Mostly, what happens in ep. 9 doesn't make sense. Just an example:
when you are in Josy&Maya's route: you are in love with Josy and she is your woman, isn't it? well, you see a syringe in Tommy's room (her brother!!) and you know he's a drug addict - well, you tell yourself it's not your business anyway and you don't tell her anything (how about a "girl, I think your brother needs help") - her DAD has just invited you at their house, dude!!
Man, you tell Josy & Sage that Chad and Troy are gay, and you don't tell your girlfriend that a guy just entered your room and pointed a gun at you ?!?!?!?! WTF, DrPinkCake!!!