I wouldn't call him incorrect, that would be too extreme. Arguing that your interpretation is not an interpretation, and the scene in question is not up for interpretation is moronic at best, trolling at worst. You even accused him of lying because you literally did not like his interpretation dude, chill. This isn't healthy.
You know what Dik and Chick are? They are content! And true fans do not question which one is better or worse, we don't need to... We just consume them like bread and wine at this point!
Facts are never for, up to personal "interpretation". Facts are Facts, period.
Fact is: Troy, from the first moment, hostile, and a legit Asshole toward MC.Just because later we found out he is Gay, its not give him automatically any excuse for his behaviour. So dont even try. So, Troy, is an asshole from day one. MC can decide whether he is passive or active about it. You can either stand up for yourself, and draw the line. or you just let him treat you whatever the way he want, and you just take it.
The later one is the biblical nonsense, the turn your other cheek.
Anyway, The guitar will be stolen. And even in that case, Troy is the asshole, who lash on to MC and push him.
of course , he has a black eye, what give you the impression that he at least didnt give it easy -
But later on this .
at this point MC , - with all that happened, that lead to this point, and now he even get pushed, by the guy who was constantly an Asshole toward him , can decide, that put this asshole to his place. - After all, if you let one person to step at you, everyone will do.
.
or he can walk away. or He can even get his ass beat, which makes it very funny,
. The ultimate beta bitch.
Anyway, that's what happened. He not beating a victim, if he decide, He beat an asshole. all the previous thing lead to him, finally snapping. Even Jill, did not reject Tybalt, nicely. She try that, did not worked, she get Blackmailed until a point where she could just not take it anymore. Technically,
Jill was a Dik.. And it was more effective
.
So after the Facts. Lets play, Dalix's game, The interpretation, conspiracy theory game.
Troy and Chad are lovers. Chad bitching to Troy, that Sage thinking he is cheating, so Him and Troy relationship is in danger, and the top of that A new Freshman, just challenged him, make him look bad in the eyes of his crew. And Yes, even a Chick player, stand up for Sage, that's the Noble thing. So MC, get targeted by the Jocks.
Troy, realized who the Freshman is, and they come out with the plan. Steal his guitar, give it to Sage, that calms her down, and at the same time it teach a lesson to the Freshman. .
But when they arrive, MC is not there, only Troy. Chad need to keep his status, so he punch Troy. which lead to Troy emotional break down, and attack toward MC later.
OR Version B :
Only, Chad, arrive, they ruin the room, and to make it believable, he punch Troy.
Dalix's game Over...
So, See the Difference Now ?
Which one is the Extreme, the interpretation, or the Fact.?! 
