Recommending An annoyed fucking user's Tier List of Games with Actual Gameplay [150+ games rated]

[madbat/]]

Alright, this is the biggest update yet. Here's the changelog:


And I do increasingly wonder... why do I even do this? This was a lot of work. But look at how much time I must have spent playing these games, the majority of which are crap. Is there nothing better I could have done with my time?

Look like someone wants a good game I see. If you want you can check these 4 games. (best play in order below)


1
https://f95zone.to/threads/parade-buster-final-excessm.11923/
2
https://f95zone.to/threads/one-x-shota-act-smash-boy-excessm.15829/
3
https://f95zone.to/threads/yume-same-v1-1-excessm.80096/#post-5588595
4
https://f95zone.to/threads/oneshota-swordplay-act-hagokoro-v1-06-excessm.85948/

In games 2 and 3 you beat the enemy on a map in 3 lanes. The difference betwines those two is in 2's game you chose mission and teleport to the arena and get weapons and skills but in the 3" game you have a whole map to explore and beat an enemy and you have 1 weapon that can transform into a different kind with different skills.
but now (in my opinion) better games that are 1 and 4 games have a whole different kind of gameplay(you click/attack enemies with different weapons or guar, give osu vibes for crit hits, hard to explain check yourself). good story in every game
as for NSFW stuff:
female domination
Shota
animation mostly above good
voice really good
can find weird 1 or 2 weird fetish animations but mostly it's normal...... except balls kicking but that does not count as the main thigh of ero parts
highly recommended

 

[j0xssdf3]

https://f95zone.to/threads/dungeon-town-final-circle-meimite.95236/ Feel like you might like this. Art is alright, but there's so much shit to do and has above-average gameplay (imo).

Also gonna have to disagree with you putting Rignetta's Adventures in C-Tier. Pixel art seems to be a lot better than the art in that entire tier (or maybe my standards are too high lol).

 

[Straylite]

Thank you.
This list and this information helped me greatly.
I appreciate the time used to make something like this.

 

[AnAnnoyedFuckingUser]

Quick followup update with some games I found on my hard drive that I forgot to include.

2022-03-28: Added: Violet Storm, Magical Waifus Academy, IslanDeity, Barrage!, Project Elimination; Reclassified Rignetta's Adventure

Look like someone wants a good game I see. If you want you can check these 4 games. (best play in order below)


1
https://f95zone.to/threads/parade-buster-final-excessm.11923/
2
https://f95zone.to/threads/one-x-shota-act-smash-boy-excessm.15829/
3
https://f95zone.to/threads/yume-same-v1-1-excessm.80096/#post-5588595
4
https://f95zone.to/threads/oneshota-swordplay-act-hagokoro-v1-06-excessm.85948/

In games 2 and 3 you beat the enemy on a map in 3 lanes. The difference betwines those two is in 2's game you chose mission and teleport to the arena and get weapons and skills but in the 3" game you have a whole map to explore and beat an enemy and you have 1 weapon that can transform into a different kind with different skills.
but now (in my opinion) better games that are 1 and 4 games have a whole different kind of gameplay(you click/attack enemies with different weapons or guar, give osu vibes for crit hits, hard to explain check yourself). good story in every game
as for NSFW stuff:
female domination
Shota
animation mostly above good
voice really good
can find weird 1 or 2 weird fetish animations but mostly it's normal...... except balls kicking but that does not count as the main thigh of ero parts
highly recommended

Thanks. I remember downloading these. I'm not sure what happened after, I will give them another shot.

https://f95zone.to/threads/dungeon-town-final-circle-meimite.95236/ Feel like you might like this. Art is alright, but there's so much shit to do and has above-average gameplay (imo).

Thanks, will definitely check this out, looks good.

Also gonna have to disagree with you putting Rignetta's Adventures in C-Tier. Pixel art seems to be a lot better than the art in that entire tier (or maybe my standards are too high lol).

You know what, you're right. Upgraded it to (high) B-Tier.

Thank you.
This list and this information helped me greatly.
I appreciate the time used to make something like this.

Thanks. I do what I must because I can.

 

[Deleted member 4238737]

Respect

 

[Ashcraig]

Have you tried Crimson Keep?
https://f95zone.to/threads/crimson-keep-ch-7-v1-6-introspurt.33488/

 

[ViviX12]

nice list, gonna come back here every now and then
a note about Hole Dweller, have you went through f1-f4? it changes the resolution, and atm only the first setting has the pixel filter

 

[HornyJail]

Weird seeing an RoR game listed, makes me wonder: which of these games actually work with the porn when it comes to rewards design? Which of them allow you to see, let's say more than half of the available content within gameplay (meaning no gallery unlock of defeat scenes) if you play perfectly? No deliberately incurring negatives, pursuing optional content is fine even if it doesn't bestow any advantages though.

