Josy says that because she's scared, scared of losing both of them. If there were a woman around here, She could explain it better since that is a woman's thing, we men don't say things that way xD
probably "indecision" is the wrong term. Josy in those occasions knows what she should do, what it would be right to do, but she always lets herself be carried away by passion. and this often leads her to say "inappropriate" things.
the same behavior on the part of MC is demolished (imagine Mc thinking about his relationship with Jill and then after some doubts having sex with Bella).
but I don't agree with you on the reason, we can't say that he does it for fear of losing them both, that can be worth the limit for the post chapter 4.
but as soon as she knows Mc, what fear can she have of losing him? when at that moment it is she who is about to leave both
we can say that Josy behaves sentimentally like MC the manwhore (not all games but many ..), with the aggravating circumstance that Josy believes / believed in a relationship with Maya. but unlike Mc, she always expresses these doubts in words and not in thoughts
Know what bothered me about Josy in the last episode? That interaction she had with the other girl at lunch in front of Maya and the MC showed a lack of character in my mind. When you have your core friends, sometimes you can't just be friends with everyone else. But when this other girl shows up, has no interest in Maya (and like I said is very dismissive of her) and barely even cares about the MC, Josy decides that she's just going to carry on a private conversation with her. That's not how you behave in a social situation. It's one thing to have a short conversation like "hey, there's a party tonight, do you want to come?" but the game gave me the impression that they chatted for an extended period of time. That is both rude to the other two people at the table, and shows a lack of social grace because she thought A) Alright to do, and B) Never noticed that it made Maya uncomfortable.
To me it was a great example of how Josy is sort of a chameleon. I don't think she's a bad person, or that she's shallow, but I don't think Josy has a very strong sense of herself. That's why I called her "generic" earlier, she just seems like this girl who is trying to be one size fits all, and will attach herself to whatever dominant personality is around her at any given time. That attitude of "I'm friends with everyone" strikes me as someone who isn't (deep) friends with anyone in actuality.
here I think you are wrong.
that is a distinctive trait of Josy's personality that is shown and underlined from the beginning. Josy talks to everyone, gives everyone confidence. when she arrives in BR the first day she already becomes friends with Jill, even with Quinn she doesn't show any fear, she responds blow for blow.
let's say it's not a feature that in real life would drive me crazy, but it's consistent with the way the character was presented to us
