Incorrect. Both Josy and Sage, knew who's dick it was, she goes to the bathrom ,depending how she feel about MC she say different things to Josy, but if you are on her path, and end up with her this will be her reaction in the end of the day.
if you not " ruin " Horseface presentation, you get an alternative scene, that frankly not worth it. This is much better.
in the end of the day Bullying Tybalt, is not a disaster in any shape and form, regarding Jill.
disaster is , if we even can call it that, is to chase both Jill and Bella and pick Bella over Jill.
Fucking Sage and Jade both, extreme disaster if you also show the video of you fucking Jade to the Diks.
regarding Jill, the only fucked up thing is that She looks at the moon, and she feels something is off,
if you have Dik affinity, ironically, while there is an another guy who literally blackmailing her to go on dates with him.
its not make a single fuckign sense, but dpc superior writing wants to lecture the players and punish them for " following their heart "