VNs are honest, they're picture books. But the ludonarrative dissonance of deliberately trying to fail, over and over, in weirdly specific ways just kills the point of a "porn game" to me. Same with gallery unlocks, why would I want to see the "what if you lost and got raped to death" scene after beating the boss to avoid that fate.

it's a fetish thing. They wanna be in the nonconensual situation instead of just being plain vanilla. It's just that imo , if you're gonna make a game like that it needs to be tough so you can actually lose unintentionally BUT forgiving with deaths so you don't have to replay sections over and over

 

[ViviX12]

it's a fetish thing. They wanna be in the nonconensual situation instead of just being plain vanilla. It's just that imo , if you're gonna make a game like that it needs to be tough so you can actually lose unintentionally BUT forgiving with deaths so you don't have to replay sections over and over

well said, reminded me about two good games I didn't see on the list
https://f95zone.to/threads/lab-still-alive-neko-no-meme.5715/
https://f95zone.to/threads/lab2-under-ground-neko-no-meme.11797/
two quite great games, pretty neat pixel art, and most importantly while still lose for H, it's very forgiving and straightforward, enemies that H will H you immediately, those that don't, won't
most scenes are HP drains rather than gameovers, so after some HP buffs you can see whole scenes without dying, and I don't remember there being huge issues with regaining health
second game is sadly untranslated, but dialogue isn't necessary for playing and google translate does well enough for understanding it

 

[j0xssdf3]

Personally found it interesting that you put FoBS in A-tier and Succubus Affection in S-tier. Any reason for that?

 

[ggAkatsukiP]

Judging from the list, I cant recommend you most of my games due to our taste being vastly different. I also touched tons of garbo games and I swear although I like some rpg gerne, you will not like them due to grind.

The only one game that catch my eyes from your list, is the alien quest eve by Grimhelm, which also happened to be in my perma r18 game file.
My to be tested game file contain 250+ gb, but most of them are expected to be garbo and will not make it to my perma game file.

Maybe check these out :

Lilitales - Dungeon crawler style, has anime adaption, not a rogue gerne but rpg gerne. Has multiple story route and ending.

Princess Sacrifice _ Adventure of Feena - mouse point & click rpg gerne, dress up theme, has a lots of secret stuff, can be frustrating at certain fight being too hard and tedious save/load.

Pronant Symphony - rpgmaker, battle suck, heavy grind, play for story, not a lot of people play it until the end, multiple ending.

Zombie Retreat - rpgmaker, story is not that great, comes for girls, not disappointed. There's Zombie Retreat 2 in current development, you can check his patreon as well as download from there for free.

Virgin Invader - 2d side scroll action, defeat the enemy and rape them theme. For those who like to be dominant, this game is for them.

Fall in Labyrinth - rpgmaker, very very very grindy, lots lots lots dress up customization for girls, the only game so far I insisted to 100% and over 100 hours. Battle mechanic is badly balanced, rng chest can be tedious grind, game difficulty can become a joke due to certain broken equipment combination.

Atelier Tia - Have not finished, but I dump it into my perma game file already. 2D side scroll platforming, despite game name suggests Atelier, its nowhere near the core of Atelier games.

Maken Incubus (Demon Sword Incubus) - 2D side scroll action, require gamepad to have better gaming experience, I almost broke my gamepad due to its difficult input combo that is comparable to Street Fighter games.

Thanks for reading!

 

[AnAnnoyedFuckingUser]

• 2022-07-23: Added: Mission Mermaiden, Magic Castle Repure Aria 2, Juuyoku no Jousai, Matchmakers Inc, Elewder, Harem Dungeon, Maid Idle, Battle Heroine Crisis, Furry Cyberfucker, Metal Flame, Sinistar 2, Parade Buster, HDoom, Secrets of the Bastion, Aphrodisiac 2, Spunk Stock; Updated: Zetria, Last Evil, Alice in Cradle

It has been a while. I apologize for the absence. For one reason or another (medical, work) I haven't had much time or inclination to play porn games the past few months. But I have been keeping an eye on new releases and honestly, it feels like the quality just keeps on dropping. Nothing new that is really interesting imo.

I would like to point out Alice in Cradle for being ridiculously pretty, Zetria for being slick and having nice animations, Spunk Stock for being the best rhythm porn game as of yet (I should check back in on bindmancer...), and Magic Castle Repure Aria 2 for being the best overall porn game of this update.

As you can tell if you look at the actual ratings I didn't actually play too many of these games. Expect future updates to be slow and infrequent. I will keep an eye out for new stuff and maybe I will add individual games as I play them, but for now I consider this list to be reasonably complete.

