried and enjoyed (something like 200+ so far - and I admit that I am happy to give new creators a shot by spending my time trying to immerse myself in their stories).

I'm looking forward to the next rev and what feels like a significant evolution in the MC/Riley relationship.

Cheers!!