 

[AnAnnoyedFuckingUser]

Weird seeing an RoR game listed, makes me wonder: which of these games actually work with the porn when it comes to rewards design? Which of them allow you to see, let's say more than half of the available content within gameplay (meaning no gallery unlock of defeat scenes) if you play perfectly? No deliberately incurring negatives, pursuing optional content is fine even if it doesn't bestow any advantages though.

VNs are honest, they're picture books. But the ludonarrative dissonance of deliberately trying to fail, over and over, in weirdly specific ways just kills the point of a "porn game" to me. Same with gallery unlocks, why would I want to see the "what if you lost and got raped to death" scene after beating the boss to avoid that fate.

I know this is responding to a fairly old post but I just saw someone quote it... the games I recommend are generally the ones I can fap to while playing the actual game. Scenes don't count. So the games further up the list generally synergize better between porn and gameplay than the ones at the bottom.

nice list, gonna come back here every now and then
a note about Hole Dweller, have you went through f1-f4? it changes the resolution, and atm only the first setting has the pixel filter

I have not, but I honestly don't care enough to go back and try it

well said, reminded me about two good games I didn't see on the list
https://f95zone.to/threads/lab-still-alive-neko-no-meme.5715/
https://f95zone.to/threads/lab2-under-ground-neko-no-meme.11797/
two quite great games, pretty neat pixel art, and most importantly while still lose for H, it's very forgiving and straightforward, enemies that H will H you immediately, those that don't, won't
most scenes are HP drains rather than gameovers, so after some HP buffs you can see whole scenes without dying, and I don't remember there being huge issues with regaining health
second game is sadly untranslated, but dialogue isn't necessary for playing and google translate does well enough for understanding it

I used to have these bookmarked for ages but never got around to play them. They would probably fit well into the list, I'll see if I can include them at some point. No promises

Personally found it interesting that you put FoBS in A-tier and Succubus Affection in S-tier. Any reason for that?

I liked that other one more

Judging from the list, I cant recommend you most of my games due to our taste being vastly different. I also touched tons of garbo games and I swear although I like some rpg gerne, you will not like them due to grind.

The only one game that catch my eyes from your list, is the alien quest eve by Grimhelm, which also happened to be in my perma r18 game file.
My to be tested game file contain 250+ gb, but most of them are expected to be garbo and will not make it to my perma game file.

Maybe check these out :

Lilitales - Dungeon crawler style, has anime adaption, not a rogue gerne but rpg gerne. Has multiple story route and ending.

Princess Sacrifice _ Adventure of Feena - mouse point & click rpg gerne, dress up theme, has a lots of secret stuff, can be frustrating at certain fight being too hard and tedious save/load.

Pronant Symphony - rpgmaker, battle suck, heavy grind, play for story, not a lot of people play it until the end, multiple ending.

Zombie Retreat - rpgmaker, story is not that great, comes for girls, not disappointed. There's Zombie Retreat 2 in current development, you can check his patreon as well as download from there for free.

Virgin Invader - 2d side scroll action, defeat the enemy and rape them theme. For those who like to be dominant, this game is for them.

Fall in Labyrinth - rpgmaker, very very very grindy, lots lots lots dress up customization for girls, the only game so far I insisted to 100% and over 100 hours. Battle mechanic is badly balanced, rng chest can be tedious grind, game difficulty can become a joke due to certain broken equipment combination.

Atelier Tia - Have not finished, but I dump it into my perma game file already. 2D side scroll platforming, despite game name suggests Atelier, its nowhere near the core of Atelier games.

Maken Incubus (Demon Sword Incubus) - 2D side scroll action, require gamepad to have better gaming experience, I almost broke my gamepad due to its difficult input combo that is comparable to Street Fighter games.

Thanks for reading!

I appreciate the suggestions, I have tried some of these in the past but did not include them for one reason or another

 

[j0xssdf3]

I liked that other one more

Well I assumed that, but any particular reason why?

 

[AnAnnoyedFuckingUser]

Well I assumed that, but any particular reason why?

Fobs has less story, simpler graphics, and overall feels smaller in scope

 

[SpiderEnthusiast]

Feels weird writing this, but thank you for this list.

 

[Xandania]

Overall I'd rate Sengoku Rance as an S+tier game. I came for the porn and stayed for hours (and plenty of replays) for the gameplay. Also, this game is funny in many situation involving the MC.

 

[AnAnnoyedFuckingUser]

Feels weird writing this, but thank you for this list.

I appreciate that

 

[j0xssdf3]

https://f95zone.to/threads/night-shift-at-fazclaires-nightclub-v0-2-zuryaaoki.125654/

Personally think you should try this, but when its more polished. I feel like it'll be a good game.

 

[Jeno]

Haven't gotten around to say thanks here, but thanks AnAnnoyedFuckingUser ! I can't say I agree with all your views, but I got several great games to play from this that I would've never encoutnered otherwise! Keep it up I'd say